Homecoming Organics or Web-Shooters?

Organics or Web-Shooters?

  • Organics

  • Web-Shooters

  • Left hand is organic, the right hand is a web-shooter

  • Right hand is organic, the left land is a web-shooter.

  • Spider-Man shouldn't shoot webs in the reboot

  • The reboot should be scientifically accurate and Spider-Man should shoot webs out of his butt

  • Who cares?


Results are only viewable after voting.
Obviously all the points have been made I'm sure. He needs mechanical web shooters to show his genius. And to show the spider bite isn't some super duper magical gift, it's a bit incomplete. He has to compensate and use his brain to complete the Spider-Man persona.
 
Obviously all the points have been made I'm sure. He needs mechanical web shooters to show his genius. And to show the spider bite isn't some super duper magical gift, it's a bit incomplete. He has to compensate and use his brain to complete the Spider-Man persona.

Yeah, this thread is like Peter Parker or Miles Morales one. Pointless. Majority will vote for Peter/web-shooters. Marvel & Sony will go with Peter/web-shooters anyways.
Peter Parker in a classic suit using mechanical web-shooters. That's what we'll get in the end.
 
And hopefully we'll get the amusing scene where he runs out of webbing this time too. In the middle of a battle would be fun.
 
In the middle of a swing would be cool. Shortest CBM ever.
 
In the middle of a swing would be cool. Shortest CBM ever.

Amazing Spider-man #7 of Stan Lee/Ditko run did something similar.
Also IIRC, Ben Reilly subconsciously stuck to wall with just one arm till he woke up.

It's not that easy to kill Spider-Man that way.
 
Amazing Spider-man #7 of Stan Lee/Ditko run did something similar.
Also IIRC, Ben Reilly subconsciously stuck to wall with just one arm till he woke up.

It's not that easy to kill Spider-Man that way.

I bought that comic. He's in a snow storm and he falls into the side of a building head first and gets knocked out, but his unconscious body stays stuck to the wall by one hand.
 
There's nothing cool about organic webbing. Web shooters can be tweaked to have different functions and stuff. Tobey's Spider-man would've been screwed in the last Electro fight

Could not have said it better myself.It was great to see hollywood right a wrong that never should have happened.Spider-Man without the mechs is like Captain America without the shield,Thor without the hammer,Indiana Jones without the whip.

This shouldn't even be up for debate: mechanical webshooters.

amen to that.could not have said it better myself.The poll is proof this thread should never have even been created.

btw,love how all the nutcases who all said that mechanical wesbshooters don't make sense and don't work on the screen all ran away with their tails between their legs here and every messageboard around the country once Amazing Spider-Man came out and proved what nutcasese they all were.:woot::hubba:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
How many movies has Wolverine been without adamantium claws? Zero!

How many movies has Cap been without his shield? Zero!

And those weapons aren't iconic? lolwut?

Imagine Wolverine without indestructible claws or Cap without an indestructible sheild. Of course they're iconic.

and there's nothing lazy about mechanical webshooters or synthetic webbing. They actually required a creative process to conceptualize.

Anyone could come up with organics. Kid gets bit by a spider and now he can shoot webs just like a spider!

ZZZZZZZZZZZ!!!

Talk about lazy.
:applaud:applaud:applaud:up::up::up::up:

that's just what I go done saying.Great minds think alike.

Your post and my previous one is all that needs t be said right there.

nuff said.
 
Eh, I like the debate. Brings out the best merits for both sides.
 
Last edited:
I never had an issue with the organics, but I think they should go with the mechanics.
 
I'm for mechanical webshooters myself, most of the reasons have been posted by others in this thread. Another potential is the idea of the Venom symbiote. Not saying the new movies will even go that route or even hint at it, but one of the big things for Spider-Man when he got it was the unlimited webbing it gave him. Now the arguments for organics work for the symbiote as well, but from a story stand point it would be interesting to see Spidey react to not needing his webshooters anymore (and then horror when Venom comes around with this advantage in addition to his other advantages).

