This is strictly my opinion, I'm not writing it to annoy or convince anyone to agree with me.
I pretty much hated the film. The direction is beyond atrocious, it's tedious and feels like it was 6 hours long and most of the songs were mediocre. Plus the two leads are not good enough singers. Jackman's acting performance is fine but his voice leaves a lot to be desired, it is flat out not strong enough to endure the songs or live singing. Russell Crowe's singing is ear bleedingly awful. I could not believe my ears, especially durring his two big solo performances. I shudder even thinking about it.
The good things about the movie are few. Hathaway is ridiculously brilliant, her rendition of "I Dreamed a Dream" is one of my favorite things of 2012. Redmayne sings beautifully and Seyfried's voice is nice, it's thin but pleasant enough. I was fine with everyone's singing expect Baron Cohen, Bonham Carter, Jackman and especially Crowe's.
I was pretty meserable but the audience applauded it.
Rating 4/10
Happy New Year everybody. Good wishes and all that.