lol. Um...They're completely different movies, so, I really couldn't compare them using the same scale.
I'd say, they're on the same level more or less. American Gangster might be half a increment down. Like, if Body of Lies is a 8/10, AG would get a 7.75/10
Cons:
-The movie is a suspense/thriller. It's not an action movie like some may think. It's not a particular con for me, but it could be for others.
-The movie has a relatively slow pace, even for suspense film.
-Clocking in at 128 minutes, the movie could've lost ten of them.
-The movie is a tad conventional and gets predictable once the story gets going.
-The thematic material may be threaten some audiences.
Pros:
-Ridley Scott. He's great at details, picking locations, getting great shots and has a knack for visually stimulating the screen, even when nothing's happening. The action is few and far between, but also real, gritty, and captivating.
-RusDiCaprio. They're a hell of a team here, even though they only share a handful of scenes together. Great acting out of the two. Both equally strong in their own way.
-Even for a slow suspense movie, it almost never drags. This feeling is supported by the nice score provided by Marc Streitenfeld.
Hmmm..Maybe I could knock this down to a 7.75 and AG to a 7.5/10, now that I realize that there were a few more cons that I'd realized..
-TNC