• Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version.

Books of Doom - The Conclusion (with SPOILERS)

Iron Maiden

Sidekick
Joined
Nov 8, 2004
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
0
Points
31
A Doombot, the return of Boris and yet another prisoner added to Doom's fun little cell block of prisoners at Castle Doom. Thus ends the latest version of Doctor Doom's storied origin. I think Ed Brubaker succeeded in what he set out to do, which is to craft a story that would stick to the basics but at the same time seem fresh to those of us fans who know the story so well or those not so familiar. It loses some of the "fairy tale gone wrong" quality of the Lee/Kirby version but Victor's origin needed to be retold in more contemporary terms.

Also worth noting is the attention Brubaker gives to some of obscure details, like explaining that the story's narrator was the Doombot that ruled Latveria for a time. In retrospect, this makes perfect sense because although it would appeal to Doom's ego to have his biography published there is also that part of him that prefers to zealously guard his privacy. By using the Doombot as a surrogate, he is able to have it both ways. The reporter got her story but nobody else will, except Boris.


The issue begins with the final battle to take the throne and it diverges a bit from the way it was told Doom's solo series in Astonishing Tales. That version showed a bloodless coup where Doom takes the throne with a bit of chicanery, using a robot double of Prince Rodolpho to announce his abdication of the throne to Doom. I think it is more satisfying, and true to Doom's character, to have him killing the King personally in Brubakers enhanced version. King Vladimir's fate is less certain in the older tale. Brubaker has Doom spare the country further bloodshed by using some kind of sorcery to turn the King's soldiers against him. Again, he keeps that element of the older story -- there is only one man that dies in Brubaker's story when Doom finally prevails and that is King Vladmir. I also like how we learn that Doom's well-known cloak belonged to the the dead King Vladimir, a symbol of his final victory that he replaces his more humble version with that of the King.

Sometimes it's the little things that makes a story for me and Brubaker has put enough of those throughout the series to show me that he has read quite a bit of the Good Doctor's many appearances. He adds some specifics of the bargain Doom made to free his Mother's soul that serves to explain the change in the way Latverians have come to regard their sovereign. He is much revered in FF annual #2 but the terms of the bargain took away some of that each year that he lost the battle to free her soul. A fair bargain for a man like Doom, who cares not a whit for what others think of him...it's enough that he knows how magnificent he is :)

I can see where some may roll their eyes and lament the use of a Doombot in this story. The Doombot card got played far too many times over the years but in this case, Brubaker was actually surprised me for once.... and I can usually smell a Doombot fake out a mile away! When the Doombot revealed his visage to the reporter, I briefly thought Brubaker and the artist Pablo Raimondo were trying to convey that Doom had become a cyborg and was purging himself of his human side, literally, by replacing the flesh with machinery.

My favorite part? We finally see Boris again! Now if only Brubaker would retcon Valeria's gruesome fate at the hands of Mark Waid, I mean the Hazaareth demons...
 
I think this was the best comic book i read this year. I was fooled also by the "Darth Vader unmasking" scene :D
The way Brubaker explains and makes the doombot oblivious that Doom succeded in freeing his mother's soul (with Dr Strange) almost help to localize in Doom's timeline the creation of this doombot...
Superb.
 
Iron Maiden said:
Now if only Brubaker would retcon Valeria's gruesome fate at the hands of Mark Waid, I mean the Hazaareth demons...

Really. The single most ruinous thing ever commited upon the character.
That's gonna take some retconning, though...
 
InVictus said:
I think this was the best comic book i read this year. I was fooled also by the "Darth Vader unmasking" scene :D
The way Brubaker explains and makes the doombot oblivious that Doom succeded in freeing his mother's soul (with Dr Strange) almost help to localize in Doom's timeline the creation of this doombot...
Superb.

