Superman Returns How Do You Feel About Singer NOW Thread

I feel about Singer what I've felt for quite some time now: While I am neutral about the man himself, I do not want to see him directing another Superman film.
 
I liked that Singer tried to do something different with it. I watched it the other night and it's a great film. But the kid and the plot poses to many problems for a future movie. Part of me can't help but be upset at Singer it's almost like he knew the way it would be after Superman Returns. Its like he's killed Superman for any other director or writter. My husband made a joke about it the other night and said Singer would of said Ha get out of that one! Hearing what he's planned or rumours of what he's planned make me want to shout no do another film then!
 
Baadshah2 said:
no, this one will becaue it's the newest.

Just like Batman BEgins and Tim Burton's Batman

Tim Burton's Batman was good, but you don't see Christopher Nolan praising Burton about this and that and incorporating it into his film
Click to expand...

In fact Christophger Nolan said he liked Burton's Batman and kept the black armoured suit concept, the glider-cape and the gauntlets.
 
Yeah. Even The Dark Knight had an obvious B'89 nod in it. It was the "Come on, hit me!!" scene.
 
I still feel Bryan Singer is one of the best directors out there, he isnt quite on the level of the Cameron's, Jackson's or Spielberg's of this world, but in his generation few are better at directing than Singer for me.

With SR, I still think he gave us an excellent Superman movie, that I personally will be watching for years to come, and I would have loved to see a sequel to.
 
I think Bryan Singer got way over his head with SR. I mean, he was excited to make a Superman, but he made it like a fanboy of the old Donner films. Which is not the way to go when recreating a character. You did realize that, yes we like the Donner film, but we dont' want to repeat the same exact thing in this generation. What is so sad is there were so many scenes in the movie that were incredible, scenes that can only be in a Superman movie, but sadly it was wasted. What is left in another movie??

I'm not saying Singer is the next Schumacher, but it does certainly look like it doesn't. Ever since SR, the Superman character is now in limbo THANKS TO SINGER.
 
Robdixxo said:
Fincher, Nolan... First names that pop into my head... There's probably a ton more. Singer ain't that good. What has he directed that so memorable and great?
Click to expand...

Fincher and Nolan are awesome also. What was it Singer directed that was so great? The Usual Suspects is a classic, and X1 and X2 not only were a big factor in the current comic-book phase, but they are still rated as 2 of the best also.

I thoroughly enjoyed Valkyrie also.
 
They should of done Superman Returns like this.

Have it be its own movie in its own universe not Donnerverse. Its the 21st century that cheesy stuff will not work in this day and age. Also would of had the mvoie be like the Godfather Part 2 were they show flashbacks and present day elements in the film. Show Clark when he was a baby on Krypton, then as a teenager in Smallville then as a young adult traveling around the world, then working at the DP for the first time and becoming SM for the first time aswell.

Meanwhile in the present day, Superman returns to earth after being abscent for 7 years. I would of kept that part of the film. Clark Kent stays in SV for awhile to get back on his feet then go back to Metropolis and work at the DP again. And him and Lois rekindle again. Though I not have her act like a total ***** and have a kid or boyfriend too.

As for Lex Luthor instead of the lame conman routine, I would of had him be the scientists like he was in the earlier comic books who wants to be like Frankenstein. Bascially be a GOD. He wants to have that power. He makes cures though for diseases so the people will be on his side of course so they will not know about his real plans. Also for people crying about Superman not fighting anybody Luthor would make a giant robot with kyrptonite that Superman fights.

Now as for Metropolis, it was an okay city but could of been better. It was not Metropolis. I would of had a mixture of great cities across the world and have a ''timeless'' look and feel to it.
 
I truly have no problem with the man himself. He has shown talent with other films. However..........As far as the Superman francise goes, they should never give him the keys the this car again especially after he crashed it into a brick wall. They are still picking up the pieces for cryin out loud.
 
Fresh Prince said:
Stop it!
Click to expand...

Why would I?

Fresh Prince said:
Its not a cheeseball fest its just light toned.
Click to expand...

Spiderman 3 was a big festival of cheese. And the two first ones had its god dose of the yellow dairy substance. At the very least the Spiderman movies' cheese-level is comparable to that of the Superman movies. I'd say SR cheese-level is quite lower than that of any of the Spiderman's movies.
 
Last edited:
I think Singer took a Huge risk with introducing a Superman's Kid and a moody glum atmosphere, but still, I would rank SR, above Superman The donner Cut, Superman 2, Superman 3, superman 4 not to mention X1, X2, X3. It can be condidered as a worthy sequel to first two Donner movies, and the closure of DonnerVerse.
 
I had faith in Singer during the build up to SR...
I remember over at bluetights.net in one of the threads there the rumour of Superman having a kid was mentioned and I argued that Singer was such a fan he'd never piss on the legend by introducing a kid for Superman... Well he did. Bigtime.
Singer also allowed a costume designer who had no idea what she was doing let the basic colours of Supermans costume wrong.
Singer also called a halt to his leading actors gym workouts because he'd had the bright idea of getting all the superman outfits made BEFORE the actor had started working out.
Singer made the decision to hang his actor from flight harnesses for hours on end before replacing most of the flying shots with sub-standard CGI flight shots.

How do i feel about Singer? I think he's an idiot that had the golden goose but decided to kill it before it even laid an egg.
 
Well, exactly like I felt about Singer years ago:

I loved The Usual Suspects
I haven't seen Apt Pupil
I liked X-Men
I liked X2, even though the direction seemed kind of bland in this one, despite the larger budget
I didn't really like Superman Returns
I thought Valkyrie was okay
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Mentok
Superman Returns *OFFICIAL* Superman Returns Noob question thread.
35 36 37
Replies
917
Views
38K
arty2
arty2
retconned
Superman Returns List of celebrities going to the premiere of Superman Returns
2 3 4
Replies
89
Views
6K
explode7
explode7
SUPERSEBAS
Superman Returns Superman returns the bryan singer cut
Replies
5
Views
5K
Retroman
Retroman
S
Superman Returns Anyone else here think Donner had some actual influence in Superman Returns?
Replies
1
Views
988
Strange
Strange
Showtime
Superman Returns Superman Returns Cast Voicing The Videogame
2
Replies
43
Views
4K
Showtime
Showtime

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)

Staff online

Members online

Total: 3,035 (members: 19, guests: 3,016)

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,269
Messages
22,077,606
Members
45,877
Latest member
dude9876

Share this page

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"