toddly6666
Civilian
- Joined
- Sep 27, 2005
- Messages
- 545
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 11
I finally folded and couldn't wait any longer for the USA NTSC Region 1 DVD releases of the classic 1980s cartoon series - M.A.S.K. - so I finally bought the M.A.S.K. COLLECTION 1 & COLLECTION 2 PAL DVDs from Australia's http://www.ezydvd.com.au/ for about a total of 80 bucks. I usually don't buy DVDs without reading DVD video/audio reviews beforehand, and i've unsuccessfully searched for DVD reviews of these Australian PAL DVDs (even at the biggest M.A.S.K. fansite www.matt-trakker.com, but they didn't really review the DVDs as well), so I finally took a chance and bought them.
As a kid, I religiously watched M.A.S.K., G.I. JOE, and TRANSFORMERS - and M.A.S.K. was always my favorite. I thought it was an awesome show and had the best toys ever. I held onto all of the toys, and ironically, the only toys that my mother gave away while I was at college were my M.A.S.K. toys, of course without my permission. Even in junior high when I stopped playing with toys and put them in the basement, I had told her not to touch them, not give them away, or throw them away, but somehow my M.A.S.K. toys didn't apply and she ended up giving those away. So, now that I'm 30 years old, I wondered if M.A.S.K. is as great as I remembered. Now, I did buy the G.I. JOE and TRANSFORMERS DVDs when they came out, and I was surprised that they aren't that dated and both of those shows are still as entertaining as I remembered. Although many may disagree, the voice acting, storylines, dialogues, and character development are still pretty damn good in the old TRANSFORMERS cartoon (Generation 1) and G.I. JOE - Not bad for a 20-minute toy commercial episode. I was hoping to feel the same with M.A.S.K., but this show is the most dated out of my three favorites, and ranks below TRANSFORMERS and G.I. JOE for me now as an adult. I'm seeing things in this cartoon that I was not aware of as a child:
1. The voice acting is overall pretty terrible. They seem more like youtube cartoon fan dubs than professional actors. For example, the main female baddie, Vanessa Warfield, is voiced by some generic-sounding actress whom is just lowering her voice, as if she is trying to imitate a man's voice. This is what she considers "evil"? No, that's not a character or voice acting, that's just a woman talking with her voice lowered. She ain't no Baronness. Then there's some annoying dude who talks like a redneck. There's an Asian guy who is painfully stereotypical with his annoying Asian proverbs. The leader of the good guys, Matt Trakker, is voiced like a zombified Optimus Prime/Duke with no character or soul. There is some good voice acting of course, but not that much.
2. I have no problem with a cartoon taking place in some Arizona desert (cheaper for animators? or easier to avoid collateral dammage?), but this desert is treated like a typical American suburbs. The main kid in the show, Scott Trakker, is connected to all the people that live in this vast desert, as if it's one happy suburbs. It's just creepy and wierd that he knows every neighbor that is about 50 miles away.
3. The lack of continuity in the M.A.S.K. cartoon (created for syndication benefits) is also a negative. I know it's a toy commercial cartoon, but continuity does create emotions and empathy - there are quite a few touching TRANSFORMERS storylines thanks to continuity and character development. Furthermore, eventhough the show starts with a clean slate after each episode, I felt like I was watching something with continuity and all it shows is some kid, Scott Trakker, constantly getting in danger with the bad guys. The single daddy, Matt Trakker, is like one of the most irresponsible fathers in a cartoon series. Lock the kid up in the house already or give the poor kid one of those powerful masks to defend himself already!
4. The writing of the dialogues, humor, and storyline is pretty horrible. With help from the already poor voice acting, all the characters lack chemistry or have souls. Yes, I know it's just a toy commercial cartoon, but in contrast to G.I. JOE and TRANSFORMERS, the positive or negative chemistry among the characters in G.I. JOE and TRANSFORMERS are pretty damn good and entertaining - those two cartoons have some excellent writing and a variety of creative characters, which I think is pretty underappreciated by 1980s cartoon critics. The majority of the M.A.S.K. characters just seem like they don't give a crap about each other and they are just there for the job. There are a couple bad guys, Sly Rax (Jack Nicholson voice) and Nash Gorey (strong nerd), whom get some juicy lines and interactions, but that's about it. I even think the kid and robot (Scott and T-Bob), whom are considered to be annoying by critics, are really not that annoying and actually have some soul.
5. As a kid, I always looked foward to a cameo by a new M.A.S.K. or Venom agent for kicks. Watching the show now, I still look foward to a cameo by a new M.A.S.K. or Venom agent, because I see now that the main cast of good guys and bad guys are sort of boring. And actually, the cameo characters are more interesting than the main ones. Not a good sign in cartoon writing. In TRANSFORMERS and G.I. JOE, I looked foward to cameo characters as well, but I liked the main cast of both cartoons.
6. And finally, I've come to the conclusion that M.A.S.K. had, and still has, amazing toys. I think that the toys in TRANSFORMERS and G.I. JOE are as equally as enjoyable as the cartoon. But watching M.A.S.K. now, I think that the toys are better than the cartoon.
Mexican M.A.S.K. Agent Julio Lopez or Borat?
So what's left to like about this show you may be wondering? Well, besides the nostalgia factor, it's still a pretty entertaining cartoon. Now that current animation is over-saturated with CGI/computer animation, I do appreciate more hand-drawn animation now. In M.A.S.K., the designs of the characters masks, outfits, and vehicles are still pretty amazing. They even have cool transforming type sounds when the vehicles transform to battle vehicles, which I don't remember as a kid. So that was a pleasant surprise. I love that 1980s hand-drawn cartoon animation where nothing is that smooth or perfect, or dialogue isn't exactly moving with their lips. I think it's charming. The M.A.S.K. theme song played at the beginning of the show and played as different orchestral versions of it during the show is pretty good too - better than that "You've Got the Touch" crap song from TRANSFORMERS. Another new thing I've noticed is that in some scenes the animation is very simple, while other scenes the animation is pretty complex - so I do like how the animated style is slightly a bit different in scenes, and not just consistent. And I do like the fact that it's like a combination of Transformers and G.I. Joe, my two other favorite 80s cartoons.
These are the complete M.A.S.K. series on PAL Australian DVDs released by MADMAN. M.A.S.K. DVD COLLECTION 1 features episodes 1 -38, and has a running time of 950 minutes. M.A.S.K. DVD COLLECTION 2 features episodes 39 - 65, and all ten episodes of the M.A.S.K. Racing Series, and has a running time of 925 minutes. Each box set is spread out onto 4 discs.
The Video is FULL FRAME 4:3. The video quality is pretty good, certainly not pixilated and overall clean. I don't think MADMAN cleaned up the colors as was done by RHINO on the TRANSFORMERS boxsets. The colors could get a boost. It's almost like watching a faded piece of artwork. I don't remember if the cartoon was originally like that, but overall, that's okay. I watched the episodes set to SMART WIDESCREEN (no animation lost) on my 34 inch LCD Sony HDTV. I even took a look at the video while watching it at ZOOM (losing animation) and it's not pixilated. The more zoomed you watch it, the more faded the artwork looks. There's some ghosting, but it's an 80s cartoon that didn't get the works a la TRANSFORMERS DVDs, so overall, it's the best I've seen M.A.S.K. on an HDTV. It obviously looks the best watching it at FULL FRAME, but I like to fill my HDTV, so the choice is yours.
The Audio is English 2.0. Everything sounds pretty clear, certainly not as crisp as I would have liked. It's sometimes a bit muffled (and i'm not talking about when characters have their masks on), but once again, it's acceptable. Unlike blasting the TRANSFORMERS or G.I. JOE DVDs with a surround sound setup, which sounded good with either 5.1, mono or 2.0 audio options, these M.A.S.K. DVDs don't sound that great if you blast the audio. The louder you play these M.A.S.K. DVDs, you will hear more faults with the audio. Subwoofer is pretty non-active as well. If you watch these M.A.S.K. DVDs at a little higher than normal volume, they sound good enough. But it would be nice of course for M.A.S.K. to get a DD 5.1 treatment.
The Extras are only on COLLECTION 2. Small quantity, but good quality - nice toy gallery, profiles of M.A.S.K. agents and Venom agents, and some artwork worth looking at.
No subtitles anywhere on these DVDs.
M.A.S.K. SERIES: 10 as a kid, but 7.5 as an adult
VIDEO QUALITY: 7
AUDIO QUALITY: 6.5
EXTRAS: 3
These are the only English audio DVDs of M.A.S.K., so I'm pretty happy with finally owning them and giving them a look. I hope that the supposed USA/UK M.A.S.K. DVDs will give this series a video/audio treatment boost though.
Overall, It's a great 80s cartoon. The PAL DVDs are worth the cost, cuz there is hours of nostalgia entertainment here! If you want to buy these dvds, don't forget that you need to have a multi-region DVD player to watch these M.A.S.K. DVDs.
As a kid, I religiously watched M.A.S.K., G.I. JOE, and TRANSFORMERS - and M.A.S.K. was always my favorite. I thought it was an awesome show and had the best toys ever. I held onto all of the toys, and ironically, the only toys that my mother gave away while I was at college were my M.A.S.K. toys, of course without my permission. Even in junior high when I stopped playing with toys and put them in the basement, I had told her not to touch them, not give them away, or throw them away, but somehow my M.A.S.K. toys didn't apply and she ended up giving those away. So, now that I'm 30 years old, I wondered if M.A.S.K. is as great as I remembered. Now, I did buy the G.I. JOE and TRANSFORMERS DVDs when they came out, and I was surprised that they aren't that dated and both of those shows are still as entertaining as I remembered. Although many may disagree, the voice acting, storylines, dialogues, and character development are still pretty damn good in the old TRANSFORMERS cartoon (Generation 1) and G.I. JOE - Not bad for a 20-minute toy commercial episode. I was hoping to feel the same with M.A.S.K., but this show is the most dated out of my three favorites, and ranks below TRANSFORMERS and G.I. JOE for me now as an adult. I'm seeing things in this cartoon that I was not aware of as a child:
1. The voice acting is overall pretty terrible. They seem more like youtube cartoon fan dubs than professional actors. For example, the main female baddie, Vanessa Warfield, is voiced by some generic-sounding actress whom is just lowering her voice, as if she is trying to imitate a man's voice. This is what she considers "evil"? No, that's not a character or voice acting, that's just a woman talking with her voice lowered. She ain't no Baronness. Then there's some annoying dude who talks like a redneck. There's an Asian guy who is painfully stereotypical with his annoying Asian proverbs. The leader of the good guys, Matt Trakker, is voiced like a zombified Optimus Prime/Duke with no character or soul. There is some good voice acting of course, but not that much.
2. I have no problem with a cartoon taking place in some Arizona desert (cheaper for animators? or easier to avoid collateral dammage?), but this desert is treated like a typical American suburbs. The main kid in the show, Scott Trakker, is connected to all the people that live in this vast desert, as if it's one happy suburbs. It's just creepy and wierd that he knows every neighbor that is about 50 miles away.
3. The lack of continuity in the M.A.S.K. cartoon (created for syndication benefits) is also a negative. I know it's a toy commercial cartoon, but continuity does create emotions and empathy - there are quite a few touching TRANSFORMERS storylines thanks to continuity and character development. Furthermore, eventhough the show starts with a clean slate after each episode, I felt like I was watching something with continuity and all it shows is some kid, Scott Trakker, constantly getting in danger with the bad guys. The single daddy, Matt Trakker, is like one of the most irresponsible fathers in a cartoon series. Lock the kid up in the house already or give the poor kid one of those powerful masks to defend himself already!
4. The writing of the dialogues, humor, and storyline is pretty horrible. With help from the already poor voice acting, all the characters lack chemistry or have souls. Yes, I know it's just a toy commercial cartoon, but in contrast to G.I. JOE and TRANSFORMERS, the positive or negative chemistry among the characters in G.I. JOE and TRANSFORMERS are pretty damn good and entertaining - those two cartoons have some excellent writing and a variety of creative characters, which I think is pretty underappreciated by 1980s cartoon critics. The majority of the M.A.S.K. characters just seem like they don't give a crap about each other and they are just there for the job. There are a couple bad guys, Sly Rax (Jack Nicholson voice) and Nash Gorey (strong nerd), whom get some juicy lines and interactions, but that's about it. I even think the kid and robot (Scott and T-Bob), whom are considered to be annoying by critics, are really not that annoying and actually have some soul.
5. As a kid, I always looked foward to a cameo by a new M.A.S.K. or Venom agent for kicks. Watching the show now, I still look foward to a cameo by a new M.A.S.K. or Venom agent, because I see now that the main cast of good guys and bad guys are sort of boring. And actually, the cameo characters are more interesting than the main ones. Not a good sign in cartoon writing. In TRANSFORMERS and G.I. JOE, I looked foward to cameo characters as well, but I liked the main cast of both cartoons.
