What you would of liked to of seen in X3?

GuestStar2004

Avenger
Joined
Aug 18, 2004
Messages
23,861
Reaction score
1,723
Points
103
juganaut and coloses fight

juganaut storming the mansion

pynix fire bird effect

Xavia and jean mind battle (as xavia can do alot of things in his mind i could picture all sorts)
 
I would like all the footage to be reassembled, including many of the deleted scenes, to create a 2hr 30mins alternate extended edition. And I'd love to be involved in doing it!
 
just because there is so much room for everyone to complain, etc.

but at the same time, this would probably be a healthier way for everyone to state what the wanted.....
 
Rogue, Storm, Colossus do more in the Danger Room

Phoenix puts Scott in a telekinetic coma

more depth to the Storm creates a storm scene

Prof. X opinion about the cure

how the Phoenix manifest inside Jean/Annie's death explained in the infirmary scene ADD Storm

Angel/WW jr. having a connection to the X-men/the school b4 he jumps out the window

add Psychic voices

add the original Jean displays power at camp scene

Scott awakes and explain the him and jean share a psychic rappore and that he has seen the horror phoenix has done

add the original X-men board the jet scene include Scott Angel

young X-men & Storm show more compassion for Jean

add Scott tells Storm their ready, and she replies I knw, but ARE you ready to do what you have to do when the time comes?

the Lineup: Cyclops,Storm,Logan,Beast,Iceman,Kitty,Angel,Peter

add Jean senses a scared little girl scene

add jean disobeys magento scene

Colossus vs. Juggernaut

Scott vs Mutliple Man

add Storm creates a wave

Magneto vs Angel

Phoenix rapture

Logan/Scott argue over who gets to save Jean

replace Logan w/Scott walking to save jean

Scott is using his optic blast, which she is reflecting using a tk shield

a more emotional scene 'tween Scott/Jean

Kitty/Logan phase behing Jean and stabs her, Jean mouths "I love you" just b4 she dies/collapses in Scotts arms

the rest of the X-Men fly over and crowd around Scott/Jean and mourn

Peter/Kitty are at Prof.X/Jeans grave and share a moment

Storm/Beast/Angel greeting the students

add the original scene Rogue doesnt take the cure

Scott says goodbye to Logan and tells him its up to him to lead the team and keep Xavier's dream alive and they shake hands and Scott departs

Logan walks on to the balcony looks around the camera pans around to Scott on his motorcycle leaving the X-Mansion for good(reminiscient of X1)

add the original idea of raven n magneto in the park....
 
well everything was so final I wouldnt have mind if they had Magneto extracting some of Wolvie's adamantium as a call back to the comics.. and then Magneto gets jumped by Beast so that not all of Wolverine's adamantium was taken out. Ah hell they "permanatized" so much in that movie with all the deaths, they could have had Wolverine coming for Phoenix with bone claws. In the DVD's there is an extended torture sequence between Megneto and Wolverine, so my idea is coming from there. Wouldn't have said it that feature wasnt in there.

it'd be nice if Wolverine had said "Colossus! Fastball Special." It wouldn't have been too cheesy.

Also in the special features for alternate endings they show Wolverine gonig back to the bar of the first film as like an epilogue. This could have been a great thing to see after the credits. Then again that would mean they'd have to leave X3 on in the theaters after everyone left. Time costs money.
 
they already left the screens on for the xavier end scene.

plus i used to work at a movie theater, they always let the movies run all the way through.
 
Rogue, Storm, Colossus do more in the Danger Room

Phoenix puts Scott in a telekinetic coma

more depth to the Storm creates a storm scene

Prof. X opinion about the cure

how the Phoenix manifest inside Jean/Annie's death explained in the infirmary scene ADD Storm

Angel/WW jr. having a connection to the X-men/the school b4 he jumps out the window

add Psychic voices

add the original Jean displays power at camp scene

Scott awakes and explain the him and jean share a psychic rappore and that he has seen the horror phoenix has done

add the original X-men board the jet scene include Scott Angel

young X-men & Storm show more compassion for Jean

add Scott tells Storm their ready, and she replies I knw, but ARE you ready to do what you have to do when the time comes?

the Lineup: Cyclops,Storm,Logan,Beast,Iceman,Kitty,Angel,Peter

add Jean senses a scared little girl scene

add jean disobeys magento scene

Colossus vs. Juggernaut

Scott vs Mutliple Man

add Storm creates a wave

Magneto vs Angel

Phoenix rapture

Logan/Scott argue over who gets to save Jean

replace Logan w/Scott walking to save jean

Scott is using his optic blast, which she is reflecting using a tk shield

a more emotional scene 'tween Scott/Jean

Kitty/Logan phase behing Jean and stabs her, Jean mouths "I love you" just b4 she dies/collapses in Scotts arms

the rest of the X-Men fly over and crowd around Scott/Jean and mourn

Peter/Kitty are at Prof.X/Jeans grave and share a moment

Storm/Beast/Angel greeting the students

add the original scene Rogue doesnt take the cure

Scott says goodbye to Logan and tells him its up to him to lead the team and keep Xavier's dream alive and they shake hands and Scott departs

Logan walks on to the balcony looks around the camera pans around to Scott on his motorcycle leaving the X-Mansion for good(reminiscient of X1)

add the original idea of raven n magneto in the park....


omg, i love all of this! except, at the end, id have scott tell ororo to lead the team, not logan.

plus id add more rogue scenes! she seriously lacked them!

i dont remember if it was just a rumor or a part in an early draft, but rogue was supposed to talk to her mom from X1, about taking the cure....not being sure about it, and wanted advice....

plus id add that once she got off the bus to the cure station, she sees a young deformed mutant girl holding an anti-cure picket sign. and then it would show her again looking confused......

i think those would have added a much more emotional side to her dilemna, rather than a robotic..."im going to do this, ive gone to do this, i just got this done"...feel.

and then another scene showcasing her powers, and her feeling more comfortable with them, really showing how much shes progressed with them.
 
Last edited:
Rogue flying...What was up with the no flying...And no super strength...?
 
No wonder she gave in...The writers didn't give her the proper powers...She got ripped off...!
 
I think whatever had happened in X3 would have generated fan criticism of some level, because there are so many characters to try to service. Thjere's always going to be disappointment.

Everyone here seemed to want X3 to include everything that had been in the previous two movies AND everything that HADN'T been in the previous movies. Fans didn't like the closure of story arcs because they want to imagine it's like the comics where everything goes on for ever, nothing changes permanently and everyone is forever young and beautiful.

I'd never want to see Cyclops killed off or Wolverine take centre stage, yet it happened inexorably since the two characters were first introduced back in the first movie, so it was of no surprise to me. I think it could have been better if Cyclops and Jean died together in a sacrificial fiery Phoenix blast, but her being stabbed by Wolverine did happen in comic book stories so it didn't just come from nowhere.

I think the killing off of Cyclops was the film-makers' greatest error, as I think a lot of the negativity here has grown from that.

But Cyclops just isn't the rugged action hero / anti-hero that Wolverine is. And Jackman's portrayal (against the casting/acting of James Marsden, who is a great guy but just not as powerful on screen) sealed the fate of the characters.
 
I think whatever had happened in X3 would have generated fan criticism of some level, because there are so many characters to try to service. Thjere's always going to be disappointment.

Everyone here seemed to want X3 to include everything that had been in the previous two movies AND everything that HADN'T been in the previous movies. Fans didn't like the closure of story arcs because they want to imagine it's like the comics where everything goes on for ever, nothing changes permanently and everyone is forever young and beautiful.

I'd never want to see Cyclops killed off or Wolverine take centre stage, yet it happened inexorably since the two characters were first introduced back in the first movie, so it was of no surprise to me. I think it could have been better if Cyclops and Jean died together in a sacrificial fiery Phoenix blast, but her being stabbed by Wolverine did happen in comic book stories so it didn't just come from nowhere.

I think the killing off of Cyclops was the film-makers' greatest error, as I think a lot of the negativity here has grown from that.

But Cyclops just isn't the rugged action hero / anti-hero that Wolverine is. And Jackman's portrayal (against the casting/acting of James Marsden, who is a great guy but just not as powerful on screen) sealed the fate of the characters.

Kind of seems like you are blaming Hugh for his awesome portrayal which made X3 go south...Which kind of is true because he was more marketable therefore from a movie stand point...There is no X-Men without Wolverine...
 
Kind of seems like you are blaming Hugh for his awesome portrayal which made X3 go south...Which kind of is true because he was more marketable therefore from a movie stand point...There is no X-Men without Wolverine...

I wouldn't use the word 'blaming' but...yes...basically that's what i meant. Jackman is charismatic and likeable.
 
they already left the screens on for the xavier end scene.

plus i used to work at a movie theater, they always let the movies run all the way through.

What did you mean about the xavier end scene? Was that about my post? I didn't mention Xavier at all so..?

Also maybe you played all the way through, but not every movie theaters plays the reels all the way through. Just how it is.
 
What did you mean about the xavier end scene? Was that about my post? I didn't mention Xavier at all so..?

Also maybe you played all the way through, but not every movie theaters plays the reels all the way through. Just how it is.


you said that they should have used that wolverine in the bar scene and put it after the credits. i was just saying they already had a scene at the end of the credits....the xavier one.
 
Wolverine taking Cyclops' role in the story I could definitely have dealt with, if only Cyclops' death was handled a bit more respectfully rather than using him as an off-screen redshirt.

Also, 2 words: ICE SLIDE.
 
Wolverine taking Cyclops' role in the story I could definitely have dealt with, if only Cyclops' death was handled a bit more respectfully rather than using him as an off-screen redshirt.

Also, 2 words: ICE SLIDE.

I believe an ice-slide was in one screenplay draft (as his entrance on to Alcatraz). The problem is it would have been a bit out there, considering he'd never used his powers so extensively before.

At least he moved from freezing a cup of coffee in X2 to freezing a pond in X3, and he did at least 'ice up' at the end, which seemed a more natural progression.

I think evolving from that to an ice slide would be good in the next film, if there is one. But he was never presented as powerful enough to ice up all the time and ice-slide all over the place - that's probably a bit comicbooky for the tone set in the films. They struggled enough with how to portray him icing up in a realistic way - the comicbook image of someone virtually naked and covered in white ice - and moving freely despite being encased in ice - is not exactly compatible with the world Singer established.

But, as I said, further training that led to him being able to form an ice-slide (even though such slides defy the laws of physics regarding centre of gravity) might be good for a future film. Emma Frost helped Iceman develop control of his powers in the comics, so that's one possibility for an X4.
 
well...
-Focusing either on 'Dark Phoenix' or 'The Cure', not trying to do both

-Cyclops not dying

-Wolverine AND Cyclops going for Jean in the forest

-More exposure and development of the new team

-Colossus VS. Juggernaut

-Either Cyclops giving that "We're X-Men" speech in the film or Wolverine giving that "You might not come home" speech from the tv spots

-the REAL Psylocke!

...for starters
 
Rogue flying...What was up with the no flying...And no super strength...?

She only had those powers because she absorbed them from Ms. Marvel, it wouldnt have made any sense for her to start flying and have super strength without getting them from somewhere. They then would have had to try to explain why she would permanently have the powers.
 
Like a few have said, extend the cut with some of the deleted and alternate scenes - it would have fleshed out the movie a bit more.

Rogue was coming into her own in X2, but that evolution into a sassier, stronger personality pretty much ended in The Last Stand. I, of course, would have kept that and would not have her take the cure. Consider it? Yes. Take it? Never.

The Kitty and Bobby relationship subplot was entirely unnecessary. :down

I was not at all a fan of the Dark Phoenix effects. Demonic, corpse-like appearance? That's not the Phoenix. :huh:

I would have preferred if the Cure plot took a backseat to what the film should have been about the Phoenix. I can see why they put the Cure at the forefront - it made sense to the overall trilogy; First film - mutants trying to turn humans into mutants, second film - mutants and humans trying to end each other, third film - humans trying to turn mutants into humans. But I don't see why it was necessary to take devour most of the film when it easily could have made for a great subplot. The Dark Phoenix Saga is a far more important story to tell.

I quite enjoyed Cyclops' character in X3... I just wished we could have seen more of it. And, even if his screen time had to be shafted (which it certainly shouldn't have, considering he played a huge role in the Dark Phoenix Saga), they didn't need to kill him off. I understand that his death was supposed to drive Jean to insanity, but I'm pretty sure she was insane when she killed him. So, I really wished he could have had more screen time, but if he couldn't, I would have at least preferred he survived. This was, by far, my biggest problem with the film.
 
I was not at all a fan of the Dark Phoenix effects. Demonic, corpse-like appearance? That's not the Phoenix. :huh:

Just wanted to point out that the Dark Phoenix (in the original X-Men comic books) does look pale, demonic and shadowy-eyed....

darkphoen1og7.jpg
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"