So I just finished rewatching the series. This was my first viewing of the show since '09 - yep, almost a decade ago. I couldn't help but cringe a bit when going over the comments in the stream I was using and saw someone say this show was their childhood...
childhood...I'm not old dammit.
Given how much has changed in my life in 8 years, I was a bit worried it wouldn't hold up...and it still does. This is still the best portrayal of Spider-Man in another medium for me.
There's really not much to say that hasn't been said. This show did everything right. The high school drama? Perfect. The villains? Most of them brilliantly done. The pacing? It flows very much like a natural river. Finally, the balance between Peter's life as Spider-Man, his job and the more interpersonal aspects? I'm amazed at how well Greg Weisman managed to balance them all in just 22 minutes.
On top of bringing to life the dynamics we know and love, Greg continues putting to use his talent in exploring new dynamics between characters we didn't consider before. My two favorite ones are Electro and Doc Ock, and the symbiote and Uncle Ben. Electro much like in the comics has a god complex compared to the humans, but an inferiority one to the supervillains. How does an egotistical master planner like Ock respond to that? By exploiting him. Having the symbiote "interact" with Uncle Ben is also one of the most ingenious ideas I ever saw done with the symbiote. Other interesting dynamics include Miles and Curt, Sandman and Rhino, and Mysterio and the Tinkerer.
As a sidenote, the flashbacks with Uncle Ben still bring tears to my eyes to this day. Despite being lighter than BTAS, some of those scenes do feel BTAS-y. The tone and colorless look give it a darker feeling than most of the other episodes.
Josh Keaton is hands down my favorite Spidey VA. When he's Peter Parker, he stutters a bit. When he's Spidey, he's fluent. When he's serious, he deepens. And when he's genuinely angry, you can hear his voice crack as if he's about to cry. Highly underrated performance.
As I said, the villains are mostly exceptional. Easily the best two in the show are Green Goblin and Doc Ock though. Weisman brought the danger and nastiness of Norman Osborn to life on the Saturday morning cartoon to the same degree Bruce Timm did with the Joker. On a first viewing I couldn't believe the Otto they presented could be Ock, and I completely bought it by the end. If I had to show a non-comic reader why people love these two characters so much, I would just direct them to this show.
Final Curtain in particular is simply a crown jewel in the Spider-Man mythos. I heard a reviewer once describe it as Greg sitting down and saying "Everyone knows Norman is the Green Goblin, let's make it a mystery again"...and it works. On a first viewing I wasn't sure if Norman was the Goblin. I had a feeling it was him, but it was impossible given the facts. On a second viewing the mystery is known, but emotionally it never leaves you. Easily the most cinematic episode in the series - eight years and it still gives me chills. And to top it off, it still doesn't forget about Peter Parker. Some of the best relationship stuff done in the series are in this episode. Even if the rest of the show was subpar, this one episode would still be my favorite Spider-Man product in another medium.
That being said, the show has its issues. Venom and Kraven are the two villains I found subpar. To start off with Venom, I think the voice sounds lame. Second, Eddie's progression feels too rushed. Some of his motivations, like the fact he felt lonely prior to the symbiote, aren't even brought up pre-Venom. Third, I felt Peter should've been more paranoid after Venom returned. As far as Kraven goes, I wasn't a fan of the mutation. Greg said he had a plan for it in Season 3, plus he's got a track record of taking lame ideas and making them cool, but as this show stands it's not that good.
There's some more minor issues too. Vulture's motivation is a little vague in Season 2. The little hairs on the fingers are the one thing they shouldn't have taken from the Raimi films, since they don't make much sense. Third, I'm not sure how a professional thief like Walter Hardy could devolve to such a thug. What's a guy with those skills doing robbing wrestling rings and parked cars? I had to see more of him. Lastly, the art style will take some time to get used to everytime I go back to it. It looks fine in combat or whenever the designs look eccentric - namely when you're with Spidey and the villains - but environments with regular humans just standing around look a little more weird - the high school, the Bugle, etc. It's not horrible, but overall not the best choice.
It's amazing the impact this show had with just 26 episodes. Fans still rabidly talk about it, compare it to every new incarnation, plus it influenced at least one of the film franchises. Everyone always talks about Electro but Emma Stone's Gwen Stacy was clearly influenced by this show, since Gwen was never the nerd counterpart to Peter prior to this. It can technically be considered the show that brought Gwen out into the spotlight again, not just in movies but also the comics. It begs the question of how else it would have influenced Spidey culture as a whole had it went on for longer.
I couldn't help but do two things after finishing it. First was to think of what could have been, and second to go back to the Season 3 speculation thread on the SHH and read some of the old posts for the sake of nostalgia. It was that very thread that first introduced me to this lovely site, and the rest is history. It sucks this couldn't go on for legal reasons, but you never know. Gargoyles came back a decade later in comic form plus Young Justice is booked to return soon. With the continued word of mouth this show gets there's always a chance.
There's also a dark side to that word of mouth. Too many other versions are being compared to Spectacular as if it's the end-all-be-all of the character. Is it
necessary to point out out differences between Homecoming and Spectacular? It's good that fans love the show, but it should be balanced out with moving on. BTAS had the same problem.
Beware the Batman's Bats was actually a better detective, but no one noticed due to the love for TAS.
But yes, overall great show.