6. And finally, I've come to the conclusion that M.A.S.K. had, and still has, amazing toys. I think that the toys in TRANSFORMERS and G.I. JOE are as equally as enjoyable as the cartoon. But watching M.A.S.K. now, I think that the toys are better than the cartoon.
Mexican M.A.S.K. Agent Julio Lopez or Borat?
So what's left to like about this show you may be wondering? Well, besides the nostalgia factor, it's still a pretty entertaining cartoon. Now that current animation is over-saturated with CGI/computer animation, I do appreciate more hand-drawn animation now. In M.A.S.K., the designs of the characters masks, outfits, and vehicles are still pretty amazing. They even have cool transforming type sounds when the vehicles transform to battle vehicles, which I don't remember as a kid. So that was a pleasant surprise. I love that 1980s hand-drawn cartoon animation where nothing is that smooth or perfect, or dialogue isn't exactly moving with their lips. I think it's charming. The M.A.S.K. theme song played at the beginning of the show and played as different orchestral versions of it during the show is pretty good too - better than that "You've Got the Touch" crap song from TRANSFORMERS. Another new thing I've noticed is that in some scenes the animation is very simple, while other scenes the animation is pretty complex - so I do like how the animated style is slightly a bit different in scenes, and not just consistent. And I do like the fact that it's like a combination of Transformers and G.I. Joe, my two other favorite 80s cartoons.
These are the complete M.A.S.K. series on PAL Australian DVDs released by MADMAN. M.A.S.K. DVD COLLECTION 1 features episodes 1 -38, and has a running time of 950 minutes. M.A.S.K. DVD COLLECTION 2 features episodes 39 - 65, and all ten episodes of the M.A.S.K. Racing Series, and has a running time of 925 minutes. Each box set is spread out onto 4 discs.
The Video is FULL FRAME 4:3. The video quality is pretty good, certainly not pixilated and overall clean. I don't think MADMAN cleaned up the colors as was done by RHINO on the TRANSFORMERS boxsets. The colors could get a boost. It's almost like watching a faded piece of artwork. I don't remember if the cartoon was originally like that, but overall, that's okay. I watched the episodes set to SMART WIDESCREEN (no animation lost) on my 34 inch LCD Sony HDTV. I even took a look at the video while watching it at ZOOM (losing animation) and it's not pixilated. The more zoomed you watch it, the more faded the artwork looks. There's some ghosting, but it's an 80s cartoon that didn't get the works a la TRANSFORMERS DVDs, so overall, it's the best I've seen M.A.S.K. on an HDTV. It obviously looks the best watching it at FULL FRAME, but I like to fill my HDTV, so the choice is yours.
The Audio is English 2.0. Everything sounds pretty clear, certainly not as crisp as I would have liked. It's sometimes a bit muffled (and i'm not talking about when characters have their masks on), but once again, it's acceptable. Unlike blasting the TRANSFORMERS or G.I. JOE DVDs with a surround sound setup, which sounded good with either 5.1, mono or 2.0 audio options, these M.A.S.K. DVDs don't sound that great if you blast the audio. The louder you play these M.A.S.K. DVDs, you will hear more faults with the audio. Subwoofer is pretty non-active as well. If you watch these M.A.S.K. DVDs at a little higher than normal volume, they sound good enough. But it would be nice of course for M.A.S.K. to get a DD 5.1 treatment.
The Extras are only on COLLECTION 2. Small quantity, but good quality - nice toy gallery, profiles of M.A.S.K. agents and Venom agents, and some artwork worth looking at.
No subtitles anywhere on these DVDs.
M.A.S.K. SERIES: 10 as a kid, but 7.5 as an adult
VIDEO QUALITY: 7
AUDIO QUALITY: 6.5
EXTRAS: 3
These are the only English audio DVDs of M.A.S.K., so I'm pretty happy with finally owning them and giving them a look. I hope that the supposed USA/UK M.A.S.K. DVDs will give this series a video/audio treatment boost though.
Overall, It's a great 80s cartoon. The PAL DVDs are worth the cost, cuz there is hours of nostalgia entertainment here! If you want to buy these dvds, don't forget that you need to have a multi-region DVD player to watch these M.A.S.K. DVDs.
