I am not going to get into the more filmmaker qualities that I prefer with TFA over TLJ. I think the idea that TLJ, which is full of supbar green screen is somehow a better looking movie then TFA is kind of crazy. But that just feels like a dance nobody wants.
But I will say, no movie had ever got me more invested outside of the OT. It is really that simple. Since I can remember, Star Wars has been my thing. And after seeing TFA, I was happier then I had ever been walking out of the theater. Not just the first time either. The other 4 times I saw it in theaters, and the 50 or so times I have watched it at home. It doesn't feel like Star Wars to me, it is Star Wars. It is everything I grew up loving. Its a beautiful looking film, with characters I instantly fell in love with, while honoring everything that I love about what came before in Star Wars. The movie is fun, funny, and thrilling to me, and never once treats the audience like it is some error to love Star Wars. It has two real errors to me imo, but to me those are very small and I call look past them.
I can understand that it did not have that effect on you. But I probably have never spent more time discussing a movie then TFA. Looking back on it, reflecting on it. TLJ had a very big impact on me, but not a good one. Especially in terms of a lasting impact. One of my great worries is that after IX, I will see the end of TFA, Rey climbing those Jedi Steps and meeting Luke ****ing Sykwalker, and instead of getting that rush of adrenaline, I will instead look on it with sadness at what could have been.
Help me JJ Abrams. You are my only hope.

t: