BoredGuy
Never Did a Popular Thing
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2008
- Messages
- 11,041
- Reaction score
- 4,385
- Points
- 103
Aside from the oft stated fact that the US Government would most probably not happily accept The Winter Soldier, a wanted political murderer for decades brainwashed or not, as the next Cap the thematic point of the scene was passing the legacy onto a new generation.
Giving Bucky the mantle of the MCU's lead hero, more or less, isn't an appropriate form of redemption because quite frankly it sends out the wrong message. The message that you can commit the worst acts and atrocities and be granted a prize as a sign of forgiveness is dunderheaded.
But you make it sound as though Bucky willingly murdered all those people, ignoring the whole brainwashed aspect. And it's not a prize, it's a role in which he'd have to prove himself to find true redemption. Plus, it's not the government's decision who is Captain America.
Also, in the comics, Bucky's identity as Cap was kept somewhat under wraps, as was the fact that he was the Winter Soldier. Granted, in the MCU it's known that Bucky Barnes was the Winter Soldier. But the Avengers could still keep that secret, and everyone would assume Steve Rogers was still the Captain (something they definitely can't do with Sam).The Public doesn't know he time traveled to go live out his life and came back old.
Sam's just too vanilla, imo, and has his own, uncomprimised hero identity. Falcon can lead the Avengers, that's fine. Why would he need to dress up as Cap to earn respect?
Also, in the comics, Bucky's identity as Cap was kept somewhat under wraps, as was the fact that he was the Winter Soldier. Granted, in the MCU it's known that Bucky Barnes was the Winter Soldier. But the Avengers could still keep that secret, and everyone would assume Steve Rogers was still the Captain (something they definitely can't do with Sam).The Public doesn't know he time traveled to go live out his life and came back old.
Sam's just too vanilla, imo, and has his own, uncomprimised hero identity. Falcon can lead the Avengers, that's fine. Why would he need to dress up as Cap to earn respect?