SR vs X3

[JackBauer]

I liked both movies, but both could have been a thousand times better. IMO this world would be a better place if Singer stuck with X-Men and someone who didn't have a man-crush on Richard Donner got to handle Superman.

true dat

 

[Substance D]

They both sucked, but at least X3 had good action and a decent story. SR sucked all around.

 

[aaron]

I don't think so man, Superman Returns was very good...

but then again, seems like you're a person who only likes a movie if it's full on action all the way through.

 

[Matt]

X-3, at least it was fun. SR was just boring.

 

[JackBauer]

X-3, at least it was fun. SR was just boring.

I'll admit the pacing on SR was kinda bad, but X3 was in no way fun.

 

[aaron]

X3 was a hour and half of pure devestation, except for a few brief juicy moments.

 

[L0ngsh0t]

see I think X3 had a very TAS feel to it (Brief plot, small character arcs, and to the point, with the point being lets get these xmen to use their powers against other mutants who use their powers) In that sense I enjoyed the fun little ride X3 was. I didn't enjoy much of SR, and I am not even a big action ****e unless it is just (like POTCDMC), But I was board during SR

 

[Karea07]

X3 was more fun

 

[Ronny Shade]

I'll admit the pacing on SR was kinda bad, but X3 was in no way fun.

Pacing of SR>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Pacing of X3.

 

[JackBauer]

Pacing of SR>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Pacing of X3.

anything of SR>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>anything of X3

 

[Wilhelm-Scream]

How.....I still don't get, how can anyone even say a serious word about a movie where Superman knocks up a chick then takes off for half a decade without saying goodbye?!?

It's the most preposterous....whatever.

 

[Karea07]

not the women!

 

[Kanon]

X3 wasn't perfect at all, but still it was good. Superman returns was boring and waaaay too long. It was a great dissappointment to me, since I got my hopes high after the trailers.

 

[aaron]

I can't believe you guys.

 

[Erzengel]

How.....I still don't get, how can anyone even say a serious word about a movie where Superman knocks up a chick then takes off for half a decade without saying goodbye?!?

It's the most preposterous....whatever.

Agreed and I was disappointed with SR.

But if you have such low expectations for a movie like X3 and it still manages to disappoint? X3 had the feel of a quickly slapped together movie.

I got the same feeling for FF2.

 

[Ronny Shade]

FF2 isn't even out yet

 

[Erzengel]

FF2 looks like it's being pushed out as fast as X3 was.

 

[Ronny Shade]

FF2 is like diarrhea after eating the bad nachos that were FF1. No way can it be good.

 

[Matt]

FF2 looks like it's being pushed out as fast as X3 was.

Why wouldn't fox? X3 is the second or third highest grossing movie this year. If it worked once, they probably figure it can work again.

I still maintain X3 is better than SR however. Even if it was rushed and lacked character development, at least I didn't nearly fall asleep in it.

 

[Matt]

FF2 is like diarrhea after eating the bad nachos that were FF1. No way can it be good.

I agree, the first one sucked, why do people think the second will be any better?

 

[aaron]

Because it's possible.

 

[Erzengel]

Why wouldn't fox? X3 is the second or third highest grossing movie this year. If it worked once, they probably figure it can work again.

I still maintain X3 is better than SR however. Even if it was rushed and lacked character development, at least I didn't nearly fall asleep in it.

I guess I'm a lil sick of the whole "It's a fun movie excuse with movies nowadays." Between X3 and Pirates this year, I want a "good" movie.

Yes it's fun to have a movie where you can leave your brain at the door but why can't it be both fun and good.

 

[The Joker]

X3 had some great action, and Ian McKellan as the villain.

SR had a campy Lex Luthor, and a snooze fest of a story.

X3 gets my vote.

 

[aaron]

Spacey ruled it.

 

[Ronny Shade]

Because it's possible.

Considering all the changes they made to the development, you could be right