Extra ending misleading?

[spidoman]

Sorry if anyone has posted this before, but one of my friends pointed it out and I realized holy crap that's possible!

When "Charles" is in the hospital bed, we know that the cure isn't actually permanent, thanks to Magneto. What if it isn't Charles in the bed? What if it was Mystique? Just a thought.

Also, what do you think would happen if Wolverine took the cure? Would his body fight the cure faster, and thus the cure wouldn't work on him, or is that not how the cure works?

 

[Mike059jig]

Good questiong...i really don't know

 

[RaisingStorm]

Why would Mistique got to Muir Island in the first place, second, she is in custody as far as I know. and Woverines healing factor works so long his X Factor still produces X Fluid, The "cure" prevents the X Factor from producing X Factor Fluid which will cause for Logan to loose his healing factor, he would die within minutes due to the toxcicity of the adamantium on his bones.

 

[spidoman]

I'd assume she isn't in custody, make a deal to catch magneto, get released kind of thing. If she was in the hospital bed it would probably be to get close to Moira or something, starting up the plot for number 4.

As for wolverine you kinda missed my point. Would the "X Factor Fluid" fight off and kill/reject the cure before the cure would take effect, personally I say yeah, considering at the end of X3 he was healing SUPER fast.

 

[ico]

It could very well be Mystique in the bed. But I doubt it.

 

[spidoman]

I can see them making an X4, and Patrick Stewart not signing on, and using that idea/excuse to explain his absence.

 

[RaisingStorm]

I'd assume she isn't in custody, make a deal to catch magneto, get released kind of thing. If she was in the hospital bed it would probably be to get close to Moira or something, starting up the plot for number 4.

As for wolverine you kinda missed my point. Would the "X Factor Fluid" fight off and kill/reject the cure before the cure would take effect, personally I say yeah, considering at the end of X3 he was healing SUPER fast.

ok, lets try again. first, Arad said in an interview that Mistique is in custody, they did not say anything about a deal or anything.

The "cure" is more so a genetically enginered virus made of of Leeche's X Factor Fluid, this virus works like the HIV, it goes straight to the mutant DNA and just like HIV prevent the human inmune system from producing White blood cells, the "cure" causes the X Factor to stop producing X Fluid. The Thing about Leeche's X Factor Fluid is that it can neutralize any other X Factor Fluid, thats why when they get close to him, they loose their powers, so with this said, now we know that wolverines healing factor will not work against the "cure" since the "cure" will neutralize it.

 

[Nell2ThaIzzay]

Okay, that might just be the lamest "twist" ever. WHY WOULD MYSTIQUE GO TO MUIR ISLAND AND PRETENT TO BE XAVIER?!

How would she even know about:

A: Muir Island
B: Moira McTaggert

And the million dollar question....

C: THAT XAVIER EVEN DIED?!

It makes absolutley no sense for that to happen.

And the cure is no temporary. Mystique and Rogue were both shown to be remained cured. Magneto wasn't. Therefore, Magneto is too powerful for the cure.

And despite the fact that realistically, if Wolverine were cured, he wouldn't have his healing power anymore, and yes, die, because of the metal on his bones... the writers did say they wrote a scene where he got injected with the cure, but his body rejected it because of his healing factor.

 

[Dope Nose]

And the cure is not temporary. Mystique and Rogue were both shown to be remained cured. Magneto wasn't. Therefore, Magneto is too powerful for the cure.

I think you're making a pretty big leap with that.

 

[Flame on!]

And the cure is no temporary. Mystique and Rogue were both shown to be remained cured. Magneto wasn't. Therefore, Magneto is too powerful for the cure.

I think the bit with Magneto was to show that the cure is temporary. It would've been a bit redundant to show 3 or 4 scenes of the exact same thing happening with the characters.

 

[Nell2ThaIzzay]

I think the bit with Magneto was to show that the cure is temporary. It would've been a bit redundant to show 3 or 4 scenes of the exact same thing happening with the characters.

It would have been, yes...

But when you see 2 scenes of the cure being permanent, and a flat out, bold statement "...way to supress the mutant X-Gene, PERMANENTLY", with no explanation or buildup to it actually being temporary, the cure is permanent.

Magneto is too powerful for it.

 

[spidoman]

Showing Mystique with the dark hair and normal skin doesn't show that the cure is permanent.

Magneto being too powerful for it....I didn't know that people can control their genes. Maybe the cure is metal? :P Although she can't control it, isn't Rogue more powerful than Magneto? So is Magneto the only mutant powerful enough to supress it?

The cure isn't permanent, the scientists were mistaken. How can you tell something is permanent when the kid is only like 10 years old? The cure could only be around for 10 years maximum. Cancer can be in remission for decades and then come back.

 

[TrailerMusic]

Patrick has said in interviews thats him on the bed

 

[8Ball2/JanG5]

It would have been, yes...

But when you see 2 scenes of the cure being permanent, and a flat out, bold statement "...way to supress the mutant X-Gene, PERMANENTLY", with no explanation or buildup to it actually being temporary, the cure is permanent.

Magneto is too powerful for it.

I HATED the ending, but I took it as a way to torture Magneto even more. That a fate worse than having no power at all anymore is still having a tiny bit left and being reduced to only being able to show a figment of that power to others.

 

[Lucky6]

has anyone actually got this clip? i don't wont to start a thread to try and that scene. some girl was closing that cinema(i think anyway) so everyone left and i didn't see the end of that scene. can anyone rip it please? or give me a link? thanks

thanks
Robin

 

[spidoman]

search on youtube for it.

 

[spidoman]

Patrick has said in interviews thats him on the bed

Well of course it's him, but is it him the actor or is it him the character duh duh duh!

 

[Lucky6]

^ i have, i can't find it. ( but there is like 12 pages. i may of missed it) i'll try again tomorrow anyway.

yeh if anyone could give me a link straight to it please that would be good.

thanks
Robin

 

[zer00]

*shakes head*

*walks out*

*blows ****ing brains out*

Must be the same people that thought Beast in Leech's room was mystique too!

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

Lol

 

[thorstone]

are you talking about the guy in the video Charles shows his class? or was there another ending after Magneto's I missed? at what part in the ending did you see a dude in a bed?

and I think the cure is only temporary

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

The cure is temporary. Did u see magneto move the chess piece without touching it? ...

 

[Bana]

If that was Mystique.. just..no. D:

They wouldn't do that..

 

[GoHF]

are you talking about the guy in the video Charles shows his class? or was there another ending after Magneto's I missed? at what part in the ending did you see a dude in a bed?

After the credits. You gotta wait almost 5 minutes for them to roll out, then there's that scene.

Anyway, going by the comics, one of the most logic characters to have been in that position (muir island, in a coma) would have been Legion. In the comics, Legion was in a comma, no sign of his mind anywhere (though he was there, just hidden too deep). Of course, if that WAS Legion and if they make another X movie, I doubt they'd make him Charles son + go into that triple personality issue he had. Still, he was the first character that popped up in my mind.

Lol, really weird would be for Xavier to have been projecting his mind from his commatose body for the past 3 movies :P.

 

[Angamb]

I though about Mystique too, but don't believe it is that way, they want to have Charles again in X2, so hasn't sense, really.

and yes, Logan will die quickly, also he would look too much older.