The Original Bamfer
Big, Bald and Beautiful
- Joined
- Feb 16, 2003
- Messages
- 42,637
- Reaction score
- 508
- Points
- 73
It's simple, really.
There are some minor errors and contradictions in the continuity, no greater in the X-Men film series than in any other expansive series of films. Star Wars has continuity errors and contradictions just as big, if not bigger, than anything found in the X-Men films.
Certain pieces of dialogue from X-Men, like "15 years" (in regards to Logan and Stryker), Xavier and Magneto meeting at 17, and a couple things from X-Men: The Last Stand and X-Men Origins: Wolverine, like Xavier walking when recruiting Jean Grey, or recruiting Cyclops, Emma Frost, and the other students, respectively, and other minor things like various versions of Emma Frost, Beast, or Bolivar Trask, are simple errors. They don't break a timeline, they are simply things that people had better ideas about later on down the line.
The continuity isn't broken. It's not irreparable. It doesn't even need to be repaired in the first place. It is what it is.
Just accept that a couple small scenes, and a couple pieces of dialogue don't line up, and the movies flow together just fine.
For X-Maniac, wanting a timeline, it's simple:
X-Men: First Class (1963) -> X-Men Origins: Wolverine (1973-1979, or 1975-1981) -> X-Men (2012) -> X2 (2012) -> X-Men: The Last Stand (2013)* -> The Wolverine (2014) -> X-Men: Days Of Future Past (2023-new 1973)
*Marked X-Men 3 in 2013 to account for the new President from X2. Timing would apply to the real world, as an election would be held in 2012, with a new President taking oath in 2013. Plus, with Alkali Lake being all snowy in X2, and not so snowy in X-Men 3, you could say that X2 takes place in winter of 2012, with X-Men 3 taking place in spring or summer of 2013.
I guess that's why their doing DoFP - to fix these things. And they've said that's their intention. It doesn't bother me in my continuity because I disclude certain films. 'Nothing wrong with that.
I should note that FC takes place in 1962.