SpideyInATree said:
Personally, I think that the boys at Marvel are trying desperately to catch new readers from the movie crowd. And it pisses me off that they have to change things around in the comics to cater to people who haven't been reading these stories for decades.
Sorry this is so long. Tried to shorten it but sure there will be one word or sentence replies anyway. Oh well.
Perhaps I'm off and have no basis for saying this seeing as I'm new to the comic fandom but not new to the character of Spider-man (cartoons, games, movies, and games over the years since I was really young) but I have to say the following.
It's kind of a damn if you do and a damn if you don't type of situation. I don't think anyone disagrees that in general the comic buying community is shrinking has been for a long time. I have to say that when I started getting into things a few months ago I was surprised at the actual number issues sold, especially the big names like Spider-man, X-men, Batman, and Superman. I had the misinformed opinion that they sold several hundred thousands or millions. I'm sure that the lowering numbers over the years isn't lost at all on DC and Marvel.
It only makes sense that they would try to take advantage of the success of the films in the hopes of trying to bring in new readers. You say that is what the Ultimate universe is for. I counter that by bringing attnetion that the movies are not based on the Ultimate universe but the 616 universe. As a result readers are going to take notice of that first.
While I liked The Other and Spidey's new powers I do think those in charge need to be replaced or givne a swift kick in the throat in order for them to wake up.
How do you advance a character but at the same time try to get back to his roots? You should either just continue advancing him. WHich is what Stan Lee and the others were doing. Which is naturally him getting married and having children and perhaps his children gain his powers or someone else gets the powers and the name is passed or perhaps he just gets older. Or you just turn back the time and start over while trying to keep with continuity. I don't think you can do both at the same time as Marvel seems to want to do.
I think the "problem" with Spider-man at the moment is as much a fault of the editors and writers as it is of the fans themselves. I know many aren't going to agree but think about it for a moment. They want the character to change and evolve as all characters have to unless they exist in a timeless bubble which Spidey does not. Which is why I think the supporting cast ended up where it did. It was just a natural progression of storytelling. Some fans, perhaps the more vocal or majority, I'm not really sure, seem very resistance to change. Maybe not all changes but some and have a different idea how Spidey should be handled. Not wanting to piss off these fans because they know they aren't getting a lot of new readers as each year passes they give in and undo changes they want to do and when they try to do more changes again the backlash takes place. Which brings us to the point we are at now I think.
I don't think problems appeared over night or even recently but have been there all along in the form of the conflict with Marvel itself with it's writers/editors and the fans themselves.
I think the only way things are really going to get better, and that will depend how you look at it, is if Marvel finally says enough is enough and stops listening to fans.Then over night either go one way or the other and stick with it.
Either they say enough and advance Peter by letting him age, get on with his life, have kids and continue to be Spider-man and take the risk of losing readers, losing the "everyman" feel and risk him not being their flagship character.
Or they say screw it all and work some magic by deaging Peter and those in his life to a point where he's back in high school an everyone from Norman to Aunt May have lives that reflect this new life where the rest of the Marvel communtiy continues on but notes that changes have taken place to certain areas in the MU and they are changed as a result. A mini-Crisis (ala DC).
Until that happens I don't think things are going to change. Marvel will continue to try "fix" things to make fans happy. But fans won't be happy, but for a while, because Marvel will try to evolove the character again but some fans won't want that.
It's like living in the woods and loving it and wanting some piece and quiet from the big city. You want the birds to stop chirpping but you don't want to kill or drive the birds away. So what do you do? Either kill the birds and drive them away or let them stay or leave the woods all together and no one wants the last option or either of the other two it seems.