Poll: Are you enjoying Ed Brubaker's Captain America?

[SpideyInATree]

Yes I can believe that a man can survive in a block of ice because of experimentation.It has been stated since the begining that Cap survived because of the SSS.I however have a hard time believing that an ordinary person could survive being on a plane that explodes.

Well, it's possible.

 

[CBK]

Surving being in a block of ice is one thing but a regular human being in ground zero of an bomb going off that should have taken out a city surving is just plan dumb. but like I said the cosmic cube could bring him back. which was like in issue #1 of Cap.

 

[roach]

Well, it's possible.

I used to stationed on an aircraft carrier. The flight deck is considered one of the most dangerous places to work. I have seen quite a few planes explode and kill everyone in the vicinity. You have to take into account shrapnel from the plane which should have shredded Bucky, the jet fuel which should have burned him alive, the fall into the water, and the waters being so cold that sent Cap into suspended animation as soon as he went under. Now if you want to believe that a one armed Bucky could survive all that still any sub wouldnt have gotten to him in time.

 

[roach]

Surving being in a block of ice is one thing but a regular human being in ground zero of an bomb going off that should have taken out a city surving is just plan dumb. but like I said the cosmic cube could bring him back. which was like in issue #1 of Cap.

hell I'd even believe some crazy Russian zombie science that brought him back over Bucky surviving

 

[CBK]

Ed Bru's Cap seems like a movie that didn't have any delete scenes. they just cramed it all in there.

 

[MyPokerShirt]

so roach voted no, whered CBK vote? i thought you'd at least given it a try?? whats the point in critisizing it if you havnt read it yet?

 

[blah]

Sorry but there should be no way that Bucky survives that. I can believe that Cap survives being frozen because of the super soldier serum but what saved Bucky....nothing....and him just losing an arm wouldnt have happened. This was a long range bomb full of fuel and explosives. Bucky should have been obliterated.

It wasn't a bomb, per se, it was a drone plane. It was just booby traped.

 

[roach]

It wasn't a bomb, per se, it was a drone plane. It was just booby traped.

did the plane have fuel onboard?????
Then once the bomb was placed on it it became one big bomb

 

[Darthphere]

Wow, roach thats pretty petty. What about everything else going on in the series? You voted no because of the way they brought back Bucky? Boo, sir, boo.

 

[roach]

Wow, roach thats pretty petty. What about everything else going on in the series? You voted no because of the way they brought back Bucky? Boo, sir, boo.

yeah im pretty petty but I have to stand by my guns. i dropped Cap after it was revealed to be him. Just like I dropped Batman after Jason Todd came back

 

[Darthphere]

Well honestly, I dont find it hard to believe someone could survive an explosion like that. I think at this point we all have seen that video of the guy sucked in by the jet fighter engine and coming out on the other side with barely a scratch, its not beyond reason.

 

[blah]

Was Bucky wearing his slightly armoured uniform under his army fatigues like cap did? Because that would increase the pausability of his survival...

 

[Darthphere]

Even if he wasnt, its possible.

 

[roach]

Well honestly, I dont find it hard to believe someone could survive an explosion like that. I think at this point we all have seen that video of the guy sucked in by the jet fighter engine and coming out on the other side with barely a scratch, its not beyond reason.

big difference between being pulled into a jet engine and being on a plane that explodes

 

[Darthphere]

big difference between being pulled into a jet engine and being on a plane that explodes

Not really, I think youve been around jet engines, you get any part of your body in there, youre screwed. Either way, I just dont see why with everything else going on it be thought to be unbelievable, he lost his arm, the blast of the explosion expelled him away from the the fire and all. Im guessing you have a problem with every action movie made with an explosion, because essentially its the same thing.

 

[Darthphere]

This is the scan of what actually happened.

This is what Cap saw because of the Cosmic Cube.

The very next page where he admits that he doesnt know whether or not these memories are real.

 

[CBK]

Havent read it? I've read all of the Caps that Ed Bru wrote I dont like it but I'm a big cap fan and I'll read it no matter if i hate it. I vote no That i dont like it. and I dont think cap and bucky would run after that plane if it was just a drone plane. but then zemo could have just told cap and bucky that plane was going to blow up a city to get them on it..but anyway its all the cosmic cube's doing...but they keep on messing with what happen that day and what happen after that explosion.

 

[The Cleric]

whoever doesnt enjoy the book should get shot by ironmans photon canon

 

[Darthphere]

Havent read it? I've read all of the Caps that Ed Bru wrote I dont like it but I'm a big cap fan and I'll read it no matter if i hate it. I vote no That i dont like it. and I dont think cap and bucky would run after that plane if it was just a drone plane. but then zemo could have just told cap and bucky that plane was going to blow up a city to get them on it..but anyway its all the cosmic cube's doing...but they keep on messing with what happen that day and what happen after that explosion.

First, if you dont like it, dont read it. Its just wow, I understand character loyalty, but if you think the comic sucks it sucks. Second I already explained the whole thing about Bucky and Cap in the post right above yours.

 

[MyPokerShirt]

Havent read it? I vote no That i dont like it.

but the no vote still says one...
??

 

[CBK]

I read it because i hope it will get better and i can afford to. and two cap got those files from??? nobody knows it just showed up to his secret hideout w/ tons of security in it and around it and it just popped up. so it could be fake we dont know if thats real. dont take what u read in that comic as truth surrounding bucky.

 

[Darthphere]

I read it because i hope it will get better and i can afford to. and two cap got those files from??? nobody knows it just showed up to his secret hideout w/ tons of security in it and around it and it just popped up. so it could be fake we dont know if thats real. dont take what u read in that comic as truth surrounding bucky.

No, theyre not fake. Read the red highlighted part, seriously.

 

[CBK]

what im saying is the whole documents could be fake...but we all could be right..Roach could be right by saying he couldnt survied the plan expolsion. and u could be right saying he could of survied it and me being right that they're fake documents..w/ just one simple lil thing the cosmic cube..I hate to repeat myself but he probaly just brought back bucky to mess with cap. but then if u had a cosmic cube why waste it on bucky.

 

[Darthphere]

Im pretty sure the file was authenticated by SHIELD, but whatever happens in the comic or anything I show you, it seems you want to hate the comic anyway so im done.

 

[CBK]

Whatever most people here just get mad when i explain different sides. All im saying is that it could be fake and your like no its real because they're in the comic and buckys alive because they say he is.