The Amazing Spider-Man 2 The Sarah Gadon in TASM2 Discussion Thread

Well, drama is our life essence.

Yeah lol. Thats my default response for when anyone on this site says anything about any topic:

"I bet you'd love that wouldnt you? Gah. Some people on this site..."
 
This is my favorite picture of the girl:

wahl_gadon.jpg
 
If the intent was to somehow disparage Woodley with that image, it failed, because anyone with a brain (provided they're actually using it) can see that both she and Gadon are very beautiful women who can also pass as the 'girl-next-door'.
 
DigificWriter, maybe, but when I see Sarah I immediately remember Awkward Shake video on youtube :cwink: Same not happening with Woodley "chick" :o
 
^ I have no idea what you're talking about.

This is likely going to piss some people off, but if you honestly don't think Woodley is beautiful, you're an idiot.
 
^ I have no idea what you're talking about.

This is likely going to piss some people off, but if you honestly don't think Woodley is beautiful, you're an idiot.

Just because i have different taste in womens dose not necassary means i am idiot. We are all different people, we have different preferences in womens, for me is first i find attractive in girl is her face and her body, second is her personality. Maybe i am shallow, but i can tell you women watching same thing in us.
 
^ I have no idea what you're talking about.

This is likely going to piss some people off, but if you honestly don't think Woodley is beautiful, you're an idiot.

Man, the apologists have gotten ... intense since I was last here. :oldrazz:

Come off it man. Different people have different preferences. There's no need to call anyone an idiot. I can't fathom why you or anyone else are so emotionally wrapped up in this topic.

Personally, I don't think she's ugly, but in these select photos (and from the general average of photos that I've seen of both of them), I would say there's not really a comparison to be made.

That said, Sarah strikes me FAR more as Felicia than MJ. I'm hoping they go with that.
 
^ Attractiveness is subjective; beauty is not. Woodley IS beautiful. Individual people might find other beautiful women more attractive, as is their prerogative, but that doesn't in any way lessen Shailene's beauty.

Recognizing that and calling people out for the idiocy of stating or otherwise doesn't make me an 'apologist', BTW; it makes me honest. It IS idiocy to deny that Woodley's beautiful even if you find other actresses more attractive. IOW, attractiveness does not = beauty.
 
Last edited:
Everyone has a different taste, its fine, but the moment you put down a girl because they are not your type or what you consider pretty then thats when it gets wrong, and aslong you don't do that then all is good
 
Last edited:
^ Attractiveness is subjective; beauty is not. Woodley IS beautiful. You might find other beautiful women more attractive, as is your prerogative, but that doesn't in any way lessen Shailene's beauty.

Perceived beauty is just as subjective. Let's not make up new rules about reality to justify ourselves here. :oldrazz: Have you never heard of the phrase 'Beauty is in the eye of the beholder'?

If so many people would call you delusional for saying that, how can you go around trumpeting that her beauty is inarguably a 'fact'?

Come on. You have a different opinion, and that's okay. It doesn't have to be the ONLY POSSIBLE opinion for you to enjoy what you enjoy, does it?
 
^ Attractiveness is subjective; beauty is not. Woodley IS beautiful. Individual people might find other beautiful women more attractive, as is their prerogative, but that doesn't in any way lessen Shailene's beauty.

Recognizing that and calling people out for the idiocy of stating or otherwise doesn't make me an 'apologist', BTW; it makes me honest. It IS idiocy to deny that Woodley's beautiful even if you find other actresses more attractive. IOW, attractiveness does not = beauty.

By that logic everyone ever is beautiful. Which, is an opinion I respect, but not one I agree with.
 
Recognizing that and calling people out for the idiocy of stating or otherwise doesn't make me an 'apologist', BTW; it makes me honest. It IS idiocy to deny that Woodley's beautiful even if you find other actresses more attractive. IOW, attractiveness does not = beauty.

You're white-knighting her in the face of harsh criticism. That is apologism. I didn't use the word with the intention of it being derogatory, but it appears you have taken it that way.

The word I used to describe your insulting behavior toward other people was 'intense'.
 
All flowers are beautiful, but individual people are going to prefer certain types of flowers and subjectively cite those flowers' beauty over others; that doesn't lessen the beauty of the flowers that a given individual passed over, though.

Gadon and Woodley are both beautiful women. You might think Gadon is more beautiful than Woodley, but Woodley is still beautiful.
 
All flowers are beautiful, but individual people are going to prefer certain types of flowers and subjectively cite those flowers' beauty over others; that doesn't lessen the beauty of the flowers that a given individual passed over, though.

Gadon and Woodley are both beautiful women. You might think Gadon is more beautiful than Woodley, but Woodley is still beautiful.
Hit it right on the nail and please give her respect whoever she may be playing
 

Dead serious, my friend.

"Why so serious," you ask? That picture is phenomenal. I want someone to manip her hair red in that one.

[my 3000th post btw! :D]
 
Last edited:
Gadon and Woodley are both beautiful women. You might think Gadon is more beautiful than Woodley, but Woodley is still beautiful.

To you, sure. I'm not denying she can be interpreted as beautiful. What I'm saying is that your interpretation is not the only possible interpretation.

beau·ty

[byoo-tee] Show IPA
noun, plural beau·ties. 1. the quality present in a thing or person that gives intense pleasure or deep satisfaction to the mind, whether arising from sensory manifestations (as shape, color, sound, etc.), a meaningful design or pattern, or something else


If something doesn't give EVERYONE who beholds it an 'intense pleasure or deep satisfaction to their mind', it is NOT inherently beautiful.

Beauty is subjective, it's something interpreted by a person based on what pleases their respective mind. Period.
 
I see her more as Felicia Hardy/Black Cat than Mary Jane. I think Shailene Woodley is attractive. Just like Anne Hathaway's Selena Kyle/Catwoman to Michelle Pfeiffer's. Still very acttractive, but different from Pfeiffer's. This pisses me off if this is true.
 
Is there any actual confirmation? Looking at her I'd say she'd make a good Felicia Hardy.
 
I'm sure Gadon will be fine just like I was sure Woodley will be. I'm not terribly protective of Woodley as an actress but the comments about her looks, the nasty ones make me sick.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,289
Messages
22,080,713
Members
45,880
Latest member
Heartbeat
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"