Offical Nip Tuck Thread

[The Shape]

All I know is that Sean better be dead. Don't get me wrong, I love the guy, but if he survives that it's unrealistic. Every one of the main characters always gets hurt and they never die. Julia is poisoned for weeks, then shot in the head. She lived. Christian and Sean's daughter get in a car accident. They're fine, of course. Just a few scrapes and a broken arm for Christian.

Aside from those two examples, they've all been in death-defying situations throughout the years a ton of times. Sean must be dead after this one.

 

[omid17]

All I know is that Sean better be dead. Don't get me wrong, I love the guy, but if he survives that it's unrealistic. Every one of the main characters always gets hurt and they never die. Julia is poisoned for weeks, then shot in the head. She lived. Christian and Sean's daughter get in a car accident. They're fine, of course. Just a few scrapes and a broken arm for Christian.

Aside from those two examples, they've all been in death-defying situations throughout the years a ton of times. Sean must be dead after this one.

he won't die, don't forget Christian was still there

 

[0neDisturbedSOB]

Sean's not going to die. At least not right away. It depends on how many months/years removed season 6 is from season 5. I could seriously see them doing an angle where he's a parapalegic or something like that.

 

[The Shape]

Sean's not going to die. At least not right away. It depends on how many months/years removed season 6 is from season 5. I could seriously see them doing an angle where he's a parapalegic or something like that.

I'd rather not have them go that route. Maybe the show picks up six months later. Sean's dead and we see how everyone is coping and what not, but a parapalegic plot would just drag on and get old.

 

[M.O.Steel]

Yeah, a mistake.

"You poisoned me for weeks and then put a bullet in my head at near-point blank range, but I know you didn't really mean to hurt me."

A mistake doesn't have to be sudden, or out of passion. matt joining scientology, mistake, matt marrying kim, mistake, christian and julia, a mistake.

i'm not saying julia's buying it, but she probably will keep hush for the sake of ollie, NOT eden. They made a point of emphasizing that eden told ollie something, probably confessing, and then the next scene you have her sitting next to julia, and she conveniently has amnesia...come on...something fishy is going on here...

 

[omid17]

I'd rather not have them go that route. Maybe the show picks up six months later. Sean's dead and we see how everyone is coping and what not, but a parapalegic plot would just drag on and get old.

well if they did kill off Sean, than all the stuff he said to Julia, and him wanting to by house in Hollywood Hills, would be have been pointless imo

 

[The Shape]

well if they did kill off Sean, than all the stuff he said to Julia, and him wanting to by house in Hollywood Hills, would be have been pointless imo

You mean when she woke up from the coma?

All that stuff will be pointless anyway as soon as Julia gets her memory back. He only said it show us (the audience) that he still loves her.

 

[M.O.Steel]

Sean and Christian will NOT die. Everyone around them will die before those two will die. the show revolves around those two. you can't just kill the main character, and expect the show to go on? that doesn't even make sense. so no, i bet sean will return. the only time i see one of those two dying is if it's the very last episode of the whole series. Thats how i knew christian didn't die at the end of the second season, and that's how i know now that sean isn't going to die.

 

[omid17]

You mean when she woke up from the coma?

All that stuff will be pointless anyway as soon as Julia gets her memory back. He only said it show us (the audience) that he still loves her.

well how weird would it be if julia found out her husband just died a day a two later, after she woke up?

 

[omid17]

Sean and Christian will NOT die. Everyone around them will die before those two will die. the show revolves around those two. you can't just kill the main character, and expect the show to go on? that doesn't even make sense. so no, i bet sean will return. the only time i see one of those two dying is if it's the very last episode of the whole series. Thats how i knew christian didn't die at the end of the second season, and that's how i know now that sean isn't going to die.

thank you

 

[The Shape]

well how weird would it be if julia found out her husband just died a day a two later, after she woke up?

That would be ****ed up, just like everything else that happens on this show.

 

[omid17]

That would be ****ed up, just like everything else that happens on this show.

but killing off a main character is going a bit too far imo

 

[The Shape]

Sean and Christian will NOT die. Everyone around them will die before those two will die. the show revolves around those two. you can't just kill the main character, and expect the show to go on? that doesn't even make sense. so no, i bet sean will return. the only time i see one of those two dying is if it's the very last episode of the whole series. Thats how i knew christian didn't die at the end of the second season, and that's how i know now that sean isn't going to die.

That's how I always pictured it, as well, but then Sean got stabbed, and it looked bad. He wasn't just stabbed once, fell to his knees, and then the show faded to black. He was stabbed multiple times. Blood from his back was spreading out all across the floor, and his mouth was spewing blood.

