I'm not 100% sure which was my first. It was either "Krypto", "Witness", or "Aqua".
Either way, I was fascinated by the concept of the show, dug a little deeper into it, and fell in love.
Actually, the better question for me is when (like you) I fell in love with the show.... For me, it wasn't with Visage.
I watched pretty faithfully after seeing the first one I did, but I didn't fall in love with the show until I finally saw the Pilot a year and a half later...
When it came around to my birthday, I had put Smallville season DVD sets on my wishlist. I got the first two that year, 2004, and watched the episodes back to back as much as I could.
I hadn't ever seen the Pilot in its entirety before, I'd only seen parts of it when it came on earlier that year, but when I saw the whole thing I fell in love with the show and with Tom's portrayal of Clark.
That's when I was hooked and that's when I started getting involved with online stuff and, in addition to writing the reviews every week, I even wrote a smallville spec script, which actually did pretty good in some contests about a year or so later.
I'm still in love with the show, even though it does let me down from time to time (the occassional dud like Blue or Static) and I still love Tom's take on Clark, even in the midst of dreck eps where Clark is acting OOC.
:heart: