Fantasy Netflix's The Witcher - General Discussion Thread

[Loden Greatstorm]

Rough in execution, but I like the vibe of it:

I dont.

 

[OutOfBoose]

I dont.

Of course not.

I wonder how much **** the show will get for not being/looking like the games.

 

[TheVileOne]

I don't expect tons of beasts and monsters in the show. Monsters are not as abundant in the books as they are in the games. But when they are there, I want them to look good. At least better than Lockjaw on Inhumans.

 

[Iceman]

Wonder which monsters they'll go for. I'd expect one quite early to help set the scene.

 

[OutOfBoose]

Wonder which monsters they'll go for. I'd expect one quite early to help set the scene.

The second book starts with a very nice introductory story. Geralt is hired to deal with a striga. It has everything to introduce the world and the protagonist. Some people speculate, based on Renfri casting, I believe, that the first episode will be based on The Lesser Evil, where Geralt reaches Blaviken with a kikimora carcass in tow. There are no beasts. But he earns his infamous title there. I doubt they will start with the golden dragon story, like The Sword of Destiny book.

 

[Iceman]

The second book starts with a very nice introductory story. Geralt is hired to deal with a striga. It has everything to introduce the world and the protagonist. Some people speculate, based on Renfri casting, I believe, that the first episode will be based on The Lesser Evil, where Geralt reaches Blaviken with a kikimora carcass in tow. There are no beasts. But he earns his infamous title there. I doubt they will start with the golden dragon story, like The Sword of Destiny book.

A striga would be a great way to start and set the tone. Is this going to have an R rating?

 

[Punisher_MAX]

I cant imagine why this would be toned down.

As fo Triss, she is mentioned in the first two books when talking about the Battle of Sodden but if they are skipping some stories, which would be a huge mistake because I think the short stories are amazing and a great introduction into the world of The Witcher, they could do some of "Blood of Elves" in the first season.

 

[OutOfBoose]

A striga would be a great way to start and set the tone. Is this going to have an R rating?

I don't know for sure, but I can't imagine it not being R-rated. I think Recapped "confirmed" a nudity scene involving Renfri. And even outside of that The Witcher is full of heavy subjects.

 

[Iceman]

I don't know for sure, but I can't imagine it not being R-rated. I think Recapped "confirmed" a nudity scene involving Renfri. And even outside of that The Witcher is full of heavy subjects.

Would only really make sense if it did but I didn't know if it had been previously confirmed. Just thinking of a Striga scene made me think it would have to be R to do that justice. Also Game of Thrones deals with plenty of heavy subjects and still manages to be a super-popular show so I see no reason for them not to.

 

[Iceman]

I cant imagine why this would be toned down.

As fo Triss, she is mentioned in the first two books when talking about the Battle of Sodden but if they are skipping some stories, which would be a huge mistake because I think the short stories are amazing and a great introduction into the world of The Witcher, they could do some of "Blood of Elves" in the first season.

Sounds good. Also I hope they are playing the long game here, so no reason to skip stuff. If it catches on they could have something that lasts for many years allowing for (and requiring) a lot of material.

 

[OutOfBoose]

Would only really make sense if it did but I didn't know if it had been previously confirmed. Just thinking of a Striga scene made me think it would have to be R to do that justice. Also Game of Thrones deals with plenty of heavy subjects and still manages to be a super-popular show so I see no reason for them not to.

Yeah, TV series viewership is much less dependent on age restriction. It's probably quite opposite when it comes to adult shows.

 

[Iceman]

Yeah, TV series viewership is much less dependent on age restriction. It's probably quite opposite when it comes to adult shows.

Seems that way. Any idea why?

 

[OutOfBoose]

Seems that way. Any idea why?

Ugh, it's a complex topic. Probably worth a separate discussion.

 

[TheVileOne]

If the Recapped rumors are any indication, the show will likely be TV-MA and will have sex and nudity.

 

[KillerMcQueen]

The second book starts with a very nice introductory story. Geralt is hired to deal with a striga. It has everything to introduce the world and the protagonist. Some people speculate, based on Renfri casting, I believe, that the first episode will be based on The Lesser Evil, where Geralt reaches Blaviken with a kikimora carcass in tow. There are no beasts. But he earns his infamous title there. I doubt they will start with the golden dragon story, like The Sword of Destiny book.

The Striga would be the perfect story to start the show with. They'd be wise to lead with the short stories, they'd work incredibly well for a tv series format and do a great job slowly introducing you to the world before Geralt takes Ciri under his wing and the overarching story takes over.

 

[Iceman]

Ugh, it's a complex topic. Probably worth a separate discussion.

Ah gotya, no probs. A discussion for another day then.

 

[Iceman]

The Striga would be the perfect story to start the show with. They'd be wise to lead with the short stories, they'd work incredibly well for a tv series format and do a great job slowly introducing you to the world before Geralt takes Ciri under his wing and the overarching story takes over.

This sounds like the best way to approach it.

 

[Loden Greatstorm]

Seems like filming haste begun yet after all.

 

[Loki882]

The show ẃill also on Netflix, which would also give them more freedom in terms of content. Also if they want this to be their GOT essentially, then I doubt that they'll skimp out on the more "adult" content from the books. Plus Recapped.com (who have a pretty good track record overall) claim that there's Yennifer nude/sex scenes in the script as well.

 

[TheVileOne]

That means we're going to have lots of articles about consent, toxic masculinity, #MeToo, and all that once Witcher TV comes around. Buckle up everyone

 

[Loki882]

As someone who is not at all ashamed of the "SJW" label, my issue with GOT at times is less the content and more the execution. So if this show can avoîd that as much as possible, then it's all good imo.

 

[OutOfBoose]

That means we're going to have lots of articles about consent, toxic masculinity, #MeToo, and all that once Witcher TV comes around. Buckle up everyone

Toxic masculinity and Geralt being Yennefer's dog don't compute. Witcher is packed with strong-minded and aggressive wahmen. Plus it's run by a female...

As someone who is not at all ashamed of the "SJW" label, my issue with GOT at times is less the content and more the execution. So if this show can avoîd that as much as possible, then it's all good imo.

Gotta admit that erotic material in GoT is repulsing or cringy 99% of the time. It's not easy to do it right. I seriously hope The Witcher manages.

 

[Loki882]

Yeah Yennifer, Triss, and Ciri are only the beginning of the badassery really.

 

[Iceman]

Yeah Yennifer, Triss, and Ciri are only the beginning of the badassery really.

So many strong female characters for this show to take advantage of.

 

[Lilbaz]

Why are so many people repulsed by showing sex on tv but have no problem with violence? Really think there is something wrong with that. Or is it that they get embarrassed for being aroused when watching with their better half?