Which of these 3 were better?

[Mr. Socko]

These are arugably the best comic book movies ever created and the critics surely loved them. My question is, which is your favorite?

 

[Darkred]

Wow, i m clueless. Thoes are the best three socko you're right but i actually, honestly dont know. Batman is my favourite character and then spiderman. I m not to keen on X-men but X2 was genius. I m torn between between begins and spidey 2, its one of thoes.

 

[Kevin Roegele]

These are arugably the best comic book movies ever created and the critics surely loved them. My question is, which is your favorite?

Dude, you forgot Superman the Movie.

 

[Isildur´s Heir]

These are arugably the best comic book movies ever created.

No, they aren´t
But X2 is definetely my second favorite comic book movie

My question is, which is your favorite?

X2
Followed by Batman Begins and Spider-Man 2

 

[Silver Sable]

It'a a tie for me

 

[The Kid]

begins is a good start to the new batman franchise, well enough at least but it's brought down by that ridiculous water vaporizor machine, and silly stuff batman does even though he says he's no executioner, it tries too hard to be serious and epic but puts stupid oneliners and gags in so it feels uneven at points, and I challenge anyone to tell me what was going on during those fights. I get that the first fight was to show him as some creature attacking a bunch of thugs, lol, got it. But all the time? katie holmes was good though. I enjoyed everything about her in this film...

Spidey 2 was excellent film making for the most part. Some bone headed ideas got through though. Ock throwing the car, chocolate cake, spidey's mask coming off every minute, him losing his powers due to not getting his MJ(jesus christmas, how much more obvioius can one make the whole idea of love uplifting your spirits. And it opens too many questions about how his powers work...), great action scenes, not so great story, really.

X2. pure win. Brilliant. Extremely enjoyable and considering how many characters needed to be given time in some way, an amazing achievement for comicbook movies. most struggle with just one, x had around ten or so to do 'something' with and it's so well made and fun. I couldn't believe how good an x-men film this was. X2 you are a god among comicbook films, never let anyone tell you different.

 

[Shadow_Knight]

Batman Begins gets my vote.

 

[CConn]

I'd rank them just as they're listed on the poll: (1) BB, (2) SM2, (3) X2.

 

[Shuley]

Spider-Man 2 > Batman Begins > X2 I liked X2 but it wasn't that great,neither was the acting.

 

[Mee]

Danananananah nanananah BATMAN!

 

[co2]

Now we are talking about a contest!! Yea, those are the three best in my opinion.
Personally I'd have to say Spider-Man 2 > Batman Begins > X2, but only by the thinest of margins.
I think this one comes down to just which character you prefer most. I'm getting a strong feeling that come the end of July, Superman Returns will make that list too.

 

[co2]

Dude, you forgot Superman the Movie.

Yeah that's the only other one that I feel might be included in that elite list.

 

[Chris Wallace]

Spidey.

 

[britrogue]

X-2 without a doubt.

 

[Zaphod]

1) X2
2) Batman Begins
3) Spider-Man 2

In a perfect world, I'd probaly rank 'Begins' and 'X2' on par with each other, both are equally superb when they get things right, but both make some exceptions to the source-material (Iceman not Iceing up, Scarecrows lack of costume etc) which waters down certain factors which could have otherwise been great, limiting their potential. 'Spider-Man 2' makes the biggest mistake in this department, diluting the character of Doc Ock so much, earning the movie its place at the weakest end of the spectrum in position '3'.

 

[Two-Face]

Batman Begins

 

[HighVoltage]

These are arugably the best comic book movies ever created and the critics surely loved them. My question is, which is your favorite?

I´m sorry, but Batman Begins is not in same league with X2 and Spidey 2.

X2 and Spidey 2 have better stories in its scripts, and a better development on the screen, in comparison with Batman Begins.

Even X2 and Spidey 2 have stories from comicbooks, Batman Begins only has a story from different movies, even other Batman movies.

The funny is every thread about Batman Begins is desperately a poll, to prove this movie is better than other comicbook movies.

Batman Begins vs X2 and Spidey, please that´s ridiculous.

Batman Begins vs Sin City, nice try, but Sin City is more realistic and darker that every Batman Movie.

Batman Begins vs Fantastic Four, the only problem about FF was Doctor Doom, because Reed, Sue, Johnny and Ben have the same style from comics, but nobody is saying the problems of Batman Begins:
Qui gon..... I mean, Henry Ducard is the master of Bruce Wayne?
Ra´s Al Ghul is another master for Bruce Wayne, wth?

Talia is not part of the league of shadows.

Lucious Fox is the copy of "Q" from James Bond movies, what original.

Talking about 007, Christian Bale is the version of Bruce Wayne meets
James Bond, yeah, that two girls from the bar is an example, even the gadgets are a proof.

The Scarecrow was a waste for this movie, he was a real menace for Gotham and Batman, but the Scarecrow was wasted in favor of other characters and plots, hey, but nobody was crying about this.

Please, stop these polls, Batman Begins is not in same level with X2, Spidey 2 or even with Fantastic Four.

 

[Katsuro]

Batman Begins > Spider-Man 2 > X2: X-Men United. That's my order, although they're all amazing movies. Also, fourth and fifth are X-Men, and Spider-Man, respectivley. I expect Superman Returns to jump in there somewhere come the end of the month, though.

Please, stop these polls, Batman Begins is not in same level with X2, Spidey 2 or even with Fantastic Four.

Funny how it wins them all then, isn't it?

 

[AVEITWITHJAMON]

I´m sorry, but Batman Begins is not in same league with X2 and Spidey 2.

X2 and Spidey 2 have better stories in its scripts, and a better development on the screen, in comparison with Batman Begins.

Even X2 and Spidey 2 have stories from comicbooks, Batman Begins only has a story from different movies, even other Batman movies.

The funny is every thread about Batman Begins is desperately a poll, to prove this movie is better than other comicbook movies.

Batman Begins vs X2 and Spidey, please that´s ridiculous.

Batman Begins vs Sin City, nice try, but Sin City is more realistic and darker that every Batman Movie.

Batman Begins vs Fantastic Four, the only problem about FF was Doctor Doom, because Reed, Sue, Johnny and Ben have the same style from comics, but nobody is saying the problems of Batman Begins:
Qui gon..... I mean, Henry Ducard is the master of Bruce Wayne?
Ra´s Al Ghul is another master for Bruce Wayne, wth?

Talia is not part of the league of shadows.

Lucious Fox is the copy of "Q" from James Bond movies, what original.

Talking about 007, Christian Bale is the version of Bruce Wayne meets
James Bond, yeah, that two girls from the bar is an example, even the gadgets are a proof.

The Scarecrow was a waste for this movie, he was a real menace for Gotham and Batman, but the Scarecrow was wasted in favor of other characters and plots, hey, but nobody was crying about this.

Please, stop these polls, Batman Begins is not in same level with X2, Spidey 2 or even with Fantastic Four.

I'm sorry but your wrong, i understand your opinion, but most critics and fans alike consider BB to be the best of the bunch and i have to say i am in agreement with them, and i dont even like Batman that much. X-Men and Spiderman have been, and will always be my favourite comic book characters, and the first 2 movies of each of those franchises are great (just hope spidey 3 isnt as bad as X3). Spidey 2 and X2 are both the pinnacle of marvel movies, and will remain so for quite a while IMO, but Batman Begins is far superior to both of them, it has the most epic feel and you genuinly care for all the main characters.

Oh, and i wish people would stop going on about the microwave emitter vaporising water in peoples bodies, the movie clearly states that the machine uses FOCUSED microwaves. Pay attention people

 

[Ronny Shade]

I love all three of these movies, but there's something to be said for the fact that I can watch BB over and over and over without getting sick of it. Therefore I vote BB.

 

[Dr. Fate]

Batman Begins owns both X2 and Spider-Man 2.

 

[mathhater]

None of the above...Superman the Movie...my favorite film of all time.
But of those 3, and it's a really tough choice cause I like 'em all, but I think I'd have to go with Batman Begins. I rarely, RARELY see a movie more than once in a theater, and I watched Batman Begins 3 times...a lot for me...just barely beating the double screening I did for Spidey 2.

 

[nogap87]

Spidey. Though each one was lacking in one area or another.

 

[AVEITWITHJAMON]

I love all three of these movies, but there's something to be said for the fact that I can watch BB over and over and over without getting sick of it. Therefore I vote BB.

I know, i must have watched it 40 times now, and i still want to watch it more.

 

[DeRaNgEd OnE]

Batman Begins was one of the best movies I have ever seen. The only problem I had with it was the whole Fear and using fear on those who cause fear and Bruce is afraid of bats, and Scarecrow is master of fear and on. Too many fear lines in the movie. Other then that, great.