Best Single Issue of 2012
Batman #5 (DC)
Batman #13 (DC)
Hawkeye #3 (Marvel)
The Shadow #2 (Dynamite)
Archer and Armstrong #1 (Valiant)
Best Ongoing Series of 2012
The Shadow (Dynamite)
X-O Manowar (Valiant)
Batman (DC)
Hawkeye (Marvel)
Wonder Woman (DC)
Archer & Armstrong (Valiant)
Bloodshot (Valiant)
Best Mini Series of 2012 (at least half of it must have taken place in 2012)
Before Watchmen: Silk Specter
Best One-Shot of 2012
Batman: Earth One
Superman Annual #1
Best Arc of 2012 (at least half of it must have taken place in 2012)
Batman: The Court of Owls
Swamp Thing/Animal Man: Rotworld
X-O Manowar: By the Sword
The Shadow: The Fire of Creation
Best Writer of 2012
Matt Fraction
Scott Snyder
Garth Ennis
Ed Brubaker
Robert Venditti
Best Artist of 2012
Aaron Campbell
Patrick Zarcher
David Aja
Moritat
Cary Nord
Best Character of 2012
Batman
Hawkeye
X-O Manowar
The Shadow
Superman
Best Supporting Character of 2012
Pulse (Bloodshot - Valiant)
Kate Bishop (Hawkeye - Marvel)
Damien Wayne (Batman & Robin - DC)
Ninjak (X-O Manowar - Valiant)
Best Villain of 2012
The Joker
Best Company of 2012
Valiant Entertainment
Best Independent Title of 2012
My Friend Dahmer(Derk Backderf)
Parker: The Score (Darwyn Cooke)
Are You My Mother?(Alison Bechdel)
Supercrooks(Mark Millar)
======================
Worst Single Issue of 2012
Iron Man #1 (Marvel)
Worst Ongoing Title of 2012
Deathstroke (DC)
Worst Arc of 2012 (at least half of it must have taken place in 2012)
Biggest WTF Moment of 2012 (things that make you go hmm?!)
The Reveal of Owlman (Batman #11 - DC)
Best Scene of 2012 (single moment in an issue, a panel or a page, etc.)
Naked Hawkeye Leap - Hawkeye #3
X-O Manowar Vs. Ninjak (full battle) - X-O Manowar #6
The Return of the Joker - Batman #13
The Shadow Wins the Greater Game -- The Shadow #6
Will fill in rest later
Best Death Scene of 2012
Ugliest Art of 2012
Worst Writing of 2012
Most Doable of 2012 (that's right... which fictional character would you 'do' if he/she were real?)