The problemwith Orton is he didn't anything interesting after he dropped the title or was booked to do stuff to piss fans off during his face run.
THE CONS:
Edge did a pointless heel turn.
The feud with Sheamus was terrible overall.
Barrett failed to win the WWE Championship thus ruining the Nexus angle.
Orton, not Miz, should've headlined Wrestlemania 27 against Cena.
Orton defeated Punk in their re-feud again.
ChristianGate happened.
Jericho Vs. Orton got delayed got delayed 2 years because they both got in trouble,
THE PROS:
I did enjoy Orton and Sheamus's HITC match.
Cage Vs. Orton at OTL 2011 was my favorite match of that year.
Mark Henry's 2011 push was fantastic.
Del Rio Vs. Orton was good.
Kane defeated Orton at Wrestlemania 28. That was a shocker.
Orton Vs. Show at Extreme Rules 2013 (unlike their disaster of a rematch at Survivor Series month later.)