• Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

Entertainment Weekly - 5 Ways to Save Heroes

I agree with every single point.

Whoever decided that Heroes, the entire mythos, is about the Bennett and Petrelli families needs to be slapped multiple times.
 
The things is, other then the online community, that's all the general and casual viewers care about, Peter especially.
 
Clearly not or ratings would not be down by 50 % from its peak performance.
 
Clearly not or ratings would not be down by 50 % from its peak performance.
 
Yes, there's some MAJOR spoilage in the first paragraph or two of that article.
 
I disagree with that article. I think the show lost viewers because 1) Season 2 wasn't all that great... 2) It was a long wait for Season 3 thanks to the writers strike.

In my opinion, Season 3 is the best season yet, and it's only getting better.
 
The things is, other then the online community, that's all the general and casual viewers care about, Peter especially.

Why do you feel this way?
 
I watch Heroes with a very casual crowd. They don't follow the online comics or the online universe like I do, so they don't really know what else there is.

They LOVE LOVE LOVE Peter, they always refer to him as the leader or the most powerful, and always vow how they'll never watch again if Peter ever gets killed. They also adore Noah and Claire and their dynamic. I'm just giving you the small observations I've seen.

Personally I disagree, I wouldn't mind losing Peter or Noah at some point during the series, I just don't think that'll ever happen anytime soon.
 
I disagree with the last way... if anything, they should end dates for CHARACTERS. That way they can get their own endings and the show can continue.
 
I agree with you. I don't think they should choose an ending date for Heroes and then work towards that because this show has the potential for so many different stories and characters throughout the series that it would just be a lot of wasted potential.

The only reason an end dates works for Lost is because, well there has to be some ending. They either all get off the island or they don't. You can't really keep a story like that going, especially with that kind of setup, for too long.

Although Gilligans Island did!! LOL
 
... You guys are right. I take it back on the last one. It really does have that spinoff potential and anthology potential.

I think Peter has a place on the show other than the center of the show. An older future Peter could be an awesome Obi-wan type character...
 
I agree with the article too. Honestly, I'm still having problems getting over how out of character that some of the characters have been written. I pretty much roll my eyes every time Hiro is on screen now due to his over-stupidity in the season premiere. (And I'm still waiting for some dangling plot holes to be cleared up...Caitlin, Nathan getting healed, etc.)
 
I'm still boggled that people actually care about Caitlin. During season two, it was constant "I hate Caitlin get rid of her" "Get her away from Peter!" Then when they finally do, people want to know where she is.

I personally don't really think it's that important to talk about.
 
^ I think Caitlin's served her purpose as far as the story is concerned. She helped Peter get his memory back in Season 2, and that's all that she was needed for. Peter's a little pre-occupied with saving the world right now and probably isn't all that concerned about having a relationship.

As far as Nathan getting healed goes, for me it's either one of two things. 1) God did it... (which I hope it's not) or 2) Peter did it. It was Future Peter who was at Nathan's bedside when he woke up... maybe Future Peter has some powers that we aren't fully aware of yet.
 
I agree with ALL their points.
However they said that Sylar turning into a good guy was a good idea...ermm, no

Anyhow am I the only one who HATES HATES Peter Petrelli? :dry:
He is such a boring predictable charecter, and Milo's acting doesn't help either :o

Eventually they need to get rid of MOST of the charecters. The writers don't have the guts to kill major charecters...they didn't even have the guts to kill Nikki (Yeah, I know its Tracy but they are basically the exact same charecter played by the exact same actress except Tracy is like super duper lame)

And hahaha @ Volume 4..."Volume 4 is going to BLOW YOU AWAY, trust me! Its amazing" :whatever:...yeah, you all said that for Volume 2 (that sucked) and Volume 3 (that sucks so far)...so NOW I'm suppose to take your word, huh?
 
^ No.

As for the person that asked about Nathan, this is straight from the writers themselves:

Andrew and the HMP Crew asked:

“Did/will we ever get a definitive answer as to how Nathan was revived back in the premiere? Theories run from Adam’s blood, to Linderman’s divine intervention, to future Peter doing it by accident using a Linderman like power.”


Nathan believes he was saved by God. We’re sticking with that.

There you go.

Yeah, I know its Tracy but they are basically the exact same charecter played by the exact same actress except Tracy is like super duper lame)

Uh what? They are two completely different personalities. Niki was warm and caring willing to do whatever she could to keep her family safe, Tracy is an, to use the reporter's description, ice queen. Stone cold, willing to put up with any kinds of crap not afraid to embrace the powers, which we're already seeing. And of course, sleeping her way to the top, something Niki would never do. She's going to go dark very soon here.
 
