Bone claws!?

[The_Guyver]

Bone Claws Dammit!!

 

[The Geek Vault]

It depends how far we're going back if we are focused on weapon X then no bone claws. If we go as far back as origin then I'd say yes. The bone claws wouldn't have to be as sharp and as lone. I'd say maybe show them as the size of a middle finger.

 

[MrSelfDestruct]

They don't necessarily need to be bone claws. Look at cat claws. They're not made of bone, and they can support a cat's bodyweight. They'd also be thin enough to cover with adamantium. Also, to whoever said that Wolverine couldn't have had claws before the WX experiments because he acted surprised when they popped out for the first time: He had no memory of his life prior to the experiment.

 

[kaijunexus]

Bone Claws would be great to see if his adamantium claws are ripped out and his bone ones heal back up. Then, of course, they'd have to think up some way of getting them coated in adamantium again, but I doubt it'd be a big problem.

 

[z21]

The thing is, if you stay in continuity with x1, x2 and x3, then logan shouldn't have "bone claws". Reasons: 1)Stryker says i gave you claws 2)Logan's admantium claws in the three movies are very narrow and thing (sort of like a knife) so itmakes it imporbable that there is bone under the metal

 

[jim_root_rules]

sum ppl are acting liek there as thin as paper, the size and shape of them if not a problem at all, they can easily have bone under them

 

[Decay]

In x-men 3 Didn't beast say something like"I have been fighting for mutant rights before you had claws"

I hate the bone claws,Its even too far fetched in a movie of a guy with metal claws.enough said

Hmm...yeah...maybe the history of the movie character is different from the comic books one, and so Wolverine got his claws after that experiment.

 

[jim_root_rules]

he sed tht as a joke to imply he had more experience than wolverine, beast dosent know wolverine is like 100 or anything about wolverine other than wot he herd from prof x

 

[Decay]

I know it was a joke but remember some scenes from X2 where we get to see more from Logan's past, and I believe that he is sure that the claws were the result of that experiment.

 

[jim_root_rules]

as far as he knows thts tru, but all he really remebers is getting off tht weapon x table his claws poppin out and him killin ever1, dosent mean thts wer he first began life

 

[neosonic]

thats right he was screaming looking at the claws.

he was in shock.

 

[MrSelfDestruct]

thats right he was screaming looking at the claws.

he was in shock.

That's because of the memory blocks.

 

[Boiiinng]

That's because of the memory blocks.

High five.

 

[cardslinger]

That still doesn't explain why Stryker said that he gave Wolverine claws. He wouldn't say that if Wolverine already had claws. Stryker even sais "The one thing I know better than anyone is my own work."
He would know if Wolverine already had claws.

 

[jim_root_rules]

he was probly actin liek he "made" wolverine, thts wot it could be put dwn to, a metaphor. and if it means havin bone claws i can ignore tht line

 

[Decay]

That still doesn't explain why Stryker said that he gave Wolverine claws. He wouldn't say that if Wolverine already had claws. Stryker even sais "The one thing I know better than anyone is my own work."
He would know if Wolverine already had claws.

Hmmm...that a good reason to think about the fact that Logan has a different history in the movies...

 

[sag002]

ya, i didnt like it that he had "natural" bone claws as part of his mutation. reeel stoopid.

 

[chaseter]

Bone claws are dumb...

 

[Decay]

No...they are not dumb, but it would be a strange mutation whatsoever.

 

[ang_hulk]

movie wolverine does not have bone claws,It was decided to keep them out since it was more realistic this way and brian didnt like the bone claw idea.if you look at his xray again you will see those are hoses that hold the claws when not extended,stryker ment it literally,also,look at the mini prop,you will see his claws not attached to his skeleton but inside those hoses.I think it was a good idea anyways.

 

[sag002]

keep the metal. bone claws suck

 

[vindrow]

Hopefully, they don't give him the bone claws in the film...to me that was the dumbest thing marvel did when Mags stripped him of his adamantium, It just seemed like they gave him the bone claws because they thought that he wasn't wolvie without claws.

 

[Fanticon]

sure why not....if they explain that they gave him metal claws because they noticed there was a particular area where it looked like he used to have bone claws that could retract but he must have shedded years ago...then it'd make sense...its the most realistic way to explain it...either that or just don't give him any.

 

[Boiiinng]

movie wolverine does not have bone claws,It was decided to keep them out since it was more realistic this way and brian didnt like the bone claw idea.if you look at his xray again you will see those are hoses that hold the claws when not extended,stryker ment it literally,also,look at the mini prop,you will see his claws not attached to his skeleton but inside those hoses.I think it was a good idea anyways.

More reasons to hate Bryan's "I wanted to keep it realistic" attitude. I'm glad he's gone.

 

[Iron Man™]

I like both really, but I wouldn't mind seeing the bone ones.