Maybe not directly horror but some definite horror vibes, you guys should definitely seek out Hannibal, which just finished its first season and is returning for a 2nd next year.
When the show was first announced I was completely put off by the whole concept. After Hannibal and Hannibal rising it just seemed like more Hannibal would just further detooth the character and the premise just sounded like a network TV cash in on Dexter or something.
I was so wrong. This show is so well put together. The cast is great. While he may never be as recognized for the role as Hopkins, I can say I think Mikkelson is the best actor to play Hannibal Lecter. While Hopkins did great work making his mark in about 12 minutes in Silence of the Lambs, Mikkelson has been fantastic as a more subtle, slow burn season length Hannibal. The rest of the cast is similarly good.
The production values are fantastic. The show is more cinematic both and camera work and just overall design than any network show I've ever seen and even gives most cable shows a run for there money.
Not that I'm complaining at all but I've been pretty well shocked by the level and quality of gore and presentation of violence the show has managed to pull of with network TV rating constraints and its budget.
Again I highly reccommend it.
Because, you know, This happens: