I always preferred 2-4 to 1. 1 was boring as **** and while 3 and 4 aren't actually good or even have much to do with the first 2 they are still pretty rad. The rest sucked.
I gotta say though, I'm kinda mixed on Hellraiser as a whole. I watched Silent Hill Revelations like a week ago and posted on my Facebook this "Silent Hill Revelations, a movie that wants to be a Hellraiser movie but just never quite figures out how. Kinda like an Hellraiser movie." Meaning that, I've always felt that these movies shy away from what they should be in the first place. A Hellraiser movie should be a mix of Silent Hill, Hostel and Saw in one. There should be lots of gore, crazy Hell torture going on, tortured souls everywhere. And most of all, more focus on the ****ing cenobites!
You know what I don't get when discussing movies. The "it SHOULD have been THAT" attitude. It's one thing to say that you'd like to see a movie like you describe, another one to fault a movie for being something which isn't in line with your own daydreams about possible movies. No,
Hellraiser doesn't have to be a mix of
Silent Hill,
Hostel and
Saw. If you'd like to see a movie which is a mix of
Silent Hill,
Hostel and
Saw, with sprays of
Hellraiser, that's fine - but that's also a whole diff'rent story!
I strongly disagree about the first one being boring (but that's, of course, a matter of taste). It's a breath of fresh air (if you can say that of a movie which was made over twenty years ago). I expected to see a movie about people opening a box and being tortured, and instead got a terrific tale of lust, murder, the crave for blood: the animalistic, demonic side of being human. A modern and skewed take on the romantic Gothic horror tales. Great atmosphere, wonderful writing, fantastic make-up effects. I LOVE it. The focus not being on the Cenobites makes it even better: not knowing too much about the box, the world of the Cenobites, gives these fantastic happenings a mythic aura, which I really enjoy. The world behind our world. Very mysterious, yet it can affect our lives. It's very unconventional, and DAMN, it delivers. Uncle Frank, by the way, was a TERRIFIC character (and I'm glad they didn't tinker with him too much in subsequent movies).
Never cared about the sequels, though. The second one has some nice ideas, but that's about it. It doesn't hold a candle to the original.
There should be more movies like this, but... you know... not LIKE this (otherwise it'd end up being a bland rehash of the movie).
