I saw the thing I posted in this thread from a few years ago ... And yeah, my "worst moment" still stands: Giants vs. Eagles at home in December 2010 (when the Giants blew a 21-point lead in the final 7 minutes). If you're an Eagles fan, you call it "The Miracle At The Meadowlands." If you're a Giants fan, you call it "The Meltdown At The Meadowlands."
Worst. Loss. Ever. I have PTSD from that damn game, I think. I was actually in freakout mode while watching Silver Linings Playbook for the first time. For a little bit, I really thought they were going to reference that game because they kept making a big deal out of the DeSean Jackson jersey. Luckily, that reference didn't happen, so I was able to continue loving the film.
My apologies to one of the posters above, but ... Super Bowls XLII and XLVI are my favorite moments as a sports fan. I'm dead serious when I tell people that Super Bowl XLII is still one of the best nights of my life.
But hey, New England won another Super Bowl just a year ago. The Patriots are definitely in a better state than my G-Men are right now.
EDIT:
I do have a "soul crushing" moment from this past NFL season. I mean, the entire 2015 season for the Giants was
rough ... But the game that "broke" me this year was their matchup against the Saints. It was a lot of back and forth, then the Saints gained a significant lead, then the Giants tied them near the end ... Only to have the Giants defense collapse at the last second for the Saints to win by a field goal. Still not as bad as The Meltdown At The Meadowlands, but I felt like CRAP after that Saints game. I knew the season was over after that.
The 2015 Giants, for the most part, knew how to play a 59-minute game. The final minute is what killed us this year, which was one of the most frustrating things to witness as a fan. Again, though ... Still not as bad as the "Meltdown" in 2010.