In fairness it was the dark nature of the character that made him famous. It started with Miller in the 80's and continued with Ann Nocenti and the rest. Nocenti did a solid job balancing out the dark and the swashbuckling at times which is why I hold that run in high regard. Karl Kesel did a critically praised run with Cary Nord in the mid 90's before the MK relaunch that was very light and noir-ish in tone.
Exactly, I mean when DD was in its dark, noir phase it was GREAT stuff. Its just that it became a little too depressing and ran a little long. What Waid's doing is a breath of fresh air, i wouldnt mind a year or two of stories like this until Matt Murdock's life inevitably turns to s*** again.
It's definately been a good read but I miss the darker feel. The only Daredevil I've read was Smith's first arc and then from Bendis on, so that's all I know. Him in a lighthearted role just feels wrong for me.
And I liked how dark and depressing the book got, and I wish it could have kept going.
I read a few '80s Daredevil comics when I was younger. One in particular that I remember featured Daredevil fighting cockroaches.