At least X3 & FF were compact & more enjoyable (not taking BO into account - even with their flaws and silliness) and were not epic-drag-ons like SR, which is unfortunate since Supes is an awesome and like the pioneer of superheroes.
And c'mon, you putting X3 & FF in the same category as Elektra and CINO pretty much automatically makes your arguments less credible IMO.
Singer does well in certain genre and is not a hack - but with SR, his overconfidence and lack of taking off the "donner-vision" visor couple with totally complicating a character right off the bat after a 20 year break kind of screwed him.
Here's to hoping the next one's great