I know what you're saying and I disagree with your assessment completely. There was no perfect balance at all. His Goblin was 90% hammy. That's not the definition of balance. Trying to compare Dafoe's Goblin to someone like Palpatine is as comical as Goblin's dialogue. His dialogue is quoted all these years later is it. Why is that notable. I see people use dialogue from the likes of Arnie's Mr. Freeze, too. Are you going to try and tell me that means it was a good performance? Dialogue is often remembered for the wrong reasons. In these cases because its campy bad. People like to look back and laugh and stupid and silly moments from CBM's. Make memes out of them etc. Stupid can be memorable. Like emo dancing Peter in SM-3 for example.
No lets pretend Molina wasn't hammy. Because he wasn't. One singular moment where he says nothing will stand in our way does not turn his performance into a hammy one. Molina played it straight menacingly for the most part. Yes Raimi's movies are 60's Spider-Man........that manage to for the most part to tread the fine line between camp and theatrical. That's why they were so beloved and successful. When they started to step over that line.....looking at you Spider-Man 3 and all the emo Peter stuff.....they got hauled over the coals for it. Yeah people look back at it now and laugh and make memes over it. But its still bad. Just like people still quote bad campy dialogue from blatantly bad villain performances like Arnie's Freeze.
Now again I don't think Dafoe's Goblin performance was bad, just a bit too hammy. His overall performance is saved by his Norman Osborn scenes. One of the reasons why when he was resurrected for cameos in the sequels it was as Norman. Because that was his best side. We never saw that hammy Goblin persona....or his costume put on anyone again.
I would prepare to be bummed then. I think his performance is going to be much more reigned in, and hopefully more on the menacing side. I look at how they handled Vulture and Mysterio, two villains who could have easily been hammy as hell. But thankfully they were not. Its one of the reasons I am ok with Foxx's Electro coming back. Because he will be as Foxx himself said a badass this time and not that cringe goofball we got in TASM 2.
One of my favorite lines from any comic book movie ever is his last line in this scene as his glider is malfunctioning away
WEEEEE’LLL MEET AGAIN.....SPIDER MANNNNNN!!!”
That still gives me cold nerd chills to this day. Like what an absolutely perfect reading. It literally sounds like what you think an old-school comic bubble line would sound like reading it in your head. So extravagantly villainous, but also with a strong hint of real wickedness.
And finally, up to his very last line. “....Peter...don’t tell Harry.....”. That is read so well. So much internal conflict and confusion can be heard just in that one line. All when he knows it’s about to end for him.
Foxx's Electro was bad because he all ham, to the point where it became stupid. It's a delicate line to balance.
To each his own, but you're very easily chilled if that gave you goosebumps. Its straight up ham. Like what I expect a Saturday morning Road Runner type cartoon villain to say. All that was missing was him shaking his fist as he flew away.
Peter don't tell Harry line was good. Because that was a Norman scene. Unmasked and bringing it down to some real acting.
Dafoe's voice and physicality is what made the Goblin work even in that silly costume. Plus, Sam Raimi is no stranger to making goofy things scary. Evil Dead and Drag Me to Hell are proof positive of that.
Goblin wasn't scary. His voice, his costume, none of it was scary. Not back in 2002 and certainly not now.
Even in the scenes where he's trying to be scary it comes off comical. People's reactions to him made it even more comical. My favorite was Aunt May's "Deliver us......FROM EEEEEEEEEVIL!!!!"
To each his own, but you're very easily chilled if that gave you goosebumps. Its straight up ham.
Spider-Man's been mostly ham through the majority of his existence, it's part of this.
This particular villain's still one of the scariest mofos in the genre for my money. Terrorising elderly women and dropping kids off bridges and one of the most brutal fist-fights in any of these movies in the finale.
You can dial the cheese up to 11 and still be an awesome villain. MasterBoss is right, that whole sequence is comic-flick caviar of the highest order.
What are you even talking about? McKellan's Magneto's dropping hokey one-liners left right and center (not a criticism, he's awesome), and Hiddleston's pretty much split down the middle between Shakespearian family-issue shiz and chewing scenery like a MFer. Go watch Loki in Avengers, he's pretty much as hammy as Goblin ever was.
Again, that's not a bad thing by any means. But he so is.
That remarkable metal doesn't run through your entire body, does it?
A huge bolt of lightning through a copper conductor.
Half of Magneto's lines serve as 'As you know' dialogue for the benefit of the audience. It's quite cheesy.
First line is him tormenting Wolvie. Second line is him making fun of how stupid Cyclops was for saying that.
Mags dialogue is savvy not corny.
I wonder how accurate that poster is. From the leaks we know the suit is far more banged up and has the addition of a belt/chest strap and purpale cloth around his shoulders.