Comic Book Movies Best to Worst

[Bat Attack]

^ I did the same thing, these are just my favorites.
Batman
Spider-Man 2
Batman Returns
Spider-Man 3
Superman The Movie
Dick Tracy (1990)
The Crow
X2
Spider-Man
Batman Forever

 

[DX]

Updated list:

1. Batman Begins
2. Spider-Man 3
3. 300
4. Spider-Man
5. Superman the Movie
6. Batman 1989
7. Spider-Man 2
8. Hellboy
9. Superman II
10. Batman Returns
11. The Mask
12. Men In Black
13. Batman Forever
14. Fantastic Four
15. Daredevil
16. Superman Returns
17. Ghost Rider
18. Hulk
19. X-Men 2
20. X-Men
21. Men In Black II
22. Blade Trinity
23. X-Men: The Last Stand
24. Batman and Robin
25. Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer

Superman Returns goes down for me after repeated viewings.

 

[Cyrusbales]

Ok, this is a work in progress list that I threw together.

The bold means they are tied.

Batman
Batman Returns
X-Men 2
Hellboy
Blade
Superman Returns
Spider-Man
Blade 2
X-Men
Superman II
Superman
Sin City
V for Vendetta
Blade Trinity
Daredevil: DC
Spider-Man 2
Constantine
Batman Begins
Batman Forever
Hulk
300
X-Men: The Last Stand
Spider-Man 3
Ghost Rider
Batman and Robin
Fantastic Four
Man-Thing
Superman III
Elektra
Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer
Catwoman
Steel

 

[Cyrusbales]

crap, I forgot loads...

 

[Cyrusbales]

Batman
Batman Returns
X-Men 2
Hellboy
Blade
Superman Returns
The Crow
Men In Black
Spider-Man
Blade 2
Superman II
Superman
Dick Tracy
X-Men
Sin City
V for Vendetta
The Shadow
Blade Trinity
Daredevil: DC
Constantine
Men In Black 2
The Phantom
Spider-Man 2
Batman Begins
Batman Forever
Hulk
300
X-Men: The Last Stand
The Crow 3
The Crow 2
Spider-Man 3
Ghost Rider
Batman and Robin
Fantastic Four
Man-Thing
Superman III
Elektra
The Crow 4
Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer
Catwoman
Steel

 

[AVEITWITHJAMON]

I'm not putting 300 down because it was a historical event before a comic book so i dont count it as a comic book movies, same with AvP.

1) Batman Begins
2) X2
3) Spiderman 2
4) Hulk
5) Superman Returns
6) The Crow
7) Blade II
8) Hellboy
9) V For Vendetta
10) Sin City
11) Spiderman
12) X-Men
13) Blade
14) Batman Returns
15) Spiderman 3
16) Ghost Rider
17) Batman
18) Daredevil: DC
19) The Punisher
20) Men In Black
21) FF: Rise Of The Silver Surfer
22) Fantastic Four EE version
23) Blade: Trinity
24) League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen
25) Spawn
26) X-Men: The Last Stand
27) Elektra

 

[DX]

Bump with an update.


1. Batman Begins
2. Spider-Man 3
3. 300
4. Spider-Man
5. Superman the Movie
6. Batman 1989
7. Spider-Man 2
8. Transformers
9. Hellboy
10. Superman II
11. Batman Returns
12. Hulk
13. The Mask
14. Men In Black
15. Batman Forever
16. Fantastic Four
17. Daredevil
18. Superman Returns
19. Ghost Rider
20. X-Men 2
21. X-Men
22. Men In Black II
23. Blade: Trinity
24. X-Men: The Last Stand
25. Batman and Robin
26. Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer
27: Superman IV: The Quest for Peace

Hulk's grown on me. I'm moving it up.

 

[BingoJesus]

1-Hellboy
2-Batman Begins
3-Spider-Man 2
4-The Crow
5-Batman Returns
6-Hulk
7-Superman Returns
8-X-Men

I could add more, but that'd just be for the sake of it.

 

[co2]

I'm really not going to run down the entire list as that will be too lengthy. I will however list what I think are the best and worst of those that I have seen.

Classics of the genre, could watch 'em anytime
Superman: The Movie
Batman Begins
Spider-man 2
X2
Batman 89
V for vendetta
Akira (had to throw one animated in)

A shame to film and comics both. I'd rather have explosive diarreha than watch
Man-Thing
Superman 3
Batman and Robin
Spawn
Supergirl
Superman 4
League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Everything else falls somewhere in-between

Still stand by this. I'm anxiously awaiting 2008, because with Incredible Hulk, Iron Man, Dark Knight, Watchmen, Wolverine, Punisher: War Zone, Hellboy and Wanted.. something...SOMETHING must break that top list!
If not..all hope will be lost.

Ouch..a horrible thought just occured to me. What if they all break my bottom list!?

 

[toddly6666]

At this point, there are a tons of great superhero/graphic novel movies. A movie rated at number 10 is still probably pretty good at this point. So, I don't think it's fair to rate some higher than others, so I'm going to include ties:

1. X-Men 2 / Spiderman 2 / Batman Begins
2. X-Men / Spiderman
3. V For Vendetta / 300 / Sin City
4. Superman
5. Hellboy (Director's Cut and Theatrical) / Daredevil (Directors' Cut and Theatrical)
6. Superman 2 / Batman Returns
7. Fantastic Four 2 / Blade 2
8. Fantastic Four 1 / Blade 1
9. X-Men 3 / Spiderman 3
10. Hulk / Superman Returns

Although there are some listed below that I can sometimes enjoy watching, every superhero movie after #11 is equally sucky: The Punishers, Blade 3, Batman 3, Batman 4, Superman 3, Superman 4, Elektra, Ghost Rider, Supergirl, League of Ext. Gentlemen, Spawn, etc...

 

[bullets]

elecktra is the worst

 

[BMM]

^ I don't know. I would say Catwoman or Steel is worse.

 

[bullets]

yeah catwomen and steel are too atrocious for me to attempt at watching.

 

[AVEITWITHJAMON]

My latest best to worse is:

1) Batman Begins
2) X2
3) Spiderman 2
4) Hulk
5) Superman Returns
6) The Crow
7) Transformers
8) Blade II
9) Hellboy
10) V For Vendetta
11) Sin City
12) Spiderman
13) X-Men
14) Blade
15) Batman Returns
16) Spiderman 3
17) Batman '89
18) The Punisher '04
19) Ghost Rider
20) Daredevil: DC
21) Constantine
22) Men In Black
23) Darkman
24) Fantastic Four: Rise Of The Silver Surfer
25) Fantastic Four: EE
26) LXG
27) Spawn
28) Elektra
29) X3: The Last Stand
30) Steel

 

[DX]

I forgot Transformers....


1. Batman Begins
2. Spider-Man
3. Spider-Man 3
4. 300
5. Superman: The Movie
6. Batman
7. Spider-Man 2
8. Transformers
9. Hellboy
10. Superman II
11. Batman Returns
12. Hulk
13. The Mask
14. Men In Black
15. Batman Forever
16. Fantastic Four
17. Daredevil
18. Superman Returns
19. Ghost Rider
20. X-Men 2
21. Superman III
22. X-Men
23. Men In Black II
24. Blade: Trinity
25. X-Men: The Last Stand
26. Batman and Robin
27. Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer
28. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace

 

[JClive2007]

Best/good comic movies

1. Spider-Man
2. Spider-man
3. Superman
4. Superman 2
5. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990)
6.Batman (1989)
7.TMNT (2007): fan boy love here
8.Batman Begins
9.Transformers(1986)
10.Blade
11.Blade 2
12. Spider-Man3: the only problem I had was it seemed Venom was rushed and wasted, they tried to balance the stories between Peter dealing with Sandman and his uncle and Peter dealing with the New Goblin.
13. The Crow
14. Sin City
15.Superman Returns
16. X-Men 1-3
Bad to borderline movies:
1. Tank Girl
2. Superman 3
3.Superman 4
4.Batman and Robin: Some of Arnie's lines alone earns Batman and Robin a spot on everyone's worst comic movies
5. The Crow 2
6. The Crow 3
7. Fan.Four: It's not super bad, it's not that really good either it's borderline it had it moments
8.DareDevil

Decent:
1. Batman Forever: had what made the first two classics, but towards the end you see the bad direction the series was heading.
2. The Punisher (sometime in the 80s): hey i saw this when I was 9 and I liked it
3. The Punisher
4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2: SOFO: the guys water down the second movie to shut up groups that thought the first one was too "violent" so I can forgive them for that one

5. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 3: It was like I was watching an live action version of the Archie's comic Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.

 

[Blader5489]

My top 10:

1) Batman Begins
2) Spider-Man 2
3) Spider-Man 3
4) X2: X-Men United
5) X-Men: The Last Stand
6) Spider-Man
7) Batman
8) Sin City
9) X-Men
10) Fantastic Four

 

[DX]

I finally saw Superman IV on Youtube......and it's the new bottom of my list now....