Okay-fan or detractor?

[Chris Wallace]

Which are you? or ?
And let's try to keep this civil; we've got enough bashing & flaming on the other threads.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

... dude...there are threads like this. why did u make an other one?

aanyway... I liked it.

 

[Super Flight]

i was disapointed... just dissapointed

 

[Nathan]

I bashed it enough, so I'll give it a simple

 

[taintedFB]

OKay, I voted yes because there was more good than bad in this movie.

THE BAD - CYCLOPS' ABSENCE/DEATH/LACK OF MOURNING and DIALOGUE (BAD)

THE GOOD - OVERALL STORY, ACTING, BEAST, ANGEL, ACTION, EFFECTS, DRAMA, STORM, ICED UP ICEMAN...

So in the end, I do like it and I think Scott can be brought back in the future, so the negative can be undone.... if we make our voices heard!

 

[Chris Wallace]

Your Avi Seems To Be Switching From Glasses To Visor.

 

[DarknessOfDeath]

yeah...thats so cool, tainted.

 

[blind_fury]

It was fun to watch.

unlike X-men, which was painful to watch.

 

[PowersOfMind]

I loved it.

 

[BMM]

Hmmm . . . just an okay-fan or a dectractor . . . neither one of those are really inspiring choices, although they seem appropriate.

 

[Chris Wallace]

"Okay" & "fan" are meant to be 2 separate words.

 

[BMM]

Haha. I see. Don't we have a few of these threads floating around already?

 

[demitri_vampiro]

I deffinitely liked this one. best of the three.too bad fox didn't give ratner the extra time he asked. It would have been even better.

 

[OptimusPrimeRib]

I voted "fan" and really enjoyed the movie. Sure there were things that I would have liked to have happened differently, but as it's been stated a million times over, this is an adaption not a translation. Things can't be just like they were in the comics, not if you want these movies to have mass appeal anyway.

 

[Nell2ThaIzzay]

Yes, I enjoyed it.

Unfortunatley, unlike the other 2 films which I thought were perfectly done, I think this movie could have been more.

It was still an amazing film, better than the first, and on par with the 2nd in certain areas. But this movie was held back by studio politics. The movie would have been 100x better with Cyclops involved the whole way.

It would have been 10x better with Angel joining the team, and not just randomly appearing at Alcatraz.

It would have been 58392785093928304759023091278949854x better if Gambit was in it like he was promised to be the 2 years between X2 and the start of production.

And it definatley would have benefitted from a bit longer running time, and a bit slower pacing.

Overall though, it's a great X-Men film. Nice conclussion to the trilogy. Better than the first one, not as good as the 2nd, but definatley on par with it in some parts.

 

[fallenAngel]

had a good story, great characters and actors, and great effects and didn't utilize any of them to the extent they should have.

and if they want to butcher the material, then they need to at least make me believe it was the right thing to do in order to make a greater movie, as singers movies did for the most part.

 

[taintedFB]

Your Avi Seems To Be Switching From Glasses To Visor.

yeah...thats so cool, tainted.

It's all about will power guys.....and Photoshop! LOL!

 

[X-Maniac]

Enjoyed it overall.

....and, yes, it had its flaws - Cyclops' death swept out of the way too quickly, no Phoenix firebird, Psylocke's puny role and death, logistical/travel issues (how did Angel get to SF, where was Magneto's base in forest, how did Brotherhood get to SF?), some scenes needed to be longer (for instance, Magneto deserting Mystique), no Storm tidal wave, Wolverine suddenly appearing behind Sentinel head...

 

[FURYoftheSTORM]

It was like watching a few good ideas mixed with several weak and underdeveloped thoughts all being dropped into a blender in order to force them to fit into a space far too small to contain them. I wanted my money back.

 

[oneteen]

I'm an okay fan.

 

[MoviesKickAss]

Aside from the obvious problems. Its at best enjoyable. In other words A Mindless Fun Action Flick. Its up there with the likes of Bad Boys

 

[JDD]

I find it to be a great movie but is not as excellent as X2, what would of help it was to make the movie longer with more chacter development other than that is a nice ending for the trilogie hopefully there gonna be other x-men movies.

 

[borinquenknight]

It had so much potential and yet it seemed like it missed its mark utterly.

 

[Cyclops]

Down as well. And as a side-note, Sky High was an incredibly fun movie.

 

[borinquenknight]

Yes it was. It really surprised me in its entertainment value.