Cap needs to have super powers, like Ultimate Cap or even more.
First off, if Cap is going to be as strong as a powerlifter (for the "press 800 lbs" or 1075 lbs or whatever), he would need to be built like one. You can't be 6'2" and 220 lbs (or whatever his stats are) and bench 1000 lbs. You need to weight 300 lbs if you want to have enough muscle to do that. And at that weight, good luck having any endurance.
However Cap was first written needs to be thrown out. He should be superhuman. A human a the pinnacle of perfection would still get tired after fighting 20 guys for 5 minutes. Go watch a UFC fight and see how even the best conditioned guys are winded if they go all out for a round agianst ONE guy. They have to pace themselves or they gas. I can buy the fittest guy in the world going all out for 5 minutes against one guy, but not a whole pack of bad guys.
.
Cap needs to have super powers, like Ultimate Cap or even more.
First off, if Cap is going to be as strong as a powerlifter (for the "press 800 lbs" or 1075 lbs or whatever), he would need to be built like one. You can't be 6'2" and 220 lbs (or whatever his stats are) and bench 1000 lbs. You need to weight 300 lbs if you want to have enough muscle to do that. And at that weight, good luck having any endurance.
However Cap was first written needs to be thrown out. He should be superhuman. A human a the pinnacle of perfection would still get tired after fighting 20 guys for 5 minutes. Go watch a UFC fight and see how even the best conditioned guys are winded if they go all out for a round agianst ONE guy. They have to pace themselves or they gas. I can buy the fittest guy in the world going all out for 5 minutes against one guy, but not a whole pack of bad guys.
Sure we suspend disbelief in comics all the time. So let's just suspend it more and make him super-strong. The bottom line is that Spider-Man (lift 10 tons) shouldn't really be stronger than Cap.
Cap needs to have super powers, like Ultimate Cap or even more.
First off, if Cap is going to be as strong as a powerlifter (for the "press 800 lbs" or 1075 lbs or whatever), he would need to be built like one. You can't be 6'2" and 220 lbs (or whatever his stats are) and bench 1000 lbs. You need to weight 300 lbs if you want to have enough muscle to do that. And at that weight, good luck having any endurance.
However Cap was first written needs to be thrown out. He should be superhuman. A human a the pinnacle of perfection would still get tired after fighting 20 guys for 5 minutes. Go watch a UFC fight and see how even the best conditioned guys are winded if they go all out for a round agianst ONE guy. They have to pace themselves or they gas. I can buy the fittest guy in the world going all out for 5 minutes against one guy, but not a whole pack of bad guys.
Sure we suspend disbelief in comics all the time. So let's just suspend it more and make him super-strong. The bottom line is that Spider-Man (lift 10 tons) shouldn't really be stronger than Cap.
Something to consider is that we don't know what the potential "peak" of human performance is in any particular field. Should it be assumed that a person can't be faster than Usain Bolt, or that 1000 pounds is the most a man can bench press? The fact that we honestly don't know, coupled with the fact that Captain America is a sci-fi / fantasy story give rise to the possibility of him having abilities that we normal folks would likely consider to be "super human." Suppose that the peak of human performance, in terms of all manner of bodily strength means he could toss a car if necessary?
If he truly is at the peak of human conditioning, then it's not far fetched that he can exceed the records held by the world's greatest athletes. First of all, seeing how far athletics have come in the last century it seems foolish to assume that the records currently held are the true peak of human conditioning. Secondly, Captain America is at the peak of ALL forms of muscle strength, not just a few like most athletes are, and since they all work together it means even more strength to each, as mentioned in a previous post. And lastly, he is at the peak of human endurance. Usain Bolt may be a ridiculously fast sprinter, but how would he hold up running that speed for an hour? Captain America should be able to do it, and still have plenty of strength leftover to kicks some bad guy ass.
How about he just be as strong as he needs to be to accomplish whatever task it is they come up with and we call it a day?


Just to get it out of the way early:
IT'S OVER NINE THOUSAAAAAAAAAAND!
I think that the potential locked inside the human body is SUPERHUMAN. Look at old ladies that lift cars to save loved ones...everyone's heard about the huge adrenaline boost s the body can produce in times of stress.
So is it really that crazy to think that the "perfect human" would also be able to tap into some AMAZING levels of power when his adrenaline kicks in?