Bought/ Thought July 5th, 2007

Thor #1- I've been waiting for this ever since Ragnarok (no puns intended). I'm enjoying where JMS is taking this title and the characters of Donald Blake and Thor. I agree, it looks like it will make a good Fantasy-Drama and even seems to have the influence of Gaiman's "American Gods" with the whole: "Man does not exist because of god. God exists because of Man." theme (which I like and wanted to see translated to Thor). So far, it even looks like JMS already gave us a supporting character and successfully placed the weird next to the mundane, thus making this the best (and maybe even only) Fantasy title Marvel has (so no, 'Vertigo' hasn't completely won yet).
 
Cap is dead right now and Marvel seems to be intent on keeping it that way for at least a year, especially with Brubaker likely begging to make Winter Soldier fill the role eventually.
You've never read any of Captain America, but you always insist that Brubaker pushes the Winter Soldier to an extreme degree. It's true he likes the character a lot (I remember an interview where he said he was his favourite character to write), but Cap was always the star of his book while he was around (Bucky was only the star of one issue, #23, and was mostly a phantom). He's now currently the biggest of the three lead characters in the post-death story, but Brubaker has said there are no plans for a new Cap anytime soon.
 
Bendis also said we'd be suprised by the current Ronin.

I don't trust writers, especially at Marvel, to uphold what they say.

Not with Joey Q around.
 
You've never read any of Captain America, but you always insist that Brubaker pushes the Winter Soldier to an extreme degree. It's true he likes the character a lot (I remember an interview where he said he was his favourite character to write), but Cap was always the star of his book while he was around (Bucky was only the star of one issue, #23, and was mostly a phantom). He's now currently the biggest of the three lead characters in the post-death story, but Brubaker has said there are no plans for a new Cap anytime soon.

I haven't read the book but most writers would almost sell their souls to imprint some large mark on the legacy of a rich character, and having a new hero take up the mantle is one of those marks.

Besides, these days people are recommending I read WALKING DEAD now. I WAS saving for the Cap Omnibus. :p I won't have enough cash for both.

Capt. America is one of few Marvel heroes who could in theory work as a legacy hero. If you take some of the history literally, he already has been (during the 50's at least). The idea of Winter Soldier taking that mantle isn't a bad one, IMO, and that is coming from someone who has never read the book. True, DC did the exact same thing with Jason Todd/Red Hood as Bru did with Bucky, and even without having read stuff, I know Todd was handled much, much, MUCH worse. The ONLY way Marvel is going to convince anyone that Cap's death is being fantasized as permanent is to have someone else take up the mask. You can't publish a CA book without a Capt. America. Period. Eventually he will have to return or have an heir. In my mind, no one else makes more sense than Winter Soldier at this point.

I mean, Punisher tried, and it isn't in any way being treated seriously, not even by Fraction himself (which is why it works).

Of course Brubaker won't admit so much in an interview. Why would he kill his own plot points? Solicts have usually done that for him. I feel Bru likely pushes Winter Soldier because WS is a unique oppurtunity; an established character, but one gone from the stage so long that he is a blank slate, and Brubaker can run wild with him. At first the idea of resurrecting Bucky as a cyborg appalled the hell out of me, like some garish idea left over from the 90's, but with the Omnibus coming out eventually I have become interested to probably read it for myself, and then run the risk of having to run a retraction on past statements and having every single poster on the Marvel Forum laugh in my face and punish me for admitting being wrong about something.

Or I can play it safe and blow my cash on WALKING DEAD, a genre I am in no way interested in investing $60+ for. :cool:
 
This turned out to be one of the biggest weeks ever for me. Reviews from here on in are likely to be short...

Dynamo 5 #5 - Jesus, has Captain Dynamo never heard of a condom? Seriously. He's got to be the biggest man ****e in comics. Oh, and this book keeps getting better and better. The splash page with the kids surrounded by the cops was beautiful. This title's a gem. :up:

American Virgin #16 - This arc is a major improvement over the previous two. This title is becoming great again. I read on Becky Cloonan's blog that the direction this book is going to take soon will surprise a lot of readers. I'm glad I stayed on.

The Faker #1 - Holy damn, Mike Carey writes some good non-spandex stuff. Really, really solid debut. Jock's artwork definitely adds to the story, too. I'm intrigued by the premise and can't wait for issue #2.

The Loners #4 - Reading this makes me hate all the people not reading it. It's because of them this won't get picked up as an ongoing, and that's a damn shame. Cebulski's writing his heart out and Moline's artwork is a perfect fit. It's a Julie-centric issue and explains her..."blonde" personality of late. I don't want this one to end.

