harlequinade
DayGirl
- Joined
- Jul 19, 2016
- Messages
- 17,066
- Reaction score
- 5,441
- Points
- 103
It's isn't 'sad' or 'depressing'.
It's a realistic interpretation of the survival of 300,000 men, thanks to the bravery of ordinary civilians doing something extraordinary.
It's actually an incredibly uplifting and positive film. I don't know where all this negative stuff is coming from. Yes, it's relentless, but relentless with tremendous catharsis.
I don't know... maybe it's because I'm British, and have more of a connection to the story.
This isn't a film about victory or 'winning', but it sure as hell isn't one long misery-fest about people dying.
All of this. Seriously this film gets hit with some of the most bizarre criticism I ever saw.
It shows such tremendous courage, not just in big actions but in small ones too, there are so many truly wonderful characters whose heroism and desire to help is really wonderful and inspirational.