Yeah, I mentioned that at another MB and it makes sense that this Doombot wouldn't know exactly what the outcome was... this was the Doombot that Doom trashed in Walt Simonson's story in FF#350 where Doom broke up the conflict between the "fake" Doom and Kristoff "the boy who would be Doom" Venard. I think Brubaker must have had that story in mind because in Simonson's story, Doom says something about saving the parts from this model because it functioned at a higher level than the others. The graphic novel that tells the tale of Doom's rescue of his mother's soul was published in 1989 , which I believe puts it sometime after FF#350.

Malus said:
Really. The single most ruinous thing ever commited upon the character.

That's gonna take some retconning, though...

Give the story to Chris Claremont - - maybe he could come up with the Doom equivalent of Xorneto!:D
 
Iron Maiden said:
Brubaker has Doom spare the country further bloodshed by using some kind of sorcery to turn the King's soldiers against him.

Not so. It is clearly explained that the soldiers turned against their King simply because they realized that Doom and his army could not be defeated, and they wanted to survive. When the King said "What witchcraft is this?", it was merely an expression. The army was delivered to Doom by the soldier he set free the night before. "Many among them wish to surrender", remember?

But all in all, probably the best mini I've ever read. Now, let's force the f***tards at Fox studios to read it, so that they may re-start the FF movie franchise properly... ;)
 
I guess you're right. When I first read it, I took that scene to imply that the soldiers were under a spell of some kind but your intrepretation fits better. Unless the soldier sent on ahead spread the spell (which is unlikely). Very impressive that they all knelt in obesiance, without the use of sorcery, when he arrived at the capital.
 
TheSumOfGod said:
Not so. It is clearly explained that the soldiers turned against their King simply because they realized that Doom and his army could not be defeated, and they wanted to survive. When the King said "What witchcraft is this?", it was merely an expression. The army was delivered to Doom by the soldier he set free the night before. "Many among them wish to surrender", remember?

Yeah, that's how i saw it as well; The King's army weren't bewitched, they just preferred to be on the winning side, at that point.

Anyway, i LOVED it! I think this mini series is a wonderful addition to any FF fan's collection. I would totally support a Doom ongoing series by Brubaker. I also wouldnt mind future mini series by him, featuring various other FF rogues (Mole Man, Mad Thinker, The Wizard, etc.,...)
 
Definitly a good read. I thought that Doom was a cyborg when I first saw.
 
CaptainStacy said:
Yeah, that's how i saw it as well; The King's army weren't bewitched, they just preferred to be on the winning side, at that point.

Anyway, i LOVED it! I think this mini series is a wonderful addition to any FF fan's collection. I would totally support a Doom ongoing series by Brubaker. I also wouldnt mind future mini series by him, featuring various other FF rogues (Mole Man, Mad Thinker, The Wizard, etc.,...)



Brubaker is a very hot writer at the moment and deservedly so! A most excellent series and Doom having his own title again would be great to read. Would not mind seeing him get a shot at the regular title someday. Altho most of the work I've read from him is street level down and dirty mystery type stuff, I think he could pull off a title of a more epic scale like FF. A good writer is a good writer and can adapt to his source material. And he has shown in Doom and Cap that he has a love and respect for the history of Marvel's characters.
 
Yeah, i just got into Brubaker's Captain America book...awesome stuff!

Are you reading his Daredevil book? It's incredible!
 
If they make a sequel they should show his first battle with the FF. They should have Brubaker do the past of Namor. On a side note, Can anyone help me find a Doctor Doom AIM buddy icon.
 
CaptainStacy said:
Yeah, i just got into Brubaker's Captain America book...awesome stuff!

Are you reading his Daredevil book? It's incredible!

I wish I had the extra cash to check it out right now. I am hearing only good things about it. But, our finances are finally looking up so hopefully I can spring the xtra cash and pick up on DD's adventures again.
 
I have Books of Doom #1, 2, 3 and 6.

Nice collection huh?:down

I can't find #4 and 5 anywhere. I have to get them off the internet.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"