Infinity9999x
Avenger
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2005
- Messages
- 12,107
- Reaction score
- 638
- Points
- 103
I think personality traits don't matter, because just having those makes the character interchangeable, so I think you saying she has none of the traits of the character isn't true. But I think she does have the personality, but with certain aspects more focused on than others.
I enjoyed BF and B&R. The world of Burton maybe, but that world was reset with Schumacher's. I don't think there was a personality change. Burton's had an over the top vibe, moreso BR, to me. I think Schumacher's continues that.
I think the characterization is there, with the personality traits, but with different aspects focused on. It's not about falling in love with the character to me. I've never even particularly liked any version of MJ. But that doesn't mean that I think Raimi didn't do the character. The characterization, personality traits and backstory are there, to me. I think the character wasn't written poorly. MJ had a character in the trilogy, so she was developed to me. I think she had more character development in SM1, than May, Ned, Michelle, Flash and Liz in HC altogether.
I mean, if you think personality traits don’t matter, I don’t know what to tell you. Without personality, there is no character. You’re essentially saying as long as the backstory is there, the character can act however they please, and I think you’ll find most people wouldn’t agree with you. If Spider-Man has the Uncle Ben backstory, but brutally kills all his criminals and acts like a hardened war vet, that’s fine, because personality doesn’t matter?
If that works for you, cool. That just won’t ever work for me.