Superman Returns Official Rate and Review Superman Returns thread!!!

[Mr. Credible]

heh... who're the 5 helmuts who gave this a '1'?

house of the dead and bloodrayne hardly deserve a '1'... '1.5' maybe, but not a '1'.

 

[SolidSnakeMGS]

Ok....bet...Moriarty. Positive or negative?

I'll say negative. Maybe he wants to stand firm on his appraisal of the script. If it was positive, I think we'd already have read it by now. He took his time analyzing every single thing wrong with the film, and then providing his own version of what should have been done.

But hey, I hope I'm wrong!

 

[Kane]

heh... who're the 5 helmuts who gave this a '1'?

house of the dead and bloodrayne hardly deserve a '1'... '1.5' maybe, but not a '1'.

Just click view poll results, the names of the offenders are listed

 

[DvilDog]

that sucks

when does superman say "i'm always around."

and when is the fist scene flying up into the sun.

twice.

Spoiler

after he sees her on the roof of the daily planet. and at the end of the movie.

 

[SolidSnakeMGS]

So far, it's:

JBElliott, Jim Lee, NateGray, rondroid, Spider-jedi

They're haters who are wasting their and our time on this board.

 

[DvilDog]

Great to know, especially coming from you who was a fan of the other interpretations, it means alot.

How was the audience's reaction to the film? And to the revelation of Jason being Supe's son....since it was quite a bold move...

Well of course i started clapping like a fool at the end. Everyone followed suit. not really sure about the crowd. but the people around me the ones i could hear seemed to have no problem with.

Spoiler

especially with the scene at the end. That was beautiful. Routh put a tear in my eye for that one. matter of fact its ur sig

 

[Kane]

Wow he says that? Amazing!

 

[DvilDog]

yes he says a little more but i will let you see it when you watch here in a couple days. You wont be disappointed i promise that. You may not like it as much as me. But i think you will really enjoy it.

 

[user123456789]

twice.

Spoiler

after he sees her on the roof of the daily planet. and at the end of the movie.

wait he does what twice?? could u be more specific please? thanks in advance.

 

[Kane]

yes he says a little more but i will let you see it when you watch here in a couple days. You wont be disappointed i promise that. You may not like it as much as me. But i think you will really enjoy it.

Well to be honest. I havent liked ANY of the live action versions of the Superman mythos before.

Though the first film was OKAY. The other 3 were a mess. I think Smallville is garbage and Lois and Clark wasnt my thing.

But, I honestly believe SR has the potential to change all that, to finally do Superman right on the silver screen.

So, I'm looking forward to it....maybe more than you were

 

[Cmill216]

Someone posted this over at IMDB, Jeffrey Lyons and Alison Bailes of Real Talk review SR.

http://www.yousendit.com/transfer.p...key=a32353afa8b40f33ee519d99369139a762151c44/

Alison Bailes..... *drools*

 

[DvilDog]

wait he does what twice?? could u be more specific please? thanks in advance.

Spoiler

im always around

 

[DvilDog]

Well to be honest. I havent liked ANY of the live action versions of the Superman mythos before.

Though the first film was OKAY. The other 3 were a mess. I think Smallville is garbage and Lois and Clark wasnt my thing.

But, I honestly believe SR has the potential to change all that, to finally do Superman right on the silver screen.

So, I'm looking forward to it....maybe more than you were

Maybe so. Hope you enjoy!!!

 

[user123456789]

Spoiler

im always around

awesome

 

[user123456789]

Also how many times does Supes use each of his powers?

 

[J.Howlett]

Another great review if anyone wants to read....

http://www.movieweb.com/movies/film/82/482/review5017.php

 

[Nivek]

Ok....bet...Moriarty. Positive or negative?

I'll say negative. Maybe he wants to stand firm on his appraisal of the script. If it was positive, I think we'd already have read it by now. He took his time analyzing every single thing wrong with the film, and then providing his own version of what should have been done.

But hey, I hope I'm wrong!

Agreed, I doubt he would have "flip-flopped", and he already put up a review of Pirates. Guess what? *Gush*

 

[J.Howlett]

Who knows what he'll post...but it doesn't matter anyway. I'm sure he enjoyed it but had a few problems with it.

Our opinion is just as valid as his.

 

[Mr. Credible]

Ok....bet...Moriarty. Positive or negative?

I'll say negative. Maybe he wants to stand firm on his appraisal of the script. If it was positive, I think we'd already have read it by now. He took his time analyzing every single thing wrong with the film, and then providing his own version of what should have been done.

But hey, I hope I'm wrong!

sadly, i can all but guarantee that you're right. oh well, 98% of people that visit aicn know what a 'rag' it is.

 

[Nivek]

I was just a bit put off by the Timing of the older script review he put up.

 

[DvilDog]

Also how many times does Supes use each of his powers?

man thats tough one. How about this. He uses all of them a lot the super breath and heat vision less than the others.

 

[Kane]

Is Ben Hubbard even seen in the film?

 

[Supermanila]

A B+ review here... http://www.moviereviews.cc/

 

[DvilDog]

drivin off in the truch before clark lands. and i think half of his face at the hospital

 

[Supermanila]

Ok....bet...Moriarty. Positive or negative?

I'll say negative. Maybe he wants to stand firm on his appraisal of the script. If it was positive, I think we'd already have read it by now. He took his time analyzing every single thing wrong with the film, and then providing his own version of what should have been done.

But hey, I hope I'm wrong!

he called Superman Returns a "little indie film"... I wonder what it hints to?