Homecoming Organics or Web-Shooters?

[Doctor Octopus]

lel at attempting to apply real world logic to this.

Apparently Garfield's Spider-man is also non-conductive to electricity. That must be the only reason why he wasn't fried with the web shooter. But wait, he was afflicted when Electro shot at him. What gives?

Agreed lol. Made no sense.

It wasn't exciting lol and this was one of my examples on how I expect they DON'T adapt the web shooters 'cause in that scene only one of his shooters was ruined so he could still use the other how convenient! If they go with Web Shooters I really hope we don't get silly moments like this.

Agreed. I hated Times Square scene and webshooters didn't make it exciting.

Oh, so that silliness was in the comics too. I mean, Superman's powers don't shut off because of feelings. Nor does Daredevil's. Or does it...

It not silliness. Stress can make people very sick in real life too. All heroes different. Spider-Man not lose his powers because of piece of green rock like Superman.

 

[BrollySupersj]

So for those that are into organics. What type of scenes would you care to see? One thing I'd enjoy is the process of the spinnerets growing inside Peter's arms. Could make a cool and painful scene. One other thing is having Spider-Man fighting a foe who can match his strength, and then smashing his wrists to stop him from using his webbing.

I'd also like to see Peter examining the webbing and studying the biological side of it all. Indulging his scientific curiosity.

 

[SuperSanchez]

Nah guys you're all wrong, it has to be scientifically accurate, he has to shoot webs from his butt.

 

[SuperSanchez]

It does. Why would Peter's arms blow up. They not metal.

But yours are

 

[The Slang]

Nah guys you're all wrong, it has to be scientifically accurate, he has to shoot webs from his butt.

Humor aside, the scientifically accurate way would actually be to have web come from his nipples.

 

[THUNDERSTRIKE]

Humor aside, the scientifically accurate way would actually be to have web come from his nipples.

I just visualized that...

 

[The Slang]

I just visualized that...

From what I understand, it turns out the closest equivalent to the spider's silk glands in a mammal would be the milk (or mammary) glands, which is why silk actually does generate there in the body of spider-mammal hybrids.
If for some reason he were to develop extra glands for producing silk, it would be almost certainly impossible that they'd appear as a pair with one on each wrist (but not his ankles).
If Parker's body were to actually generate a silk protein, I'd say the sweat glands being the source would be a good compromise between realism and weirdness.

Parker could analyze his sweat, find a unique silk protein, and then Bingo... the secret ingredient for his web formula.

 

[BrollySupersj]

With organics they can recreate that total immobilization bit with Iron-Mans armor, I'd love to see that.

Inb4samethingcanbedonewithmechanicals.

 

[ernesth100]

Mechanics give Peter a chance to show his genius early on in the story by inventing them.

 

[Octavias]

Eh I posted in the original thread on this when this was spidermanhype... may as well continue it here....
Mechs all the way... creating web fluid and the shooters is an integral part of the character. It pushes the genius of parker to the forefront and makes it clear that the kid never needed to be a superhero, he had other paths to success available, which makes his choice to do the responsible thing all the greater

 

[THUNDERSTRIKE]

there's no way in hell that they'll ever choose organics, since that's not Spider-Man... he's a scientific genius and his ingenuity is what'll be shown that Peter utilizes... THAT'S what he's about..

 

[JOE]

Web-shooters, but I hope they don't use it as a lame excuse to showcase intelligence. Show us in other ways how Peter is a genius.

 

[BatsDC]

Organics shouldn't even be considered.

 

[ernesth100]

Organics shouldn't even be considered.

Exactly, I mean they were a cool concept in the 2002 films. But he's better with the web shooters.

@Joe, other than him getting good grades the web shooters were one of the first examples of Peter's genius.

 

[The Infernal]

Organics shouldn't even be considered.

This. /thread


Also with Marvel back in the mix I doubt they would go that route again.

 

[Random490]

I find this thread funny, mainly because I remember when this debate went on when the first Raimi film came out. Some things never change.

I'm not sure if someone came up with this before but I think it would be cool for Peter to use Tony's lab to create new improved webshooters, So he starts with homemade ones like ASM, but then makes cooler one. I could picture the scene:

"What's he doing?" - Cap

"Making new webshooter, I gotta say, he reminds me of a young me. Except more... awkward." - Stark

 

[THUNDERSTRIKE]

organics supporters should be hit in the mouth with impact webbing and become a part of the silent minority...

 

[Green Goblin]

The wining looks like some can't stand that mechanical is and always be the most popular option.

Why was this poll up? We already know what atleast 70% of us will say because we've always said it.

 

[Green Goblin]

This. /thread


Also with Marvel back in the mix I doubt they would go that route again.

I don't think Marvel being in the mix changes things.

 

[Pecola1]

One of each could be interesting... he realizes the limits of only having his one organic shooter (where the spider bit), and because of this uses his smart brain to create another one, the other one can be more advanced. Or maybe fully organic but one loses the power or something... He could start out fully organic, but when he runs out of web he can't refill! XD Which forces him to make mechanical web shooters. Either way he needs to have shooting web abilities, that's his main superpower, it shouldn't be written out as just some tech he made up, even if it's more realistic for him to have to make it.

 

[Spider-Fan83]

or he naturally has the able to produces the web fluid, but, needs the web shots to control them and weave it into webs

 

[The Infernal]

I don't think Marvel being in the mix changes things.

They've made a deal to work with Marvel and have their people involved in the creative process and you don't think that changes anything?

 

[The Slang]

One of each could be interesting... he realizes the limits of only having his one organic shooter (where the spider bit), and because of this uses his smart brain to create another one, the other one can be more advanced. Or maybe fully organic but one loses the power or something... He could start out fully organic, but when he runs out of web he can't refill! XD Which forces him to make mechanical web shooters. Either way he needs to have shooting web abilities, that's his main superpower, it shouldn't be written out as just some tech he made up, even if it's more realistic for him to have to make it.

I'm not sure if I'm understanding you properly, but Spider-man never had the power to shoot webs (until the first Raimi movie). Originally it was tech that he made up, and it's been that way for decades.

Having one organic webshooter and one mechanical webshooter sounds really terrible to me. I'd much prefer he just have one or the other. However, I'd be more open to the idea of him having organic web and using mechanical web shooters to fire the stuff and weave it into shape.