Uncanny X-Men #488 - By far the worst of Brubakers titles, and it's still enjoyable. In a perfect world, he would be filling Bendis' slot as Marvel's ace writer. In any event, Hepzibah (she's growing on me) begins to acclimate herself into the group, and it comes of as natural. What's most interesting to me is Warpath's character. I didn't read the last arc, but he seems very confident and much more mature than I remember. He's literally written as Storm's equal. It's a little jarring at first, but I have to give Brubaker credit for actually developing the characters he's using instead of just throwing them at evil mutants and hoping a story comes out of it. Xavier continues to do his own thing with Kurt tagging along. I read the Xavier scenes, and I wonder if Kurt is hanging around Xavier out of pity. I mean, no one likes the guy anymore. It must be awkward to not be welcome in the home you created. I think that's why he keeps himself busy. He's like a lonely, retired guy who keeps trying out new hobbies to pass the time. It's so weird.

Astounding Wolf-Man #2 - It took about 8-12 issues for Invincible to hit it's stride and look what it's become now. I'm hoping once Kirkman has the time to develop the world Gary lives in, the same thing will happen. I'll give him credit for not decompressing anything. Since the first issue, the reader has been thrown in the story at a break neck pace. It's nice to buy a superhero comic book, and get your money's worth. And the cameo by Art Rosenbaum answers the question of what universe this takes place in. ;)

Exterminators #19 - This book is schizophrenic. After a solid 6 issues of completely ignoring the main plotline, we're now right back in it. I have no idea what Simon Oliver's plans for the book are. Darick Robertson's pencils were a treat, though.

X-Men #188-193 - I picked up Carey's first arc and I'm impressed. It's actually pretty interesting stuff. It seems that while Morrison was doing weird for weird's sake, Carey's story is weird in nature; like it kind of forced itself to be unusual. I even dug Bachalo's pencils. Sometimes he can be distracting, but I think he actually adds to this story. I honestly wouldn't have wanted anyone else doing the art. The only complaint I have is the splintering of Rogue's team from the rest of the X-Men. I felt like I was reading X-Treme X-Men all over again. I enjoyed this enough to decide to continue picking this title up, although I'm not too thrilled about Ramos' contributions.

I still have Daredevil: Battlin' Jack Murdock #2, Marvel Zombies vs. Army of Darkness #5, and Black Diamond #2 to go...
 
The more I read photojones2's posts, the more I see we probably have simular tastes in comics. :cwink:
 
The more I read photojones2's posts, the more I see we probably have simular tastes in comics. :cwink:

Was it a coincidence you posted that when you did, or did you really read my post above it and reply within a minute? If so, teach me your ways.
 
Was it a coincidence you posted that when you did, or did you really read my post above it and reply within a minute? If so, teach me your ways.

Read, and posted. And also have been reading your reviews closer since we've seemed to discuss things more often at Hype.

I really do read the reviews of others besides myself here. :D
 
Daredevil: Battlin' Jack Murdock #2 - I'll admit, the premise sounds lame. It's a story about a superhero's dad. Lame City. But for anyone who didn't give it a chance: you're missing out on a really amazing book. I'm in awe over how well written and incredibly well drawn this is. This new guy, Carmine Di Giandomenico is a talent. I don't know where he came from, or what his next project is, but I'll buy it. He's like a hybrid of Stefano Casselli and French artist Luc Jacamon. It truely is great work.

And the story is so wonderfully written. Jack Murdock is such a complex character. He's not a good person. He's not a bad one, though either. He's just...human. He makes stupid mistakes and sometimes realizes it, and sometimes doesn't. Sometimes he tries to do the right thing, and sometimes he can't be bothered by it. I really believe that Carmine and Zeb Wells have recreated him to be one of the most multi-dimensional characters I've ever read in a Marvel comic. And it's done with such care and subtlety. It's like I'm reading a true story. I'm that impressed with this book.

Most people's minds were made up when the book was announced, so I won't even bother recommending it. All I can say is: You missed out.
 
Dread, you don't read Captain America? FOR SHAME.

Those who read DMZ: Anyone know when vol.3 is due out?
 
Both Marvel and DC get a lot of drama out of "shattering" longtime character friendships or romances, but I can't remember said actions ever ADDING anything worthwhile to those characters involved.
Good point. DC just tore apart Batman, Wonder Woman, and Superman's friendship before Infinite Crisis, and then by JLA #0 it was like nothing ever happened. Their relationship was exactly the same as it had always been. It made all of the strife and turmoil they went through with Wonder Woman being a murderer and Batman calling Superman an uninspirational ***** and Superman tacitly approving of Batman's mindwipe seem utterly inconsequential. I hope, at the very least, things between Cap, Thor, and Iron Man remain at least a little strained whenever all three of them are together again.
 