If they come back next season and he's in a hospital bed recovering, that's just lame IMO. Well, first of all, I think it was a bad idea to have her stab Sean anyway. Why not stab someone close to Sean? It would have been better if she went into the hospital and killed Julia for good or something, because that would have hurt Sean the most. My question to the writers of this show is this: What good comes of stabbing Sean? If he dies, then what? If he lives, then what? It doesn't seem like they have anywhere interesting to go.

 

[M.O.Steel]

That's how I always pictured it, as well, but then Sean got stabbed, and it looked bad. He wasn't just stabbed once, fell to his knees, and then the show faded to black. He was stabbed multiple times. Blood from his back was spreading out all across the floor, and his mouth was spewing blood.

If they come back next season and he's in a hospital bed recovering, that's just lame IMO. Well, first of all, I think it was a bad idea to have her stab Sean anyway. Why not stab someone close to Sean? It would have been better if she went into the hospital and killed Julia for good or something, because that would have hurt Sean the most. My question to the writers of this show is this: What good comes of stabbing Sean? If he dies, then what? If he lives, then what? It doesn't seem like they have anywhere interesting to go.

I agree with you 100%, on every account, first and second. But i highly highly doubt that Sean will die, no matter how lame it sounds (and yes, it sounds very lame), but this is just from non-story perspective, as an audience member.

Spoiler

(example: last week on smallville, lex got shot square in the fore head, between the eyes, and he survived. but i knew they weren't going to kill him off. It will be interesting to see how much they will stretch to bring him back)

 

[omid17]

That's how I always pictured it, as well, but then Sean got stabbed, and it looked bad. He wasn't just stabbed once, fell to his knees, and then the show faded to black. He was stabbed multiple times. Blood from his back was spreading out all across the floor, and his mouth was spewing blood.

If they come back next season and he's in a hospital bed recovering, that's just lame IMO. Well, first of all, I think it was a bad idea to have her stab Sean anyway. Why not stab someone close to Sean? It would have been better if she went into the hospital and killed Julia for good or something, because that would have hurt Sean the most. My question to the writers of this show is this: What good comes of stabbing Sean? If he dies, then what? If he lives, then what? It doesn't seem like they have anywhere interesting to go.

do you watch the show? she was obsessed with Sean

 

[M.O.Steel]

but killing off a main character is going a bit too far imo

and it's not just A main character, but THE main character.

 

[omid17]

I agree with you 100%, on every account, first and second. But i highly highly doubt that Sean will die, no matter how lame it sounds (and yes, it sounds very lame), but this is just from non-story perspective, as an audience member.

Spoiler

(example: last week on smallville, lex got shot square in the fore head, between the eyes, and he survived. but i knew they weren't going to kill him off. It will be interesting to see how much they will stretch to bring him back)

lol please don't compare that with nip/tuck

 

[M.O.Steel]

lol please don't compare that with nip/tuck

not comparing the show...i'm saying that no matter how obvious the death looked, they will not kill off a main character.

 

[omid17]

and it's not just A main character, but THE main character.

and another thing is that the show has already proven that sean and christian can't be apart from each other

 

[omid17]

not comparing the show...i'm saying that no matter how obvious the death looked, they will not kill off a main character.

agreed

 

[The Joker]

Sean's not going anywhere. He'll survive just as sure as Julia survived a bullet to the head.

Eden and Colleen are two of the best villains of the series. Especially that Colleen. My god, she is so screwed up. I really want to see her get what's coming to her.

Julia's amnesia was such a lame cop out. Talk about unimaginative writing.

 

[omid17]

Sean's not going anywhere. He'll survive just as sure as Julia survived a bullet to the head.

Eden and Colleen are two of the best villains of the series. Especially that Colleen. My god, she is so screwed up. I really want to see her get what's coming to her.

Julia's amnesia was such a lame cop out. Talk about unimaginative writing.

agreed

 

[M.O.Steel]

Sean's not going anywhere. He'll survive just as sure as Julia survived a bullet to the head.

Eden and Colleen are two of the best villains of the series. Especially that Colleen. My god, she is so screwed up. I really want to see her get what's coming to her.

Julia's amnesia was such a lame cop out. Talk about unimaginative writing.

I don't really like colleen. She seems a little too over the top. Eden's a good villian.

I honestly think there's more to it that just amnesia. I think they still have time to redeem themselves.

 

[Golgo-13]

I'm still wondering what Eden told Olivia exactly, upon finding out that Julia was awake. Then Olivia had an evil/odd look on her face when telling Sean and co that Julia had amnesia.

I'm suprised that Olivia also didn't also follow up with asking about the results of the fruitcake, as wasn't it her that recommended using those doctors that came up with the Mercury results, in the first place?

 

[Golgo-13]

so who enjoyed watching Christian bang that chick, lol?

The chick with no legs? Classic Nip/Tuck!