Question about ending of TLH

Previous case files before the Holiday murders.

 

Why would someone use that? Because it works and is more inconspicuous than going out and buying a scilencer..

 

hey i have a question myself

whats the cover price of the tp?

 

$19.99

Of course, you can get it for nearly half that at www.amazon.com or www.dreamlandcomics.com

 

is it confirmed that Glida was Holiday at one stage? or was it a dream sequence, or was she just talking crap or what?
has leob told us what really happened?

 

Nope, nope and no he hasn't.

 

There were just other cases where people used baby bottle niples as silencers. People use household items to make inexpensive but effective tools for crimes all the time.

 

A plastic bottle also works like a charm, but it's a bit big.

 

Yes, followed by Harvey Dent and then Alberto Falcone. Though that is a subject of debate and what I stated is my opinion. But Gilda and Alberto were definetly Holiday killers

No

No

No, and in my opinion that's what makes the Long Halloween so great

 

I personally believe she didn't, but I'm of the minority when it comes to that.

And Loeb has pretty much left us to have our own intepetations when it comes to the order of the Hoiday murderers.

 

In my opinion Gilda did the first killings, followed by Harvey (attempted to kill Alberto but failed) followed by Alberto (starting Father's Day) then finally Two-Face.

 

The bad thing about that is, there's really no answer to the mystery. They leave it so open-ended that it isn't even satisfying to solve it yourself, because you can't. It might be twelve different guys, for all you know.

 

Gilda Dent
Halloween - Johnny Viti
Thanksgiving - Jimmy Murphy, Kevin Kelly, Willie O'Neil, Donald Sullivan, Mickey Sullivan
Christmas - Milos Grapa

Harvey Dent
New Year's - Alberto Falcone (failed)
Valentine's Day - attack on Maroni's Restaurant (numerous killed)
St. Patrick's Day - attack on Maroni's safehouse (numerous killed)???
Halloween - Carmine Falcone (as Two-Face)

Alberto Falcone
St. Patrick's Day - attack on Maroni's safehouse (numerous killed)???
April Fools Day - the Riddler (failed)
Mother's Day - Gunsmith
Father's Day - Luigi Maroni
Independence Day - Gotham City coroner
the Roman's Birthday - Carla Viti
Labor Day - Sal Maroni

 

I think Gilda started it. Harvey may or may not have tried to kill Alberto but anyway Alberto continued. Gilda stopped because she thought Harvey had continued. Two-Face was the last one.

I see Two-Face as the bad side and Harvey as the good side of the same person. Therefore I think it doesn't work if Harvey started killing before he became Two-Face.

 

It's clear that Harvey was behind the attacks on New Year's and Valentines Day. The rest are debateable.

 

However, now that I think about it, Alberto clearly was the one who killed the Gunsmith. Harvey and Gilda made their guns in their basement. Alberto is obviously not a person who would do such a thing and the Gunsmith would have revealed that Alberto was alive and well just like the coroner and Carla Viti would have. Also it was Alberto who went to do the "killing" of the Riddler on account that Harvey was busy with Gordon at the time of the shooting, talking about Bruce Wayne's connection with the Falcones.

 

God bless The Long Halloween.

It's been out how long and we can still talk and debate about it. THATS what makes a great book.