Dread
TMNT 1984-2009
- Joined
- Oct 11, 2001
- Messages
- 21,788
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 31
I feel some day Dread is going to reveal himself to actually be like John Byrne or Greg Weisman.
Wolverine shouldn't be held accountable for this because IT WASN'T HIS FAULT. Unless falling in love with a hot Japanese woman makes him guilty. Wolverine did what he thought was right even though he loved Mariko. He stayed awa from her. He didn't bring that on the X-men. The Yakuza brought it to them.
Is what happened to the mansion and Xavier the fault of the X-men and Xavier?
Please.
Bryne's past his prime, but I wouldn't mind being Weisman. I'll admit to being one of the two if you admit to being Craig Kyle

Most of my last post was nitpicking about the X-Men jobbing to ninjas in a fight, but whatever.
Wolverine could have sat down and briefed the X-Men on some of the threats to his past. Something Xavier never did and could have made their lives a lot easier, or at least a little less unpredictable. "Hey, look, there's some secret cabal of military people who gave me my bones, and some ninjas have a vendetta against me." Instead Logan did what he always does, keep all his secrets to himself, which worked when he was a loner, not the leader. Fortunately for him, not one member of the X-Men will address that. Xavier will just pat his back and say "Atta boy". Scott is too busy being a whimpering mess. Storm is a non-entity. And Frost usually only offers a wry quip. Rogue once tried to hold Logan responsible for his constant biker quests, but now that's over. If this is an "X-Men team with internal tension", I'd hate to imagine a cohesive unit.
In interviews with Brian M. Bendis, the writer of the latest Marvel event comic SECRET INVASION, he often described interested nuances and dynamics that he claimed were in the mini, but had little to do with his actual core event. It led some critics to wish that they could have "read the comic in his head" in so many words. Well, in some ways I am in the same position with this show. On the whole, it is a good show. But it is a frustrating one because that bar from "good" to "great" is so very close, but the writing staff just isn't on the ball right now. In interviews Kyle and Johnson describe dynamics or ideas that are barely passing details in the show they have actually written. I imagine WOLVERINE AND THE X-MEN was more interesting and had better characterization in their heads than on screen.
Considering SPECTACULAR SPIDER-MAN by Greg Wiesman is an episode ahead of W&TXM (on episode 19 while W&TXM is gearing up for 18 this week), I didn't want to start comparing, but I may as well. There are two things that Wiesman's show has over this one. Dismissing, of course, the genre differences between Spider-Man and the X-Men, and Wiesman's superior TV experience. One is that SS-M is better able to shift the mood in the show; it can go from comedy to adventure to even creepy horror within moments. W&TXM is not very good at that; beyond some wisecracks now and again, it goes from serious to very serious to darkly serious. While that is part of the X-Men franchise, it hasn't been an angle that has helped it long term. The other difference is that subtle character nuances, characters reacting to each other with almost no line being throwaway, is essential in SS-M. In W&TXM, the plot is the main thing and characters are essentially along for the ride, beyond of course a focus episode now and again (or six times if you are the titular Wolverine). Characters are simple and blunt, with little nuance unless it is part of the plot.
This cartoon is essentially the opposite of X-MEN EVOLUTION; that show often had weak or mundane plots in most of it's episodes, at least until the end of Season 2 into Season 3, and relied almost exclusively on character interaction for a good, long while. Some of that was likely because the Kid's WB network people got in the way of things, such as the original game-plan for Spyke. With WOLVERINE AND THE X-MEN, it is almost as of Kyle and Johnson are so thrilled to have little restrictions on the kind of epic stories they want to do that they've all but gladly sacrificed a lot of the character stuff. The problem with that, of course, is that an adventure story is merely a video game without deep compelling characters. Look at FANTASTIC FOUR: WGH; that show pretty much literally relied most of it's strength on character interaction between the Four, and it actually worked for a bit to cover the fact that it had no central subplots nor was the action usually fulfilling.
Is WOLVERINE AND THE X-MEN better than many cartoon shows on TV? Yes, without question. Is it better by episode 17 than X-MEN EVOLUTION was, as a whole? Sure, I'll give it that for now. The lack of the meddling Kid's WB has been a welcome change to things. But without managing to really nail down those nuances, without just a little more depth or complexity, W&TXM will have to settle for being Good rather than Great, and when Greatness is so, so close, that can be very frustrating for me as a fan. Those story subplots keep me watching, but very rarely is there any nuance to make me rewatch. Character cameo's are not nuance. A 2.5 minute scene where Logan would have to justify an action to Kitty and Storm's well minded objections would be worth a million Rockslide cameo appearances; part of what made, say, Captain Kirk so defining was that he did have to justify his sometimes seemingly reckless behavior to Bones or Spock. Deep down I believe Kyle & Johnson (and sometimes Yost, who has written a little for the show) know this, and I can only hope these matters start improving, and real fast.
My little sis watches those anime thingies which honestly bore me to death. And yes she does do that! Even I used to do that with cartoons when I was a kidThank God I grew out of it. Pretty sure she will too.
But apparently guys don’t mature at all. My bro and cousins still rant on and on about this superhero being more powerful than thatAnd now the writers and their man-love for Wolvie. They could’ve used poison! Or some virus to take down the X-men!
Oh and I ran into the online WATXM game on Marvel’s website and guess what the missions were? Rescue Cyclops, rescue Beast, rescue Shadowcat and Rogue and so on. I’m on level 8 right now![]()
They thought knock out gas was good enough, even though they clearly showed nearly every X-Man unable to defend themselves against more than one ninja.
Heh, least the games are reflective.

