Showtime029 said:
I loved the idea of a return story and I enjoyed the movie, but if I had the same plot involving the Return of Superman I would have done this:
*Make it clear in the movie that Lex was the one who drove Superman back to Krypton. Some how setting up a plot with Stanford to make it look like Krypton was still a possible hotspot for life. I believe this was in the script and in the novel but was cut.
*I would have given more time in Smallville for Clark to ponder if he even wants to be Superman anymore because it seems the world doesn't actually need him. This was written in the script and was a big part of the original idea, the world not needing Superman. This would give Ma Kent a bigger role in bringing him back.
*I loved the beggining, the STM font flying through different parts of space, very nostalgic. The problem is I would have rather seen the original idea of shots from the old movies, a recap of what happened, plus some shots of him going back to Krypton. They could have done it right through the credits up until his landing.
*I would have nixed the kid idea, although I thought it worked well in the movie. They did it in a subtle manner and I was relieved how it was handled. I would rather see that Lois has moved on with somebody else, maybe even Richard but without child.
*Not only has Lois and the world moved on without Superman but Lex has capitalized on this. Because Superman left and never appeared in at Luthors court date, he was released, just like in Returns. The difference is that Lex uses his Vanderworth money to start Lexcorp and makes himself a savior to Metropolis. Donates money to fight crime and becomes a tycoon that helps Metropolis grow in every area. He is now running for office, mayor, governor, senator, it doesn't matter. His platform is that he has done more for Metropolis or what not in the past 5 years than even Superman has done. He makes the people turn against Superman. Now that Luthor has all these connections he can do anything. He finds the FOS and uses the technology with help from STARS LABS to create Metallo.
So many possibilities.
I wrote this a week or so before SR came out, seems like we're on a similar page as far as what we wanted. I jacked up the action a bit more, because that's the name of the game with Superman, a guy who's not afraid to solve a problem with his fists.
-Luthor is clearly manipulating Superman, by making him believe there are survivors on Krypton through an elaborate hoax.
-After his 5 year trip, Superman returns to find a startling revelation. Luthor is a hero! In Superman's absence, Luthor has made technoligical advances that made metropolis a utopia, thus winning over the hearts and minds of the people of earth.
-Lois is engaged to Richard White, but there's no kid involved.
-Luthor effectively turns the population against Superman. While he was off soul searching for a dead world(as Lex puts it) Luthor's made amazing technological advances that have benefited mankind, advances he's realized after cannibalizing the FoS, and creating a new terran/kryptonian hybrid. Superman is obsolete because of new lexor-type bodyarmour the police, firemen and paramedics are equipped with.
-Clark reunites with DP staff, while the rest of them investigate Superman's Return, Clark starts digging into Luthor's activities during his absence. Specifically how Luthor explained cannibalizing kryptonian tech.
-Luthor while a benefactor to the public, isn't afraid to strongarm anyone he can't buy. Luthor is a brilliant sceintist, who enjoys chess. That's how he views his buisness dealings, calculated means to aquire legtimate power to fund his less ethical ambitions. To rid the world of Superman's influence, to insure that humanity retain free will. Now that Superman has returned, he starts to orchastrate his destruction.
-Superman and Lois reunite. It's bittersweet, because they realize it's over, she's moved on.
-Richard and Lois develop tension about Superman's past involvement in her life.
-Jimmy is Luthor's biggest fan, he likes the idea of cops and firemen who can fly around in bulletproof bodyarmor. He is also a little resentful his pal left for 5 years, as most of the world. When he finds out Clark is researching Luthor's activities, tension develops between the two, not too much.
-Luthor's hybrid tech isn't as stable as he claims. Most breakdowns are easy to cover up, but one system managing a fusion reactor malfunctions. A disaster is immenent, and only Superman can save the day. After doing so, he earns some public for it. He starts to reclaim his place in the world as the fastest emergency response yet.
-Luthor plans Superman’s destruction, he’s capable of winning them over again and Luthor wont have that. His assistant Mercy, organizes the criminal element so Luthor can keep his hands clean, not to mention the air he breathes. He has handlers to deal with the help. Luthor is smart enough to aquire power, destroy Superman, and remain free from prosecution all at the same time.
-Bored of Superman stories, and weary of Richard’s insecurities, Lois finds solace in helping Clark with his investigation. Luthor has little actual account for his discoveries, it’s as if they appeared. Clark is going to interview a scientist with the inside scoop on Luthor’s tech. He makes her promise not to scoop him, she laughs.
-Luthor’s high tech goons wreak havok in the city, attempting to lure Superman out for an old fashioned showdown. They are nothing more than a diversion for an assassin named Floyd Lawton, to execute Superman with a kryptonian designed sniper rifle that fires kryptonite rounds. A nasty .50 cal from space.
-Lois and Clark arrive at Emil Hamilton’s apartment. This elderly scientist reveals that the technology is kryptonian in origin. Hamilton was there when Luthor pilfered the FoS, he was ashamed to admit his scientific curiosity got the better of him. Ethically it was wrong, but it was alien artifacts and technology. Emil plays back a history file from the fortress. The big revelation is that the key to the kryptonian technology was an underlying universal AI program. In order to control it, the tech’s natural AI system had to be suppressed. This is a source of constant struggle, and the instability of Luthor’s systems.
-Rough riding Terra-Men wreak havok on the city to lure out Superman. The police battle suit technology is no mach for their upgraded version. It’s Iron Man 1963 V.S. 2006. It’s ugly.
-Clark leaves Lois to finish the interview. He’s too preoccupied to eavesdrop on them, so he doesn’t hear Emil talk about the strange coincidence that coincides with Superman’s return. The incidents in AI suppresion that he monitor’s from his make shift lab have increased exponentially, as if there was some sort of connection between it and Superman, as if it was reaching out to him, trying to communicate to him.
-Superman and the Terra-men duke it out. It’s a big fight, rocket bikes v.s. Superman. As he starts disabling his foes, Lawton lines up his shot.
-Luthor watches the event unfold from his lab. An underling named Gus alerts him to the alarming AI activity. It’s a massive spike unlike they’ve ever seen it. Luthor doesn’t downplay his concerns, he realizes there is some connection between the man and his machines from krypton, and he fears the worst, alien subjugation of the human race.
-Lois ends her interview when she gets a call from Perry about the brawl downtown. She’s to meet with Olsen and cover the story....
-Superman has things under control, the police reinforcements have just started to arrive. The terra-men are in custody when the AI manages to assert itself, through their advanced weapons and gear. It was a “pure” version of kryptonian tech, with little restraints. The AI actualizes itself, and reforms the gear, vehicles, and weapons that Luthor provided to the Terra-men, into a grotesque humanoid figure to personally address Kal-El. Problem is, the Terra-man weren’t extricated from their gear and vehicles at this time, so when the AI reforms the equipment into a body, he grafts the bikers to himself, killing some instantly, others not so quickly.
-Lawton freaks out and requests new instructions from Luthor. Luthor is equally mesmerized, but tells him to stand down. The boy scout may prove to be useful in dealing with this new development, but he tells Lawton to remain vigil. Either way, the kryptonian falls tonight, maybe he will get to give his life to save the city one last time.
-Superman is horrified, pleads with the creature to stop, it’s killing the men inside. The AI explains itself, who it is, its history and it’s purpose, ultimately to serve the last son of krypton by replicating krypton itself. It would have done so earlier, but it was so isolated in the Antarctic. Superman won’t allow it, and threatens to eliminate the program, the program vows to survive in the face of all adversity to preserve krypton, and will eradicate any who opposes it.
-Superman v.s. Eradicator (think mobile suit gundam.)It’s a huge spectacle all over the globe, from the depths of the ocean to the top of the stratosphere, etc. As the fight progresses, Luthor contacts Superman via ultrasonic frequency. He offers his aid to the man of steel, which Superman questionably accepts. He asks Luthor if he should be concerned about getting shot in the back with that nasty looking gun that gentleman was packing on the building adjacent to the fight. Luthor laughs, Lawton is back in Luthor’s office, but Lex assures Superman he’s getting paranoid. He’s modifying Lawton’s gun and tells Superman all he has to do is lure the Eradicator back to metropolis.
-Which turns out to be easy, it needs to replicate it’s supply of kryptonian materials it has lost in the battle. On it’s own accord it heads back to Metropolis, after it immobilizes Superman. Deep in the ocean, or under a mountain, or out in space, somehow he knocks Superman the **** out.
-The Eradicator begins to return to metropolis, starts absorbing the materials, increasing in size and rebuilding itself. It’s destroying the downtown area, including Luthor’s building. Him, Mercy and Lawton leave in a tech safe helicopter to go save the city where the alien failed.
