Senator Pleasury
Sidekick
- Joined
- May 26, 2013
- Messages
- 2,844
- Reaction score
- 5
- Points
- 31
Spider-man 3 is better than Batman & Robin. That holds some credibility.
we did SM1 VS TASM and guess who won... TASM
To be honest, I may have actually thought this poll wouldn't be such a dominated one with 103-17.
What is the world is cold and depressing about Batman Begins?Meh. Still prefer ASM to BB and no poll is going to change my mind on that. BB is too cold and depressing for me to watch over and over and ultimately rewatch value is how I personally judge my favorites.
Good concept /= good execution. Some of us simply think that it was presented poorly. BB started off strong, but like far too many films in the genre it lost traction once the hero was fully formed. I found it boring after Bruce's initial journey.What is the world is cold and depressing about Batman Begins?
I always find it odd when people seem to not like their superheroes to have a legit threat to face. Bruce is confronted with a city on the brink of death. It is a fantastic starting point.
Good concept /= good execution. Some of us simply think that it was presented poorly. BB started off strong, but like far too many films in the genre it lost traction once the hero was fully formed. I found it boring after Bruce's initial journey.
Meh. Still prefer ASM to BB and no poll is going to change my mind on that. BB is too cold and depressing for me to watch over and over and ultimately rewatch value is how I personally judge my favorites.
BB is nowhere as cold and depressing as TAS-M is as a film
You know what, I kinda agree with that. I really enjoyed TASM but it definitely seems very cold and depressing in some ways compared to BB. And Batman is supposed to be more cold and depressing than the world of Spider-Man hehe.
What is depressing about ASTM? That uncle Ben was killed and Peter could have prevented it? That he feels the weight of the world on his shoulders? That he can't be with the girl he wants without having problems?
Not necessarily the story which is very Peter Parker accurate but the world it exists in seemed quite "darker" than the generally light-heartiness generally with Spider-Man. In terms of the looks or cinematography.
2 Types of people have picked TASM in this poll:
1. Spider man Fan boys
2. People who have never seen Batman Begins
Scarecrow was nowhere near as wasted as Lizard.
Watch BB again, you have obviously missed a lot.
2 Types of people have picked TASM in this poll:
1. Spider man Fan boys
2. People who have never seen Batman Begins
You know what, I kinda agree with that. I really enjoyed TASM but it definitely seems very cold and depressing in some ways compared to BB. And Batman is supposed to be more cold and depressing than the world of Spider-Man hehe.
Scarecrow was nowhere near as wasted as Lizard.
Pretty much. Scarecrow was still recognizably Scarecrow. A genuinely creepy psychologist with an obsession of fear. The scene where he sprays Batman with the toxin is one of the genre's most disturbing scenes. As for how easy he was taken down, he was never much of a physical fighter.
Lizard had his heart and soul ripped out. It was the worst version of that character since the goofy 60s animated version.
Also Lizard was the main villain of his film. Scarecrow was a minor villain working for the real one. Even if their adaptations were equally poor (which they weren't), Lizard would be worse than Scarecrow on that alone.
I loved scarecrow in the TDK series and frankly as scary as he was supposed to be i enjoyed the levity that he brought to the series especially in TDK and TDKR.
I'm a DC fangirl, and I found BB to be the better-crafted film, but I still preferred TASM overall. Why? 1.) None of the dialogue in TASM had me cringing as much as some of Goyer's worst moments in BB. 2.) Emma Stone/Gwen Stacy was a FAR superior love interest and I felt the connections with most of the relationships more. 3.) I liked the action scenes more. 4.) The score for TASM is one of my favorite superhero scores ever. BB's? I enjoy it, but it doesn't have that "magic" for me. 5.) I loved the characterization of Spidey so much. It was much closer to the one I'm familiar with than the Raimi versions were, whereas the Nolan Batman, much as I loved it, wasn't as close to the Batman I grew up with. 6.) The weakest factor in TASM - the villain - just happens to be the aspect I care the least about in all superhero flicks, so it didn't bother me the way it bothered most.2 Types of people have picked TASM in this poll:
1. Spider man Fan boys
2. People who have never seen Batman Begins