LOVE the Jossverse! I own the first 6 seasons of Buffy and all 5 seasons of Angel. Both were the 2 best shows are TV during their run and are still better than half the shows today. If I could rank and some up both shows, it would go like this:
Buffy Review
1. Season 3-Definately the best! It had the perfect balance of drama, horror and humor. The Buffy-Faith-Angel dynamic was excellent. So many classics and unforgettable moments to name!
2. Season 2-One of the show's darkest and saddest seasons. The whole Angel turning evil plot is classic! Angelus was fantastic as well as Spike and Drusilla who made their debut here. Who could forget the heartbreaking 2-parter?
3. Season 5-The saddest season besides Season 2. The plot with Glory and Dawn is the most imaginative and original story arc the writers ever created. The family theme was so touching; also so many powerful stand alone episodes...The Body left me speechless!
4. Season 4-Harshly underrated! It had some of the best stand alone episodes of the series like Hush, Restless, and Fear Itself etc. The Initiative and Adam plot was always watchable for me, but even if you don't like it, you can't deny the brilliance of some episodes.
5. Season 7-Has some shaky parts, but the overall arc is a dark and fearsome one! Some truly great episodes here with the First and Caleb wrecking havoc!
6. Season 1-A little overrated in my opinion. While the witty dialogue is there, the monster of the week episodes were too basic and plain. There are some good episodes but the short run of episodes doesn't help.
7. Season 6-While has some truly amazing episodes, this season's storyline went all over the place, Spike and Buffy's sexcapades got tiresome, Anya and Xander spilt up for the wrong reasons, Tara died, and don't get me started on Doublemeat Palace and Gone!
Angel Review
1. Season 4-It's the darkest and most epic season of the series. There are no useless fillers but just one long arc that got better with each episode the whole season! I loved the episodes with the Beast, Angelus, Faith and Jasmine was an inventive villain who is misunderstood by most fans.
2. Season 2-The series got much darker and the Darla arc brought some of the best and most shocking episodes of the series. Wolfram and Hart got more interesting this season, not to mention Drusilla got involved!
3. Season 5-While the first half was very weak in places, the second half was incredible with some of the darkest and most hilarious episodes of the series. Spike made for an excellent addition! Also Illyria, Hamilton, and the final battle for the gang were amazing!
4. Season 1-A great start with some amazing stand-alone episodes, like the ones with Faith, some hilarious ones, and inventive villains!
5. Season 3-While I loved the Darla/Angel/Connor arc, I was annoyed by Holtz and Justine's antics. But Wesley's descent into a dark character was flawlessly written.