Cast Mask of the Phantasm

[trustyside-kick]

I was reading in some thread about a guy mentioning MOTP being one of 3 of the best Batman movies. I agreed with him and if this was filmed it would have been probably the best Batman movie.

So who do you think could play the following roles? Who makes the cut and who gets cut?

Cast:
- Andrea Beaumont
- Arthur Reeves
- Carl Beaumont
- Salvatore Valestra
- Detective Bullock
- The Joker

Batman, Alfred, and Commissioner would just be the ones chosen for Begins. Have fun kiddos. I will come up with my own choices for cast when I can.

 

[The Chairman]

Batman / Bruce Wayne - Christian Bale

Alfred Pennyworth - Anthony Hopkins

Jim Gordon - Gary Oldman

The Joker - Paul Bettany

The Phantasm / Andrea Beaumont - Rachel McAdams or Natalie Portman

Arthur Reeves - Jude Law

 

[The Chairman]

Carl Beaumont - Tom Selleck

Detective Harvey Bullock - James Gandolfini, John Goodman or Michael Madsen

Salvatore Valestra - James Caan

Sol and Bronski weren't big characters so they can just go to any random character actors as far as I'm concerned.

 

[trustyside-kick]

Carl Beaumont - Tom Selleck

Detective Harvey Bullock - James Gandolfini, John Goodman or Michael Madsen

Salvatore Valestra - James Caan

Sol and Bronski weren't big characters so they can just go to any random character actors as far as I'm concerned.

I like all of those just unsure about Sal Valestra. Nice though.

 

[The Chairman]

I like all of those just unsure about Sal Valestra. Nice though.

Thanks. I too am not 100 % sure on Caan, either, but for some reason he just entered my mind. I also like that older guy from The Sopranos for the part, Dominic Lucchesse (sp?)

 

[trustyside-kick]

Yea. Oh and I agree with you about Chuckie Sol and Buzz Bronski. They could be played by anyone really since they have such a short appearances. As long as they look super close to em.

I'm going to edit the first post and remove their names.

 

[Two-Face]

Batman/Bruce: Christian Bale
Alfred: Micheal Caine (who else?)
Commissioner Gordon: Gary Oldman
Joker: Adrien Brody
Andrea Beaumont: Rachel McAdams
Det.Harvey Bullock: John Goodman

 

[Eddie Dean]

Batman / Bruce Wayne: Eion Bailey

Alfred Pennyworth: John Hurt

Jim Gordon: Chris Cooper

The Joker: Christopher Eccleston

The Phantasm / Andrea Beaumont: Naomi Watts

Harvey Bullock: Steven Schirripa

 

[trustyside-kick]

Mainly curious about the best candidate for Andrea Beaumont since she plays a huge role in this movie. Keep em coming.

I have been trying to come up with my own cast but having trouble.

 

[The Chairman]

Batman / Bruce Wayne: Eion Bailey

Why not Bale?

 

[Eddie Dean]

Why not Bale?

Just to pick someone else.

 

[The Chairman]

Just to pick someone else.

Ah, I see.

My personal alternate choice would be Billy Crudup, who I want for Iron Man.

 

[trustyside-kick]

Ah, I see.

My personal alternate choice would be Billy Crudup, who I want for Iron Man.

Pic?

 

[The Chairman]

Pic?

 

[trustyside-kick]

ANTHONYNASTI check the TLH Casting thread.

 

[Dr. Fate]

I like the idea of Tom Selleck as Carl Beaumont.

I want Alicia Witt for Andrea Beaumont/Phantasm.

 

[Gamma Warrior]

She's a bit old now though.........

 

[The Chairman]

I like the idea of Tom Selleck as Carl Beaumont.

Good to know.

As a sidenote: does anyone think that Carl Beaumont looks a bit like Bruce from DKR.

ANTHONYNASTI check the TLH Casting thread.

I have. I posted my cast already.

 

[trustyside-kick]

No...I was telling you to check it because I added something about Loeb. To vote for him in the Elimination Game Round.

 

[The Chairman]

No...I was telling you to check it because I added something about Loeb. To vote for him in the Elimination Game Round.

I always hated those elimination rounds. The way it works confuses me.

 

[trustyside-kick]

I always hated those elimination rounds. The way it works confuses me.

Ok well this way is simple. It is down to O'Neil and Loeb...take 1 point away from O'Neil and add to Loeb.

Ex:
O'Neil 127 (-)
Loeb 74 (+)

 

[The Chairman]

Ok well this way is simple. It is down to O'Neil and Loeb...take 1 point away from O'Neil and add to Loeb.

Ex:
O'Neil 127 (-)
Loeb 74 (+)

Like this:

Neil 10 (-)
Loeb 12 (+)

 

[trustyside-kick]

Ok...if you know how then why did you say it confused you.

Vote for Loeb please!!! Most elimination games I do not care as much about. But Loeb is my favorite Batman writer and all. TLH was the greatest.

 

[The Chairman]

Ok...if you know how then why did you say it confused you.

Vote for Loeb please!!! Most elimination games I do not care as much about. But Loeb is my favorite Batman writer and all. TLH was the greatest.

Voted already

 

[trustyside-kick]

Awesome.

But you voted incorrectly. If you want to vote for Loeb then edit your post and type this in.

Denny O'Neil 128 (-)
Jeph Loeb 73 (+)