le sigh...I haven't and will not read some of the opinions in this thread. However, when I was looking through some of my old posts I saw this and it did make me wonder about some folks....
THREAD: TDK...to dark for kids....
http://forums.superherohype.com/showthread.php?p=15217792&highlight=#post15217792
charl huntress - As a side note to this discussion, my sister asked me if she should let my niece and nephew see TDK because she "heard" its too violent for kids. She wanted my opinion because she knows of my hidden geek nature. Anyway, I'm not saying TDK is too violent, but all this talk might make some parents shy away. My niece is 11 and my nephew is 14. My sister read a review that said TDK should have been "R" rated. My nephew is crazy siked to see this since he's been a fan of The Batman cartoon.
captain clown - you should watch it first then decide.
charl huntress - I will, but I watched movies that I think were worse when I was younger. LOL...I watched Raw Deal when I was like 8 years old. I am fine and not in bad shape, but kids today....well...they are different. I'm not sure what to say because...I don't have any kids.
So much f-ing pressure.....

t:
captain clown - Ya, I think we need an objective eye to figure if we "didn't turn out too bad" after seeing these movies. Also we aren't these kids either so what works for us definitly might not work for them. I think this movie might have its moments of freaking kids out though.
Lots o lafs - As long as there's no nudity in it who cares if a kid watches it. If he can get in he can see it that's my motto.
Anubis Raptor - Pretty much mine to.
Lots of lafs - Although I don't have kids I take my little cousins to all kinds of stuff.
charl huntress - Hope someone doesn't blow up a school/building/arena/etc in your area trying to imitate the Joker in TDK...if they do let me know how you feel about that
You have to censor stuff because certain sectors of society are not always capable of differentiating between real life and fiction. They may take the angst a character feels to a personal level and try to imitate something they saw to obtain the power of a fictional character. Stuff like that happens all the time, and children do that frequently.
I know my niece and nephew are good kids, but the reality of movies is potent and life-changing for some.
http://forums.superherohype.com/showthread.php?p=15217792&highlight=#post15217792
Dude obviously wasn't a kid, but maybe we need ratings for adults too...