Hollywood reporter review
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr/reviews/review_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1003019160
Hollywoodland
By Michael Rechtshaffen
Bottom line: This noir take on George Reeves' death has its high points but doesn't quite fly.
The prospect of recasting the 1959 death of TV's "Superman," George Reeves, as a noir murder mystery holds an undeniably intriguing allure, but despite some terrific performances and finely detailed period touches, "Hollywoodland" ultimately falls short of reaching the pleasingly pulpy heights of an "L.A. Confidential" or a "Chinatown" despite those obvious aspirations.
First-time feature director Allen Coulter, whose extensive TV credits include multiple episodes of "The Sopranos" and "Sex and the City," effectively soaks up the tainted atmosphere provided by newcomer Paul Bernbaum's script, but there is a stifling lethargy hanging over the production that prevents it from ever taking on an organic life of its own.
With its release scheduled to follow a week after its Aug. 31 premiere at the Venice Film Festival, the Focus Features film will get an early head start out of the awards-season gate and a savvy marketing push, combined with the enticing subject matter, could yield some lofty business.
Known at one point as "Truth, Justice and the American Way," the picture finds a way into Reeves' life and disturbing demise through the investigation conducted by Louis Simo (Adrien Brody), a scrappy, low-rent private detective hired by Reeves' mother (Lois Smith), who refuses to accept that his death was a suicide.
As Simo plunges himself into the case, Reeves' life and times unravel in a series of alternating flashbacks, with a heavier Ben Affleck doing the honors.
Despite landing a role in no less than "Gone With the Wind" immediately after landing his first studio contract, Reeves is just another struggling actor at the outset of the 1950s, when television and a certain caped superhero first beckon.
Before the series begins to air, his private life also is looking pretty rosy as he embarks on a live-in affair with the older Toni Mannix (Diane Lane), whose husband, Eddie (Bob Hoskins), happens to be GM of MGM, not to mention an ex-mobster from New Jersey who hasn't exactly left his past ways behind.
For a while George is content being a kept boy, but by the time "The Adventures of Superman" runs its illustrious course, he has dumped Toni for the much younger Leonore Lemmon (Robin Tunney), a New York socialite and budding starlet. A year later, at age 45, he was found dead in his bedroom, succumbing to a single gunshot wound.
As Simo proceeds to connect the dots, "Rashomon"-style, he whittles down the motives to three possible scenarios: Reeves' death was a suicide, he was shot by Lemmon, or he was "taken care of" by Eddie Mannix in retaliation for hurting his wife.
Of course, nobody will ever know for sure, but all the guesswork makes for a compelling scenario. It's in the execution that "Hollywoodland" stumbles.
All that back-and-forth between Brody's investigation and the Affleck flashbacks doesn't always make for smooth transitioning, and though a hard-working Affleck gained 20 pounds for the role, he still doesn't have that convincing Reeves heft.
There are standout moments, though, that hint at a greater potential, including a personal appearance made by Reeves in front of a group of kiddie fans. One is brandishing what looks disturbingly like a real gun and is keen on finding out if bullets will actually bounce off of him.
But other aspects of "Hollywoodland" don't work, including the decision to digitally put Affleck's Reeves in a scene opposite Burt Lancaster during a screening of "From Here to Eternity," which comes across as a cute but distracting "Forrest Gump" novelty.
There certainly is no shortage of keeper performances, from Brody's hustling gumshoe to Lane doing her best Norma Desmond to Hoskins' casually menacing studio exec. And the fading luster of production designer of Leslie McDonald's declining Hollywood is evocatively matched by Jonathan Freeman's cinematography and costume designer Julie Weiss' period perfect wardrobe.
Hollywoodland
Focus Features
A Focus Features and Miramax Films presentation of a Back Lot Pictures production
Credits:
Director: Allen Coulter
Screenwriter: Paul Bernbaum
Producer: Glenn Williamson
Executive producers: Jake Myers, J. Miles Dale, Joe Pichirallo
Director of photography: Jonathan Freeman
Production designer: Leslie McDonald
Editor: Michael Berenbaum
Costume designer: Julie Weiss
Music: Marcelo Zarvos
Cast:
Louis Simo: Adrien Brody
Toni Mannix: Diane Lane
George Reeves: Ben Affleck
Edgar Mannix: Bob Hoskins
Helen Bessolo: Lois Smith
Leonore Lemmon: Robin Tunney
Art Weissman: Jeffrey DeMunn
Howard Strickling: Joe Spano
MPAA rating R
Running time -- 126 minutes