I get that but haven't they done "stealth" missions in the previous episodes...i don't know...you guys seem to have better memory when it comes to info like this.
So my question is...why now? Why the stealth costumes now? I know this is a kids show but i would actually like to hear a throw away line or just a one-liner explaining the opting of the black costumes out of the blue...so to speak.
The stealth costumes first showed up in episode 16, "Badlands". As for why now, I don't know. Not mentioning those little things is just one of those things one has to deal with in this show. Maybe Logan had just thought of it.
A better question is why Logan sticks with his bright yellows when he goes on solo biker quests that likely require stealth, too.

They did make a point to mention how the ninjas were highly trained assassins. I mean, c'mon they're damned ninjas. If it wasn't for their blatant overuse as henchmen in cartoons (mainly ninja turtles) they'd be untouchable badasses.
Unfortunately, things like reality, such as the overuse of ninjas, HAVE to be taken into consideration.
Picture this example. Not all of the henchmen that are employed in Gotham City are lacking any fighting skills. Some of those guys must be good brawlers. I can imagine some even boxers or martial artists. Yet if a squad of no name goons burst into the Batcave and effortlessly defeated Batman, Robin, Alfred, and Batgirl, just so Nightwing could eventually come upon the scene and do a rescue, would any of that matter? Or would you just watch the TV and say, "Everyone got owned by nobodies"? It wouldn't matter if they were all trained by Batman's sensai or whatever; all that would matter in the reality was that everyone would be jobbing to Grayson. And no matter how great the episode was, it would be that little niggle that keeps it at A- rather than A+ grade. And sometimes those niggles bother me.
Seeping the gas into the ventilation system would have accomplished the same goal, and avoided the idea of the X-Men all losing en masse to worthless ninja. Ninja are canon fodder in anime, movies, comics, TV shows, and every single damn work of fiction known to mankind. Unless they are named characters, minions like them are sheep, and losing to sheep lessons your efficiency meter.
I think the point the writers are trying to make (and failing) with the X-Men constantly getting owned, is that they're still not what they once were. They don't have the teamwork they did before disbanding. Oh well.
You are right; that is what the show is intending, but without that nuanced character interaction that is mostly sacrificed for storyline and endless cameo appearances, that "disunity" of the X-Men is not apparent. The 90's X-MEN cartoon had Xavier as headmaster, Cyclops as leader and Wolverine as rebel, and that team was FAR more disunited than anything Kyle & Johnson have yet written here. So far, they have essentially written a show that, no matter how good it is, no matter how cool the main storyline may be, says that the X-Men are absolutely nothing without Wolverine. No one embodies the ideals more than him. None of the X-Men are as competent, or dangerous. Weapon X has the right idea; rather than recruit a dozen members, they just endlessly try to clone Wolverine. Same with Trask; make an army of robot Wolverine's. Wolverine is so awesome that he can make mistakes, or be reckless, or even have deadly enemies who come without warning, and everyone still loves him anyway. He's like Thing only without the sense of humor, or humility.
The only character on this show who comes close to upstaging Logan is Nightcrawler, which may be conveniently why Kurt is often missing in some of the episodes since rejoining. The writers obviously like him and would have had problems with showing him jobbing to Ninjas, so he magically wasn't shown.
I mean the premise really is sound; the irony is that in seeing the execution of it across 17 episodes, part of me kind of wishes it was actually handled better. It had potential for a cartoon. Instead there is always a feeling that they pull back or simplify for TV, when the best shows are the ones that throw caution to the wind. It takes risk to be timeless. The premise alone with Wolverine being the star attraction is NOT a risk for an X-Men cartoon; that is like saying a Dragon Ball series that focused on Goku exclusively was risky. It could have been deeper than it is, though, and it is frustrating for me that it isn't. These writers are more than capable.
The scene could have worked better if they would have had the ninjas stealthing up on each member individually and gassing them, without being noticed. Not giving the X-Men a chance to futilly fight back, making them look like chumps. Anyone can lose when you're blindsided, if you get owned face to face it's another story.
See? You, an unpaid novice, figured a way around that dilemma in a better manner than a paid professional who had maybe a week or two to write the episode. That says something to me. It says that there seems to always be some unseen invisible wall with this show, where the writers pull back and say, "okay, let's not go too far, this is for a mainstream audience." I am like, no, DON'T pull back. Take those risks!
Last edited: