Jaws
It's my all time favorite film and as far as I'm concerned it's the best movie I've ever seen(and I have seen Citizen Kane). I've probably watched it a hundred times over the last 35+ years.
"The Place Beyond the Pines" is in running to become the movie I've seen most times in theaters. I'm coming up on viewing number five right now, which would beat out TDKR.
Quite an unconventional choice. Can I ask you what drew you to this movie.