Now if they don't go that story route that's fine, I just prefer mechs. I remember several off hand mentions of having to refill his web fluid in the cartoon I grew up with (90s) and it felt natural, so the drama of running out doesn't always have to relate to a gun running dry.

In short, whatever works best for whatever storyline they decide to use is the right answer.
 
I don't mind the discussion so long as I'm on the winning team.

#imwithshooters
 
So say, through some crazy happenings, they go with organics once more. How would you guys take it?

Also, found this post on organics, not sure how old it is though. But it's one of the more thought out defenses for them.

OK, we've been through this organic/webshhoter thing a million times. Those that hated the idea, STILL hate it, and those that like the idea, STILL like it.

Most of you know my position on the whole organic webbing thing by now. When I first came here, I actually agreed that the organics were bad in terms of story. Everybody was under the assumption that organic webbing was BETTER than the webshooters (in terms of a superpower, not the idea). Everybody assumed Peter had an infinite amount of webbing all of a sudden, and would mean the end of the "oh no, out of webbing" storyline twists that Spider-Man fans love so much.

As I thought about this more and more, it became pretty obvious that having organic webbing would pose as many problems as having the web-shooters, and would create just as many interesting twists in the stories and battles.

Seeing as Spider-Man is so heavily steeped in sci-fi and "logic", it would make sense that biologically, Peter simply couldn't hold an infinite amount of webbing in his arms (lest his arms looked like Popeye's), and I thought it would be comparable to any other bodily fluid.

Think of it like spit. You can spit for a while, but not contantly. You need time for your glands to create more spit, and as long as you drink and eat, you'll always create more. It makes sense for this to be in the same manner that Pete creates his webbing, as it's exactly how Spiders make their webbing. It also means organics do not equal infinity. He would need a lot of pressure to fire his webbing great distances, and would therefore need a lot stored in back-supply to create such pressure. This means he couldn't just stand there and fire his webbing all day, it would run out pretty quickly (think spit again).

This got me thinking yet again, sometimes Pete's gonna have his ass handed to him. In the past, when Pete was beaten, his web shooters would malfunction or get damaged - whos to say his own fatigue would
Red Superfly
cont.

create the same problem? Being run down, and weathered, Pete's body would also be exhausted, causing his webbing to either dry up, or become weak and inconsistent. This would create as many "Oh no, out of webbing" issues as the writer sees fit.

So, in all, if we think about organic webbing, it actually makes sense, in any case you throw out.

"But he can't mix things into his webbing to defeat guys like Hydro Man and Electro!"

Um, he could still create and use the webshooters to fight these villains. Having a mix of both organics and the web shooters would be brilliant I must admit.
 
So organics are good because they can do the same as mechanicals? Then just keep mechanicals.
If he's going to create mechanicals in addition to organics as a way to alter his webs, then the organics are even more needless.
 
So organics are good because they can do the same as mechanicals? Then just keep mechanicals.
If he's going to create mechanicals in addition to organics as a way to alter his webs, then the organics are even more needless.

Well to me what he's saying is, even if you prefer organics to mechanical, you can still have them as every bit as vulnerable as normal web shooters, just in a biological sense.
 
Yeah, but how is that a defense for using organics (as you said)? They can work just like mechanicals, therefor they're good? Mechanicals already work just like mechanicals.
 
Yeah, but how is that a defense for using organics (as you said)? They can work just like mechanicals, therefor they're good? Mechanicals already work just like mechanicals.

That they can achieve the same effect as mechanicals is the defense. Should someone prefer to use them, and have the same effect, then it's not really that awful. Yes if that's case, why not just stick to mechanicals, you have a point. But then it all just comes back to preference. Mixing a best of both worlds I guess.
 
Last edited:
^^ Same. I just loved it in Spider-Man TAS when Spidey had to change his web cartridges mid-fight or whilst falling or adapt his webbing to subdue a particular enemy or like in Spectacular when Spidey is suddenly compromised and has to find other means to defeat a villain.

The fact that Spidey's webshooter did not work against Electro at first in Times Square made the fight all the more exciting, showing that Spidey can be rendered vulnerable like that. They need to have more moments like that in future films.
 
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"