You were deducted because Karea changed the URLs to the picture after I told him not to. After the judges had already each submitted their scores for the ORIGINAL picture based on the ORIGINAL PICTURE. Karea then changed the URL to delete the original picture all together, despite asking me if it was ok and my responding "No, its already been judged."
We didn't judge the new picture at all. I didn't even see the new picture until I posted the scores and realized Karea changed the URL.
Thats not why. You lost points because it was ugly as hell. The black background was unpleasant on the eyes. The miscast was just my musings.