I live in hope they do reboot. I have no faith in JL with Hack Snyder in the director's chair again. If that is another disappointment for WB, then its time to just cut their losses and reboot. Sony had the good sense to do it after two lame Spider-Man movies. How many is it going to take for WB to wake up to themselves.
Its not if, its when.
JL is going to end up needing damn close to a billion to turn a profit. Its going to be so damn expensive. BVS opened at 166. SS is down from that. Granted, SS has better competition in Trek and Bourne and less iconic characters (but it also has consistent box office draw Will Smith and Joker/Harley who are box office draws on par with Batman). Its indicating that there is a bit of fatigue already. Factor in the poor reviews and the big drops that are already happening, its showing that these movies are both incredibly front loaded and cannot survive bad word of mouth.
Audiences are far more brand aware than 20 years ago. BvS reflects on SS and JL. SS will reflect upon WW and JL. Audiences will hold these movies against JL.
Further, Warners has already played their best hand. No one is going to JL to finally see Aquaman and Cyborg on screen. The biggest draw of JL was Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, on screen, together. It was an event movie. And Warners foolishly blew their load prematurely by making BvS. BvS, in retrospect, was so ill-advised, if for no other reason it takes away from the event nature of JL. It would be like making Captain America Civil War right after First Avenger and then planning The Avengers afterward. Its just a dumb strategy. You need to build up to the event, not show it all in your second outing.
But that could be okay. They could have recovered if BvS were good and got people hyped. But it wasn't. Instead it became a punchline. And SS has done nothing to rehabilitate it.
And none of that speaks to the competition JL is facing. It is releasing two weeks after Thor Ragnarok (so you can expect some superhero fatigue). Then,
5 DAYS AFTER JL IS RELEASED comes a movie by a little studio called Pixar. A studio whose average WW gross brings in 650 million dollars. And none of that speaks to the fact that the average is dragged down by their earlier productions like A Bug's Life (before they really caught fire) and Cars 2. So, JL is sandwiched in-between two behemoths. Then a month after JL releases...Star Wars: Episode VIII. Do you know what all of these movies have in common? Strong WOM. Pixar movies are almost universally beloved. People flock in droves to see the Marvel movies and Star Wars is iconic. Meanwhile, the DCEU's reputation gets worse and worse with each release.
What I am getting at is, there is no room for JL to stretch its legs and there is barely room for it to be front loaded when it is surrounded by competition, during the holiday season when people's pockets are a bit lighter than usual as it is. People will be more selective about what they see in the holiday season.
So to recap: JL has a huge budget, has nothing to hype up (as what it offers has already been seen in BvS), is part of a franchise with a bad reputation, is smothered by stronger competition, and is releasing in a time when people have to be more selective in their spending habits.
All of this is recipe for disaster. And I'm not talking BvS underperformance disaster. I am talking Independence Day Resurgence bomb disaster.