Last edited:
In response to...

1. Kill Maya (now that Elle's gone, she's the hottest regular, but she's just a s***ty character), Mohinder (as semi-interesting as his story is, I'm pretty much done with him), all of the Ali Larters (she should of died with Niki, but the writers have such a hard-on for her, they couldnt let her go), possibly Ando (I like him, but as long as he's alive, Hiro will be kind of a p***y. We need badass Hiro. I suppose Ando or Hiro could always turn to the dark side as seen in the future), and maybe Sylar (what better way to prove himself a hero than sacrificing himself for the greater good). I'm pretty sure that Flint, Knox and Meredith are expendable, as well. A smaller cast will allow for more time to focus on certain characters, like Company Man did back in S1 (which was, for my money, the best episode of Heroes to date).

2. About plot twists, dont stop them, but just make the writers try harder. Lost has legitimately good plot twists, that are well thought out, and seem as though the writers have had them planned for a while. As for Heroes, I doubt that the writers had planned on Sylar being a Petrelli. I doubt they knew that Niki would end up being a triplet that were injected with abilities. Try harder, guys.

3. The blackhole power wasnt a big deal. Get over it, EW. But they have a good point about the change from season one to now. They're focusing a little too much on every single character being involved with the company. It's taken a big chunk out of who those characters were. For instance, Peter doesnt even seem like an actual character anymore (like he was in S1), as much as a walking assortment of abilities. I hope the writers are going somewhere with having his abilities taken away.

4. Agreed 100%. The show has become a bit too formulaic for my tastes. Enough with the future. It was cool season one. It was fresh. Now, its played out. Try something new with volume four and season four and on. Lost got a little tiring with the constant flashbacks, so they changed the format to flashforwards. Now, no one even knows what the format season five will be like, with half of the cast making it off the island, while the other half stays behind. As Heroes is, everyone can pretty much tell the basic arc of each season. Change it up.

5. I'm not sure if it would have an impact on the show itself, but an end date would be fine by me. I really dont want Heroes to get dragged into an eighth or ninth season (*cough*Smallville*cough*) and have it be a shell of the show it used to be.

Heroes can still be saved. It hasnt "jumped the shark," as many tend to say everytime a show has so much as a mediocre episode. It's a tired phrase, and I feel like punching someone in the face a majority of the time I hear it. Heroes is not living up to the potential that S1 had, but it isnt dead by any means. The writers just need to put a little thought into it, and not rely on the same plot points. The show itself would be better for it.
 
Flint, Knox and Meredith are expendable

I wholeheartedly disagree. Meredith has been such a great addition to this season and I absolutely love Jessalyn Gilsig. I love Meredith, Claire, and Sandra together!

I doubt they knew that Niki would end up being a triplet that were injected with abilities. Try harder, guys

Ah, but if you pay attention to Linderman during the season one finale you'll know the seeds were planted way back then. He told D.L. and Niki themselves that he was responsible for their entire life.

He'd been watching them since they time they were born and was behind them getting together. He made that 100% clear.
 
I do agree they need to make the cast smaller, there slowly working on it by killing off Mya and getting rid of Monica and Mitch LOL.
 
I wholeheartedly disagree. Meredith has been such a great addition to this season and I absolutely love Jessalyn Gilsig. I love Meredith, Claire, and Sandra together!

Expendable was the wrong word, sorry. I just meant that, if she does die, it would add a little more depth to Claire. It could make for some good stories. Honestly, though, I like Meredith. There are characters I would like to see go before her, but I just cant see her sticking around for too long.
 
I also wanted to say that I am soo happy they decided to keep Matt instead of killing him off, because he is slowly becoming one of my favorite characters. I've just really really grown to like him a lot over the past two seasons because is story his just great.

Matt is just on a search for that perfect little life that he thought he had before until everything just crumbled underneath him. The dynamic between him and Daphne is just great, I really like them as a couple. It's not rushed, there's really a chemistry building up between them and absolutely LOVED their scenes together in last weeks episode.

Daphne is great too because you know she wants to do that right thing, but there's something Arthur and Pinehearst are holding over her head. You can really see it on her face that she doesn't believe in anything she's doing. Daphne and Brea were great additions this season as well. I hope she sticks around.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"