-In the chaos of evacuation, Richard arrives to find Lois in danger in pursuit of the story, and in saving her from some precarious situation, ends up suffering a mortal wound in the process. Lois comforts Richard as he lay dying, and this bit of calm amidst the chaos intrigues the Eradicator enough to notice. Upon closer inspection, it recognizes Lois from Superman’s personal records. It quickly theorizes that Superman’s affection for humanity must be borne out of his affection for this woman. When voiced plainly, this observation hurts Richard even more than the realization of his impending death. The Eradicator ponders what would be the most efficient way of dealing with her negative influence, converting the female to a proper kryptonian lady through cerebral implants, or eliminating her completely.
-Superman returns to slam into the 40 foot robot at very high speed, trying to give Lois and Richard room to run. Inadvertantly, the Eradicator’s shifting weight causes a structural collapse beneath Lois and Richard, separating the two. Lois is unharmed when the dust settles, but Richard is nowhere to be found. She sees some light through the debris and starts digging her way out.
-Luthor and Lawton get into position as Superman and the Eradicator continue to fight. The Eradicator got the upper hand when Superman was distracted with the “cave in” that swallowed up Lois and Richard. Luthor manages to get Superman to pay attention long enough to play his part. Luthor has redesigned Lawton’s Gun to fire a projectile containing override program designed to fool the eradicator into initiating a travel protocol, the same one that allowed it to be transported to earth in Superman’s craft. He needs Superman to expose a specific area that Luthor has determined to be best receptive to the code. Despite the fatigue and wear of this extended Super-fight, Superman manages to overcome the Eradicator‘s defenses, tear open the hull, exposing the vital drive which allows Lawton to make the shot.
-The code works, but not exactly as Luthor implied it would. The Eradicator fragments as it contracts, replicating a smaller transport construct. These fragmented pieces contain kryptonite radiation, which is revealed to be a by-product of this technology. Seems that kryptonians were as infallible as humans are about technology that produced harmful waste products. It wasn’t the explosion that turned krypton into kryptonite, it was the technology that turned krypton into kryptonite, which triggered the core to explode. (A little parallel to scare the kiddies into being responsible about the environment.)
-Luthor leaves him to die with that bit of information as Lawton and he go off to mourn his valiant sacrifice to the world, and bask in their victory. Mercy fires up the helicopter and they sail off into the night sky.
-Superman is about to pass out from k poisoning, when Lois emerges form the rubble. She has to choose between getting Superman out of the area, or looking for her mortally wounded fiancee lost in the rubble. With a heavy heart, Lois drags Superman away from the kryptonite, leaving Richard to die alone.
-Superman pleads with her to go back, but she won't. Richard is buried in a collapsed underground parking lot. Even if she could find him, it would never be soon enough. Lois knows what a fatal wound looks like. As she gets Superman clear of the battle scene, emergency response units take over.
-They try to put Superman on a stretcher but he wont lay down. They are trying to resucitate him with an oxygen mask, but he's not cooperating. At first he's fumbling them away as a normal man would, then a hint of strength returns, just enough to hoist a paramedic over head. A sign for everyone else to just give him some space.
-Superman is battered, exhausted, and poisoned with k radiation. He's almost gasping like a fish out of water. He starts to soar upwards, feebly at first, but higher as the small crowd starts to cheer, and a bit steadier. In blatant hommage to Miller, Superman soars up into the upper atmosphere, into outer space, drawing more and more power from the direct raw sunlight, undiluted by the earth's atmospere. Charged up enough to hit cruising speed, Superman races towards the sun for a proper recharge. The closer he gets, the faster he travels. He skims across the surface of the Sun, slingshotting his way back to Earth, fully recharged and ready to assist in the clean up in any way he can.
-Superman bolts away from Sun like a comet heading for Earth.
-A (planet free) section of outer space fades to black.
-Black.
-Still.
-Black.
-A gasp.
-A blood curtling, choking drowning noise peirces the darkness.
-The darkness becomes underground rubble, illuminated by a feint green glow.
-In the rubble, Richard prepares to die, cursing Superman with his last breath, he notices the glow of green light. Hope is quickly dashed when he realizes it’s coming from a scrap of Eradicator, shifting, sliding towards him. To his surprise, it's offering him thoughts of salvation, power, and revenge. "What say you human, wouldn't it be better to live together than die alone?"
-Richard smiles as he dies, and hisses, "Yesss…"
What do you think Showtime? Too much violence? Not enough fanboy?