It going to a looooong time before Steve, Tony and Thor are all in the same room together.
 
Probably. By that time they'll probably have conjured up some stupid way for Thor to be on Tony's side, reversing the historical norm, too.
 
Probably. By that time they'll probably have conjured up some stupid way for Thor to be on Tony's side, reversing the historical norm, too.

I never really saw Thor as being staunchly supportive of either one. Yes, he has a great respect for both men (perhaps for Steve more than Tony), but I never saw Thor as being one to blindly follow any man's lead like say, Hercules would.
 
Good point. DC just tore apart Batman, Wonder Woman, and Superman's friendship before Infinite Crisis, and then by JLA #0 it was like nothing ever happened. Their relationship was exactly the same as it had always been. It made all of the strife and turmoil they went through with Wonder Woman being a murderer and Batman calling Superman an uninspirational ***** and Superman tacitly approving of Batman's mindwipe seem utterly inconsequential. I hope, at the very least, things between Cap, Thor, and Iron Man remain at least a little strained whenever all three of them are together again.

They did it with Batman and Zatanna too, and there was so much room for awesomeness there, but no one even touched upon the tension until Dini did just now, and that was to make them all BFF!
 
Yeah, Bats went from being constantly suspicious of Zatanna to "zomg Zatanna almost died I must love her 4evarrrrr!!!" I love Dini's Detective Comics, but that issue was definitely not his best.
I never really saw Thor as being staunchly supportive of either one. Yes, he has a great respect for both men (perhaps for Steve more than Tony), but I never saw Thor as being one to blindly follow any man's lead like say, Hercules would.
He didn't blindly follow Steve's lead. The last time Cap and Iron Man were at each other's throats, when Steve was ousted from the government and acting as the Captain and Tony was wanted for his crimes in the Armor Wars, Thor was torn between his loyalty to each of them and didn't know who to side with. He and Cap were attacked by Set's forces and Cap lifted Mjolnir, proving to Thor that Cap was of the highest moral integrity. Thor has since treated Cap as basically the most honorable human being ever.
 
Marvel Zombies vs. Army of Darkness #5
A fun end to a fun miniseries. There really isn't much else to say.

Uncanny X-Men #488
It was good but didn't advance the plot very much. I'm still interested though. The Endangered Species story was good too, but I don't know who those people at the end were.
 
He didn't blindly follow Steve's lead. The last time Cap and Iron Man were at each other's throats, when Steve was ousted from the government and acting as the Captain and Tony was wanted for his crimes in the Armor Wars, Thor was torn between his loyalty to each of them and didn't know who to side with. He and Cap were attacked by Set's forces and Cap lifted Mjolnir, proving to Thor that Cap was of the highest moral integrity. Thor has since treated Cap as basically the most honorable human being ever.

I...know. I mentioned that Thor wouldn't blindly follow anyone.
 
Yeah, but I was saying he is staunchly supportive of Cap because of that incident. Before, sure, his respect for each was about even. But after Thor #390, he was more on Cap's side, I think.
 
Yeah, but I was saying he is staunchly supportive of Cap because of that incident. Before, sure, his respect for each was about even. But after Thor #390, he was more on Cap's side, I think.

What I'm saying is that there are no sides as far as Thor's concerned. Thor may repsect Steve more than any other mortal, but he's not on "his side". He's on the side of right. If Cap stepped out of line, Thor's not going to follow suit.
 
Ms. Marvel #17

This is one of the better books Marvel puts out. There's less of a reliance on overly long story arcs, there's a good balance between story and action, and imo there's yet to have been a single bad issue.

That being said this issue wasn't one of the stronger ones. While I liked the splintering of AIM, and am interested in the mystery of who the heck this Wagner creep really is, the rest of the issue just felt like one big tease.

There was no real showdown with MODOK he sort of just went away, the revelation of the traitor was a let down since it was the most likely candidate and we didn't really get any further in the mystery of what is up with the (aliens?) in Carol's body. All we know is that she knows something is wrong.

And whatever happened to Arana? I liked her as an addition to the supporting cast and now she's sort of dropped off the radar.

Still, this book was a fun read regardless.

3/5

Detective Comics #834

Another bit of a letdown. It was a good solid issue and all, it hit all the marks, Joker was perfect (I especially liked that little peek into his head when Batman investigates his shower: the heart over the Harley Quinn figure was particularly amusing) but other than that it was largely ho-hum.

Joker did what he always does and Batman did what he always does. Nothing new but sometimes there's no particularly wrong with using an established model.

3/5
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,268
Messages
22,076,658
Members
45,876
Latest member
Crazygamer3011
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"