I always hear about this potential third party. Who exactly is going to make up the core of it? The so-called independents, who aren't as independent as they lead us to think? Libertarians? Angry Dems and GOPers looking to stick it to their former parties?
The way I see it, this people will bring the same attitudes and baggage that the current parties already have.
I'm not saying a true third party is a bad thing. But I'm not convinced that it's a great thing, either.
Probably a third of the country, at least, fall into the category of social liberal and fiscally conservative. Progressive on social issues, but responsible with spending. Why? Because that's how they live their lives anyway.
Arguably, the Libertarian party is probably the best 3rd party whose ideals represent that.
But people don't go to a third party, any third party, typically for 1 of 3 main reasons:
1) The spoiler effect: They're too afraid to leave their current party because the evil other side will gain power by default and take over. Can't throw your vote away like that!
2) Lack of power: What's the point of going to a 3rd party if they're so small. It's not like they can really do anything.
3) Ignorance: They don't even know the 3rd party is out there. Or they do, but haven't done the research to realize how well it might fit with their beliefs.
What they fail to understand is:
1) Voting for someone you don't really believe in just because it's the lesser of two evils is still throwing your vote away.
2) If everyone who wanted to join the 3rd party but was afraid to do so, actually did so, we'd suddenly have a viable 3rd party in this country.
3) It's hard to be aware of a 3rd party if the game is, at least somewhat, geared towards keeping the Big Two in everyone's mind. Partly because the Big Two have the power to do so, and partly for the first two reasons.